Little Italy's Pizza

502 N Walnut St, Mt Carmel
(618) 262-4121

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rebekah Leach

We love the breadsticks, pizza, and Stromboli’s. Beef manhattan is pretty good too. 😋

Andrew Mullins

Always getting my daughter breadsticks & cheese off the food truck in Olney

Melanie Rees

I noticed the truck here in Olney. It was selling an assortment of menu items. The guy said call the store before 2pm and you can place an order. That way you’d know he had the thing you want. I called to place an order. Turns out they charge a delivery fee when doing it this way. It was an extra $4 charge. I’d rather just take my chances and not call ahead.

Jesse Schwartz

amazing place! great food, great people! definitely recommend!!!

Cynthia McFarland

Staff was nice and the food delicious!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Grim

I have just stomached all I could of the 6” Chicken Parmesean sandwich. This sandwich consisted of plain, seemingly unseasoned chicken breast, perhaps some mozzarella cheese (I could not discern any actual cheese taste or texture), two finger-sized peppers that I was not informed of prior to purchase, and some type of bread slathered in pasta sauce.

If I recall correctly, the paper menu, which lacked prices as far as I could tell lest I had temporarily fallen selectively blind, listed the bread as Italian. I could not confirm or deny that claim as this sandwich seems to have been dropped into a vat of red sauce before it was wrapped in tinfoil and given to me in exchange for real, human money that I worked for and was using to sustain myself. There is more sauce OUTSIDE the sandwich than betwixt the pieces of sopping, saucy bread. Nowhere on the menu does it warn the customer that what you will actually be buying is a sandwich encased in an orb of red, Italian goo. If the intention was to mask the inclusion of the dryest, most bland, hockey-puck-esque piece of chicken on God’s green Earth, this sandwich failed. I only choked down the first half of the sandwich because I am a firm believer in not wasting food, but this sandwich calls into question the very definition of “food”. I would not give this to my dog. Granted, I do not currently own a dog and would not give any of the spices in an average pizza sauce to a dog if I did own one, but this sandwich speaks for itself. At least, I fear it might start to.

The only positive aspect about this sandwich is that my hunger-fueled hubris was limited by this sandwich only being available in 6” portions, meaning I will be using less gasoline to rid myself of this cursed “food” item.

I also ordered the mozzarella sticks and some cheese sauce and was surprised when my meal total came to over $20, as I was expecting an appetizer-sized portion of cheese sticks dipped in breadcrumbs and then fried to go along with my “sandwich”.

I was surprised when I found a pizza-sized, sectioned circle of bread and cheese in my ownership, however this time the surprise was pleasant as I am a cheese enthusiast of sorts. This would almost make up for the lack of cheese in my atrocity of a “sandwich”, but upon consumption the bread feels as if it has sat out too long and the food item as a whole was practically absent of ANY flavor, even with the assistance of the almost-equally-flavorless cheese sauce. This food item, at least, I will be able to stomach with another meal or two once I have properly seasoned it.

The restaurant looked fine and the person working register was nice though.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Jessica Grieshop

The food was delicious especially the ribs! However the place could benefit from adding a kid's menu for if families aren't ordering pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

jefcyn67

Always good

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mary Mayberry

We are from Chicago in town to visit sick aunt. Stopped here to eat. Pizza was delicious. Best tasting pizza ever

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Melinda Arena

It puts the lotion on it's skin or it gets the hose again!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kelly Rymer

Good food! Love the Italian Sub.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

John Camacho

Great Italian Beef. ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeff Ingram

The Chicago style deep dish pizza was good, probably the best Chicago style pizza south of Chicago.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lasagna

Traci Yarber

Pasta and sauce had to much water in the plate as if they didn't let the pasta drain. Not much flavor.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Daryl

Nothing special. I ordered one of the lunch specials last year, and it was a joke. It really wasn't a good deal for the money. My lasagna looked like it had been rolled around a couple of times. It was a rinky dink little slice. Not really the bargain or quality that lead you to believe. There's better pizza in town at better prices.

Loading...