Big fan of sandwich Saturdays. The mafalda bread, mortadella and pesto sandwich last week was so good. Hoping it'll be back again. Also bought a few slices of the tres leches cake with sandwiches this weekend and everyone enjoyed them.
Ana G.
Palermo's Bakery made 40 cake pops for our rehearsal dinner in March 2024. They did a fantastic job! They stayed in communication through the entire process and made pick-up easy. The cake pops were so delicious! I only have one photo (from their bakery) because my guests and I were too excited to eat them. I'll definitely use Palermo's services again for future events!
Tami Johnson
You can't go wrong here,special occasion or just for your own consumption. Everything is fresh and delicious and customer service is outstanding.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gianna Abbinanti
I Palermo bakery! I saw on their instagram that they have pupo con uovo. My Nonna used to make them every year, but is unfortunately no longer with us. This would be our 4th Easter without them. We called Palermo first thing this morning to put in an order. We also ordered Iris, which they didn’t have today but made 10 for us, on a super short notice. (WOW!) I picked up the order, and all of the employees were so kind and welcoming. (As always). I also got a slice of eggplant pizza, which I devoured before even making it home. (Amazing). we were absolutely blown away when we got home and opened the boxes. The iris are HUGE, and very generously filled! We split a pupo con uovo in half, not having very high expectations. (What’s better than Nonna’s baking?) to our surprise, they were absolutely perfect. The best pupo con uovo we’ve ever had. (Sorry Nonna.) we also picked up a reginella cake here 2 weeks ago, which was phenomenal as well. Thanks to Palermo, this will be the best Easter we’ve had in years. I definitely recommend following them on social media, they always post what they’re making for the day. Will be stopping by every weekend going forward :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cheryl Matrasko
This Bakery is a good Bakery! This is the best Bakery in this location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli Cake
Karina Maurina
My expectations were met and went above and beyond with the junior stuffed cannoli I ordered. Absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli Cake
George Trumbulovic
Great, that's it just GREAT!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Filled Sandwich Cookies, Cannoli Cake, Cookies
Camou Flage
Parking is a pain when traffic is busy but food is amazing. Well worth a lil parking headache every now n then ;)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathy Napolitano
You could never go wrong with this Bakery been a customer since they were on Harlem Ave,, excellent products, wonderful owners, don’t walk in there hungry? Don’t , love everything about it ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli Cake, Cupcakes, Cookies, Birthday Cake, Candy Apple
D T.
Bakery goods were good but counterperson not so nice. Said her name was Kimberley. Treated us poorly and seemed put out that she had to wait on us. Gave me a bad feeling to deal a her. Needs a course in customer service.
We have tried many of their treats in the past year, and almost all have been fabulous. We have also purchased a few Too Good to Go bags. The only items we were so/so on were the decorative cookies. They were as gorgeous as the day is long, but the flavor is just meh. What I love is that even when they are busy, service flows well. It's easy to want one of almost everything in the shop! Their cake pops are outstanding!
Larry Cairo
Parking: Tough to get in and out
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Tony D.
For an Italian bakery they sure do polish paczki amazingly. This treat is only made once a year so it is a must stop in the morning for Fat Tuesday. There zepoli and other Italian treats are also great. This is a local gem in an area which is blessed with far to many amazing bakeries. The staff is always very friendly and efficient in getting you taken care of. My only critique would be the lattes are a pass. The drip coffee was fine but the latte was a pass.
Zully M.
My family and I enjoy their cookies. I came in today, I've been in a few times and usually the person that takes my order is helpful and welcoming. Today the woman who helped me was rude and seemed annoyed that I was there. I felt so uncomfortable picking out the cookies. She made me want to cancel the order. I hope next time I come in I feel welcomed and not a bother.
Big fan of sandwich Saturdays. The mafalda bread, mortadella and pesto sandwich last week was so good. Hoping it'll be back again. Also bought a few slices of the tres leches cake with sandwiches this weekend and everyone enjoyed them.
Palermo's Bakery made 40 cake pops for our rehearsal dinner in March 2024. They did a fantastic job! They stayed in communication through the entire process and made pick-up easy. The cake pops were so delicious! I only have one photo (from their bakery) because my guests and I were too excited to eat them. I'll definitely use Palermo's services again for future events!
You can't go wrong here,special occasion or just for your own consumption. Everything is fresh and delicious and customer service is outstanding.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I Palermo bakery! I saw on their instagram that they have pupo con uovo. My Nonna used to make them every year, but is unfortunately no longer with us. This would be our 4th Easter without them. We called Palermo first thing this morning to put in an order. We also ordered Iris, which they didn’t have today but made 10 for us, on a super short notice. (WOW!) I picked up the order, and all of the employees were so kind and welcoming. (As always). I also got a slice of eggplant pizza, which I devoured before even making it home. (Amazing). we were absolutely blown away when we got home and opened the boxes. The iris are HUGE, and very generously filled! We split a pupo con uovo in half, not having very high expectations. (What’s better than Nonna’s baking?) to our surprise, they were absolutely perfect. The best pupo con uovo we’ve ever had. (Sorry Nonna.) we also picked up a reginella cake here 2 weeks ago, which was phenomenal as well. Thanks to Palermo, this will be the best Easter we’ve had in years. I definitely recommend following them on social media, they always post what they’re making for the day. Will be stopping by every weekend going forward :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This Bakery is a good Bakery! This is the best Bakery in this location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli Cake
My expectations were met and went above and beyond with the junior stuffed cannoli I ordered. Absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli Cake
Great, that's it just GREAT!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Filled Sandwich Cookies, Cannoli Cake, Cookies
Parking is a pain when traffic is busy but food is amazing. Well worth a lil parking headache every now n then ;)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You could never go wrong with this Bakery been a customer since they were on Harlem Ave,, excellent products, wonderful owners, don’t walk in there hungry? Don’t , love everything about it ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli Cake, Cupcakes, Cookies, Birthday Cake, Candy Apple
Bakery goods were good but counterperson not so nice. Said her name was Kimberley. Treated us poorly and seemed put out that she had to wait on us. Gave me a bad feeling to deal a her. Needs a course in customer service.
Restaurantji Recommends
We have tried many of their treats in the past year, and almost all have been fabulous. We have also purchased a few Too Good to Go bags. The only items we were so/so on were the decorative cookies. They were as gorgeous as the day is long, but the flavor is just meh. What I love is that even when they are busy, service flows well. It's easy to want one of almost everything in the shop! Their cake pops are outstanding!
Parking: Tough to get in and out
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookies
For an Italian bakery they sure do polish paczki amazingly. This treat is only made once a year so it is a must stop in the morning for Fat Tuesday. There zepoli and other Italian treats are also great. This is a local gem in an area which is blessed with far to many amazing bakeries. The staff is always very friendly and efficient in getting you taken care of. My only critique would be the lattes are a pass. The drip coffee was fine but the latte was a pass.
My family and I enjoy their cookies. I came in today, I've been in a few times and usually the person that takes my order is helpful and welcoming. Today the woman who helped me was rude and seemed annoyed that I was there. I felt so uncomfortable picking out the cookies. She made me want to cancel the order. I hope next time I come in I feel welcomed and not a bother.
Excellent service and delicious desserts!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5