We walked in and were greeted immediately. The staff were very friendly. We ordered the white pizza, I regret it only because im just visiting the area and that pizza will be something a crave ofter. 💙 the garlic knots were very good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casey Taft
I’ve loved Betty’s and it’s been my go to pizza spot since moving to Oak Park 3 years ago but the last two times I’ve ordered from here I feel the quality of the pizza has gone down. The pizza was soggy and I noticed chunks of burnt charcoal under our pizza from our last order. They’ve also forgotten items from my order the last two times I’ve ordered and when we went back to ask for the items or a refund, they were closed (it was 7:40pm) even though the website said they closed at 9pm. The consistent misses have been disappointing as I used to love this spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Angela M. Gallo-Birkley.
The pizza is great overall. The canned beer is not cold enough. The service could be improved by havIng someone manage the take out, and another person the tables. It is not fair for the server to have to do it all. I will be back for the Hawaiian!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Douglas Ritcher
Family style portions available! Vodka Pasta and Arugula/Quinoa Salad were amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stuart S.
A delicious pizza and a team that cares. It might be your takeout spot but you should try dining in the clean and inviting dining room. They serve beer and wine and the pizza is delicious. Served hot and fresh ingredients, they use cornmeal unde the crust so it has a great crisp crunch not soggy. We had cheese NY style with mushrooms, olives and Basil. Easy and affordable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Salmon
I tried to order online and their 3rd party system was not working. I then tried calling and was told by the employee on the phone that I have to use the online system. He seemed uninterested when I explained that the online system doesn't work. Unfortunately, this is not the first time I have had difficulty ordering from Betty's and I'm sick of it. I will be spending my money elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mike Forsberg
Normally an amazing place, but they accidentally took my card and charged someone else's meal to it. Luckily, the money hit back right away, but they said it could've been up to three days and then they didn't understand why I was angry at them. They could've at least refunded my meal for the mistake. Then I forgot our sodas, and when I went to go pay, they tried to serve me a soda instead of refunding me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Missy
Low rating for service as they weren’t taking pickup orders on a Friday night at 7pm. I get maybe not taking deliveries but come on! And the person on the phone was not kind, apologetic or making us feel like she cared in the least. Having worked in restaurants, I get that kitchens can be short staffed or things can happen but to not even apologize or give a reason ensures that we’ll look elsewhere for our pizza Fridays.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Cassandra Taylor
The NY style pizza was definitely NOT NY style pizza. The crust was all wrong. The sauce was fine, nothing great but not bad either. The wild mushroom topping was good. We also got a NY style margarita pizza, the crust was all wrong and barely any mozzarella. The $20 salad was expired, with moldy lettuce and obviously from a bag. Our check was $110 for salad and 2 pizzas, we tipped well because the server was good, she was also very kind and doing the bus boy's job. Come on guys, do better.
You won’t get the super thin undercarriage NY slice here, but it’s still tasty and is a solid pizza.
I really want to support this local business 100% but can’t get myself to fully. They’ve gotten my order wrong the last two times (both phone orders for takeout) and this past time the order was taken by a very not-friendly lady.
The first time this happened, I notified them and they said they would refund me. Well, I never ended up getting the refund to my credit card. I let it slide because they are a small local business and I understand mistakes can be made. However, this past time it happened again but I didn’t even bother to let them know solely because the lady who took my order and who also was there when I picked up my order, was so curt and rude. I did not want to deal with her again.
Overall, I want this business to do well and I want to be a frequent customer. However when your order is wrong twice, and the first time the promised refund never gets followed through and the second time there’s an unfriendly employee, it isn’t a great feeling as a customer. Betty’s, please work on getting your orders processed and executed correctly. It would be nice too if your workers AT THE VERY LEAST have neutral attitudes.
