Sugar Mama Bakery (Downtown Bloomington)

109 W Jefferson St, Bloomington
(309) 386-1018

Recent Reviews

J Johnson

Ordered a coconut cake. My wife loved it!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Amanda Calhoun

It’s was amazing and exactly what I wanted!! Thank you so much!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Olivia H.

Absolutely unreal!!! I will 10000% order a cake from them again. The service was so easy to work with and the bakers were so kind. The cake was the best cake I have ever had. Lemon cake with raspberry filling.

Nupur Kumari

All time favorite ❤️

Molly T.

Have been getting cupcakes here and they always get rave reviews. Salted Carmel and red velvet are great. Love that they offer GF and vegan as well.

Raquel Williams

We've been getting our birthday cakes here for the past 4 years and Sugar Mama always delivers the best cakes every time! So much beautiful detail and the cakes are delicious <3

Laura L.

We just stopped I to this bakery and watched as they turned away a blind woman with a seeing eye dog. She explained that the dog was a service dog and she needed it and they told her they didn't care and made her leave the bakery. Literally refused service to a blind woman. There food might be good but with bigoted behavior such as that we won't be back.

O B.

walked in...and then walked out...hardly anything on display, super expensive, tiny sizes, looks like they aspire to be a custom pastry/cupcake boutique and not a walk in bakery. I don't see this staying afloat. Walked over to Ivy Lane bakery for my fix

Patrycja McCoy

We have been Sugar Mama customers for over 4 years. Although we recently had a first time issue with the bakery, they made up for it. The cakes are delicious and always receive compliments at our events.

Halo Sane

The atmosphere is so peaceful. Fair prices, very kind employees. I got an espresso latte and a cinnamon roll (which was absolutely delicious). My partner and I were even given 2 forks to share it. Visit if you can!

Liv Durica

Got cupcakes from here for my gfs birthday party and they were AMAZING. They always have tasty and creative flavors here :)

Nick Pate

They did a custom cake for my wife's 40th based on a terrible description and idea from me, and knocked it out of the park! Looked great and tasted even better!

Kelley Karis

Broccoli cake was amazing. They continue to impress for any cake request I've had

Kailee

I ordered a last minute heart-shaped cake for my engagement celebration on 4/18 for 4/22. The person I spoke with on the phone was very kind and directed me to the email to submit my custom order request. I was met with a quick response regarding cake details and within the hour, my request was accepted, deposit was paid for, and the pickup details were sent over. This was my first time visiting the bakery and it was absolutely adorable! Pickup was quick and easy, and my cake turned out exactly how I envisioned it! Working with this bakery was such a pleasure and I am very happy with the outcome of our cake! However, I did knock down one star due to lack of taste in the buttercream frosting. We chose vanilla, and I really didn’t get much of that; it was very much just a sugary taste without the traditional buttercream flavor. Although, the cake itself was delicious and moist! Overall, I would order from here again ?

Ellen D.

I ordered a birthday cake and was charged $70. The cake was good, but there lacked any decoration. Let's just say I was underwhelmed. A grocery store would have done a better job for less than $30 This place is not worth the money. I should have gone to Janet's

Load More

Sugar Mama Bakery (Downtown Bloomington)

109 W Jefferson St, Bloomington, IL 61701
(309) 386-1018