Great menu Great cocktails and 50% of bottles of wine to boot! We had a table for 4 outside on a lovely summer night. I enjoyed every bite of my walleye special!
James
The hostess had our table ready for us and our guests. The server, Olivia, was just fantastic answering any question my guests had on different items on the menu because it was their first time there. The service, drinks and food were above the top as usual because we go there often and the owner, Tony, give us a complimentary desert. I would recommend Pennyville Station to anyone and I know once you go there, you will come back. Jimmy and Yvette
Greg
On a warm summer night, sitting outside here was great. It's crowded, but the servers do a good job keeping up with the rush. Food is good, the drinks are cold and the atmosphere is great.
Norman
Great food and service. Outdoor dining is very comfortable, not jammed in together, good shade from direct sun. Atmosphere is vibrant and lively, people enjoying themselves.
Slobo Tomicevic
Solid place..nice to seat outside
damira kurtovic
Great food and service. Bottomless mimosas on Fridays and Saturdays definitely add a fun touch to brunch.
Armando
We had an amazing time. Everyone's choice of dinner was perfect and no complaints whatsoever. Emily took care of us and even though visibly busy was very attentive and friendly with us - not rushed. Highly recommend and do ask for Emily!!
Beth
Comfy spot for GNO. Fun drinks, never felt rushed by staff. I really appreciated the Manager accommodating my very unusual food restriction, by preparing a modified dish just for me. Will try sitting outside next time.
C D
The ginger snap mocktail was amazing. Would come back just to have this drink. The scallops also were great and perfect for when you don't want to eat to much.
mahfuz
Our server Kate was amazing, very attentive and caring! Went to celebrate our son's 4th birthday and Kate made him feel very special! Thank you!!
Enjoyed lunch here with colleagues with whom I used to work who became lifelong friends. We meet a couple times a year and decided to try Pennyville Station. We were not disappointed. The food and service was fantastic. Our server could not have been more friendly or attentive. It was a lovely afternoon for all of us. Pennyville will be our new go-to place! Using OpenTable proved a great choice as we got our requested round table which enabled easy conversation for all of us. Woohoo!
John Nydam
The kung pao cauliflower was delicious. Their chopped chicken salad was stellar with a perfect mix of olives, cucumber, feta. My pork chop was good-a lot of food for the price. Service was very nice and accommodating.
David De Jesus
Five tables available and we were told that we would have to wait 20 minutes for a table. We went next door to Harp and Fiddle and were greeted, seated and treated amazing.
When were we’re done, we walked by Pennyville and the same tables were still empty. What a joke!!!!
Thanks but no thanks Pennyville. Empty tables will get you to “Pennyville!”
W AR
We walked to Pennyville for date night yesterday and sat outside for a great dining experience. I had the shrimps for appetizer and the pork chop for dinner. The food was the perfect temperature and very flavorful. It was also the perfect temperature for outdoor dining.
Robert Edgar
Good food, great cocktails and awesome service...always made to feel like part of the family!
Great menu Great cocktails and 50% of bottles of wine to boot! We had a table for 4 outside on a lovely summer night. I enjoyed every bite of my walleye special!
The hostess had our table ready for us and our guests. The server, Olivia, was just fantastic answering any question my guests had on different items on the menu because it was their first time there. The service, drinks and food were above the top as usual because we go there often and the owner, Tony, give us a complimentary desert. I would recommend Pennyville Station to anyone and I know once you go there, you will come back. Jimmy and Yvette
On a warm summer night, sitting outside here was great. It's crowded, but the servers do a good job keeping up with the rush. Food is good, the drinks are cold and the atmosphere is great.
Great food and service. Outdoor dining is very comfortable, not jammed in together, good shade from direct sun. Atmosphere is vibrant and lively, people enjoying themselves.
Solid place..nice to seat outside
Great food and service. Bottomless mimosas on Fridays and Saturdays definitely add a fun touch to brunch.
We had an amazing time. Everyone's choice of dinner was perfect and no complaints whatsoever. Emily took care of us and even though visibly busy was very attentive and friendly with us - not rushed. Highly recommend and do ask for Emily!!
Comfy spot for GNO. Fun drinks, never felt rushed by staff. I really appreciated the Manager accommodating my very unusual food restriction, by preparing a modified dish just for me. Will try sitting outside next time.
The ginger snap mocktail was amazing. Would come back just to have this drink. The scallops also were great and perfect for when you don't want to eat to much.
Our server Kate was amazing, very attentive and caring! Went to celebrate our son's 4th birthday and Kate made him feel very special! Thank you!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Enjoyed lunch here with colleagues with whom I used to work who became lifelong friends. We meet a couple times a year and decided to try Pennyville Station. We were not disappointed. The food and service was fantastic. Our server could not have been more friendly or attentive. It was a lovely afternoon for all of us. Pennyville will be our new go-to place! Using OpenTable proved a great choice as we got our requested round table which enabled easy conversation for all of us. Woohoo!
The kung pao cauliflower was delicious. Their chopped chicken salad was stellar with a perfect mix of olives, cucumber, feta. My pork chop was good-a lot of food for the price. Service was very nice and accommodating.
Five tables available and we were told that we would have to wait 20 minutes for a table. We went next door to Harp and Fiddle and were greeted, seated and treated amazing.
When were we’re done, we walked by Pennyville and the same tables were still empty. What a joke!!!!
Thanks but no thanks Pennyville. Empty tables will get you to “Pennyville!”
We walked to Pennyville for date night yesterday and sat outside for a great dining experience. I had the shrimps for appetizer and the pork chop for dinner. The food was the perfect temperature and very flavorful. It was also the perfect temperature for outdoor dining.
Good food, great cocktails and awesome service...always made to feel like part of the family!
Loading...