Other positive reviews and pictures were consistent with our experience. Friendly staff, typical NY style pizza, inexpensive (18 inch pizza enough for 3-4).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Russell Garrett
Chewy, tasty crust that scratches the NY pizza itch. Thursday night is a double dip opportunity to get good deals. Half price wine and a $22 pizza special!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Giodude1580
genuinely pathetic they cant deliver pizza to an address 3 miles away, why even do delivery at that point
This is the best pizza in oak park!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We walked in and were greeted immediately. The staff were very friendly. We ordered the white pizza, I regret it only because im just visiting the area and that pizza will be something a crave ofter. 💙 the garlic knots were very good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve loved Betty’s and it’s been my go to pizza spot since moving to Oak Park 3 years ago but the last two times I’ve ordered from here I feel the quality of the pizza has gone down. The pizza was soggy and I noticed chunks of burnt charcoal under our pizza from our last order. They’ve also forgotten items from my order the last two times I’ve ordered and when we went back to ask for the items or a refund, they were closed (it was 7:40pm) even though the website said they closed at 9pm. The consistent misses have been disappointing as I used to love this spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
The pizza is great overall.
The canned beer is not cold enough.
The service could be improved by havIng someone manage the take out, and another person the tables.
It is not fair for the server to have to do it all.
I will be back for the Hawaiian!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Family style portions available! Vodka Pasta and Arugula/Quinoa Salad were amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A delicious pizza and a team that cares. It might be your takeout spot but you should try dining in the clean and inviting dining room. They serve beer and wine and the pizza is delicious. Served hot and fresh ingredients, they use cornmeal unde the crust so it has a great crisp crunch not soggy.
We had cheese NY style with mushrooms, olives and Basil. Easy and affordable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I tried to order online and their 3rd party system was not working. I then tried calling and was told by the employee on the phone that I have to use the online system. He seemed uninterested when I explained that the online system doesn't work. Unfortunately, this is not the first time I have had difficulty ordering from Betty's and I'm sick of it. I will be spending my money elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Normally an amazing place, but they accidentally took my card and charged someone else's meal to it. Luckily, the money hit back right away, but they said it could've been up to three days and then they didn't understand why I was angry at them. They could've at least refunded my meal for the mistake. Then I forgot our sodas, and when I went to go pay, they tried to serve me a soda instead of refunding me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Low rating for service as they weren’t taking pickup orders on a Friday night at 7pm. I get maybe not taking deliveries but come on! And the person on the phone was not kind, apologetic or making us feel like she cared in the least. Having worked in restaurants, I get that kitchens can be short staffed or things can happen but to not even apologize or give a reason ensures that we’ll look elsewhere for our pizza Fridays.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
The NY style pizza was definitely NOT NY style pizza. The crust was all wrong. The sauce was fine, nothing great but not bad either. The wild mushroom topping was good. We also got a NY style margarita pizza, the crust was all wrong and barely any mozzarella. The $20 salad was expired, with moldy lettuce and obviously from a bag. Our check was $110 for salad and 2 pizzas, we tipped well because the server was good, she was also very kind and doing the bus boy's job. Come on guys, do better.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
You won’t get the super thin undercarriage NY slice here, but it’s still tasty and is a solid pizza.
I really want to support this local business 100% but can’t get myself to fully. They’ve gotten my order wrong the last two times (both phone orders for takeout) and this past time the order was taken by a very not-friendly lady.
The first time this happened, I notified them and they said they would refund me. Well, I never ended up getting the refund to my credit card. I let it slide because they are a small local business and I understand mistakes can be made. However, this past time it happened again but I didn’t even bother to let them know solely because the lady who took my order and who also was there when I picked up my order, was so curt and rude. I did not want to deal with her again.
Overall, I want this business to do well and I want to be a frequent customer. However when your order is wrong twice, and the first time the promised refund never gets followed through and the second time there’s an unfriendly employee, it isn’t a great feeling as a customer. Betty’s, please work on getting your orders processed and executed correctly. It would be nice too if your workers AT THE VERY LEAST have neutral attitudes.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Love Betty's, always.
Food: 5
Other positive reviews and pictures were consistent with our experience. Friendly staff, typical NY style pizza, inexpensive (18 inch pizza enough for 3-4).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chewy, tasty crust that scratches the NY pizza itch. Thursday night is a double dip opportunity to get good deals. Half price wine and a $22 pizza special!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
genuinely pathetic they cant deliver pizza to an address 3 miles away, why even do delivery at that point
Loading...