Fantastic baked goods. Definitely try a scone, and the ham and cheese quiche.
B_Side Cocoa _
The food is wonderful but a little pricey the manager here is very rude….a lady with dark curly hair and glasses. I walked up to the counter to wait for my items because I knew I had to grab it myself and she just looked at me for a minute like I was bothering her without asking me if I needed anything….i than said “oh I’m waiting on my items” and she kindda shewed me away. Seems like she needs to work on some of her soft skills (I am also a supervisor in a coffee shop and I would never do this)
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Arati Chidi
Amazing cute place. Tried a few pastries and they were all amazing, especially their key lime pie. Loved their coffee also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brenda Chavez
The Horchata Matcha is SUBLIME!💚 It is delicious and refreshing. They also have great bakery options. I actually am not a fan of quiche, but I always get a slice when I go! The crust is perfect! However, the best part is the service. Everyone that works there is so incredibly kind and they always brighten my day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Assorted Cookies, Quiche of the Day
Beth Ruyle
Not as good as I thought it would be. S'Mores Pie didn't have a very good flavor, Chocolate Cream Pie was better but pretty one note. Key Lime was better tasting but crust was incredibly crumbly. Chocolate Chip Cookie was average. Raspberry Cherry Pie was good, best of the bunch. Take and bake biscuits, pies, and granola were incredibly expensive. Way overpriced on those.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
marina milinovic
Whatta pastry shop 👌👌
Food: 5
Service: 5
B
The aroma outside Spilt Milk had me looking forward to a treat. When I got in, the service was wonderful. Unfortunately the Financier I got lacked any discernible flavor. I like to bake and appreciate that the texture was nice and it was moist but the lasting impression was just of something sweet—no almond or vanilla flavor or anything else other than the taste of sugar. I'll give the place another try someday, but was disappointed in what I got today.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Yvonne Swiergula
Got a full pie for a party! Everyone including me loved it! Will definitely use Spilt Milk again!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Jim Unander
Scones were unimpressive, and the walnut one had no walnuts (maybe powder?).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Sarah and Wasay
I got a drink and didn’t like it but the baristas made me a new one! It was a great experience and truly appreciated their ability to change my drink. Shoutout to Mikey!
Really nice shop. Delicious cookies and pie. The drinks are good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lola Massenberg
I’ve been a couple times before and didn’t really love anything that I tried but I love a local bakery so wanted to try again. I placed an order for a Friday meal and wow, it was so good! I also purchased a couple of slices of pie and loved them. Prices are high for the baked goods ($25 for two slices of pie and a cookie) but I’m okay with that as long as the taste is good. I can’t afford that regularly but I’ll splurge every once in a while. Will definitely check out the Friday meals more often! Glad I gave it another shot.
Robin Robinson
I've been purchasing the key lime pie for years. Bought it for work, birthdays, holidays and just had a taste for it. I believe the price was around $30.00 then. I know and understand the cost for everything has gone up, the pie is at $49.50 now. However, if you need to charge more, please, please use the original ingredients that made everyone be willing to pay this high price. I just purchased the pie today 5/3/25 and it did not have much flavor mostly tasted sugar and alot of cream. I would like to continue to purchase from you. Please do better. Best, RRR
Don Mazza
Very nice and authentic
D Adams
We love it here, no matter what you get sweet or savory it has all been fantastic! Show up very early if you want a breakfast sandwich they are insanely popular
Fantastic baked goods. Definitely try a scone, and the ham and cheese quiche.
The food is wonderful but a little pricey the manager here is very rude….a lady with dark curly hair and glasses. I walked up to the counter to wait for my items because I knew I had to grab it myself and she just looked at me for a minute like I was bothering her without asking me if I needed anything….i than said “oh I’m waiting on my items” and she kindda shewed me away. Seems like she needs to work on some of her soft skills (I am also a supervisor in a coffee shop and I would never do this)
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Amazing cute place. Tried a few pastries and they were all amazing, especially their key lime pie. Loved their coffee also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Horchata Matcha is SUBLIME!💚 It is delicious and refreshing. They also have great bakery options. I actually am not a fan of quiche, but I always get a slice when I go! The crust is perfect! However, the best part is the service. Everyone that works there is so incredibly kind and they always brighten my day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Assorted Cookies, Quiche of the Day
Not as good as I thought it would be. S'Mores Pie didn't have a very good flavor, Chocolate Cream Pie was better but pretty one note. Key Lime was better tasting but crust was incredibly crumbly. Chocolate Chip Cookie was average. Raspberry Cherry Pie was good, best of the bunch. Take and bake biscuits, pies, and granola were incredibly expensive. Way overpriced on those.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Whatta pastry shop 👌👌
Food: 5
Service: 5
The aroma outside Spilt Milk had me looking forward to a treat. When I got in, the service was wonderful. Unfortunately the Financier I got lacked any discernible flavor. I like to bake and appreciate that the texture was nice and it was moist but the lasting impression was just of something sweet—no almond or vanilla flavor or anything else other than the taste of sugar. I'll give the place another try someday, but was disappointed in what I got today.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Got a full pie for a party! Everyone including me loved it! Will definitely use Spilt Milk again!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Scones were unimpressive, and the walnut one had no walnuts (maybe powder?).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
I got a drink and didn’t like it but the baristas made me a new one! It was a great experience and truly appreciated their ability to change my drink. Shoutout to Mikey!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Really nice shop. Delicious cookies and pie. The drinks are good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been a couple times before and didn’t really love anything that I tried but I love a local bakery so wanted to try again. I placed an order for a Friday meal and wow, it was so good! I also purchased a couple of slices of pie and loved them. Prices are high for the baked goods ($25 for two slices of pie and a cookie) but I’m okay with that as long as the taste is good. I can’t afford that regularly but I’ll splurge every once in a while. Will definitely check out the Friday meals more often! Glad I gave it another shot.
I've been purchasing the key lime pie for years. Bought it for work, birthdays, holidays and just had a taste for it. I believe the price was around $30.00 then. I know and understand the cost for everything has gone up, the pie is at $49.50 now. However, if you need to charge more, please, please use the original ingredients that made everyone be willing to pay this high price. I just purchased the pie today 5/3/25 and it did not have much flavor mostly tasted sugar and alot of cream. I would like to continue to purchase from you. Please do better.
Best,
RRR
Very nice and authentic
We love it here, no matter what you get sweet or savory it has all been fantastic! Show up very early if you want a breakfast sandwich they are insanely popular
Loading...