Server was good but busy .. I asked for dairy free bun options - told gluten free bun - only option. I said .. “ok”.. removed all other options from sandwich. Bun was awful! Didn't eat- left on the side .. ate sandwich without bread - no big deal. But, was charged for a bun that could not be eaten. Cocktails - (2) drinks $17 ea because of an $8.00 upchange .. not sure why??? it was a very expensive dinner -
John
Not my first time at Penneyville, they never disappoint. Tried the pork chops, I must say it was delicious. The wine selection is excellent.
Katie
The food was good but service was really slow for a Sunday brunch. We were there much longer than expected because it took so long to get anything we needed.
Cathy
Always a great place for food and the outside seating area is perfect! Thank you Pennyville!
alina
I have dined at Pennyville Station multiple times and this was the first time I was dissatisfied. Smaller portions, my 10 years old who usually does not finish her fries had to order more fries ($7). They forgot the lettuce, tomato and sauce on my daughter ‘s sandwich. My hamburger was tasty and cooked well, but it was brought out lukewarm. Five dollars extra charge if you want to change the regular fries included in the meal with truffle fries seemed a bit much. Overall, quality and quantity went down.
Addy Leopoldo
Their short rib dishes hit every time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Samantha Slove
Our experience at Pennyville Station was terrible from start to finish. We were sat and completely forgotten about—no server ever came to our table until we finally flagged someone down after 30 minutes. Even then, the service was inattentive and disinterested.
When the food arrived, it was a huge disappointment. They somehow managed to burn something as simple as pancakes. For the price, the quality was shockingly mediocre. Throughout the meal, we had to ask for service three separate times, and no one ever offered an apology or any attempt to make things right.
Between the bad food, the awful service, and the lack of accountability, this was one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. We will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Edgar Del Rivero
Came here for Sunday lunch with my kids. Nobody was waiting in front of us. We were the only ones standing there. We literally stood there for 5 minutes while the staff just looked at us. No help or anything. Not coming back ever again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sally
It has been a year since we ate here. They expanded the dining area out front to accommodate more outdoor space. Food was good. Our server was great. She kept an eye on us and anticipated our needs. The other staff members were quick to take away our plates once we finished eating.
Sara Pessimisis
We had an excellent experience at Pennyville Station while meeting up with friends for brunch! It was family friendly which was a major plus. The food was delicious, paired with a fun atmosphere!
We have been to this spot a few times and it remains consistent. A fun atmosphere and food is always great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Regina C
Wonderful experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
michael
Great menu Great cocktails and 50% of bottles of wine to boot! We had a table for 4 outside on a lovely summer night. I enjoyed every bite of my walleye special!
James
The hostess had our table ready for us and our guests. The server, Olivia, was just fantastic answering any question my guests had on different items on the menu because it was their first time there. The service, drinks and food were above the top as usual because we go there often and the owner, Tony, give us a complimentary desert. I would recommend Pennyville Station to anyone and I know once you go there, you will come back. Jimmy and Yvette
Server was good but busy .. I asked for dairy free bun options - told gluten free bun - only option. I said .. “ok”.. removed all other options from sandwich. Bun was awful! Didn't eat- left on the side .. ate sandwich without bread - no big deal. But, was charged for a bun that could not be eaten. Cocktails - (2) drinks $17 ea because of an $8.00 upchange .. not sure why??? it was a very expensive dinner -
Not my first time at Penneyville, they never disappoint. Tried the pork chops, I must say it was delicious. The wine selection is excellent.
The food was good but service was really slow for a Sunday brunch. We were there much longer than expected because it took so long to get anything we needed.
Always a great place for food and the outside seating area is perfect! Thank you Pennyville!
I have dined at Pennyville Station multiple times and this was the first time I was dissatisfied. Smaller portions, my 10 years old who usually does not finish her fries had to order more fries ($7). They forgot the lettuce, tomato and sauce on my daughter ‘s sandwich. My hamburger was tasty and cooked well, but it was brought out lukewarm. Five dollars extra charge if you want to change the regular fries included in the meal with truffle fries seemed a bit much. Overall, quality and quantity went down.
Their short rib dishes hit every time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Our experience at Pennyville Station was terrible from start to finish. We were sat and completely forgotten about—no server ever came to our table until we finally flagged someone down after 30 minutes. Even then, the service was inattentive and disinterested.
When the food arrived, it was a huge disappointment. They somehow managed to burn something as simple as pancakes. For the price, the quality was shockingly mediocre. Throughout the meal, we had to ask for service three separate times, and no one ever offered an apology or any attempt to make things right.
Between the bad food, the awful service, and the lack of accountability, this was one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. We will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Came here for Sunday lunch with my kids. Nobody was waiting in front of us. We were the only ones standing there. We literally stood there for 5 minutes while the staff just looked at us. No help or anything. Not coming back ever again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
It has been a year since we ate here. They expanded the dining area out front to accommodate more outdoor space. Food was good. Our server was great. She kept an eye on us and anticipated our needs. The other staff members were quick to take away our plates once we finished eating.
We had an excellent experience at Pennyville Station while meeting up with friends for brunch! It was family friendly which was a major plus. The food was delicious, paired with a fun atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Try the Cobb salad and Sticky Toffee dessert.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been to this spot a few times and it remains consistent. A fun atmosphere and food is always great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Wonderful experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great menu Great cocktails and 50% of bottles of wine to boot! We had a table for 4 outside on a lovely summer night. I enjoyed every bite of my walleye special!
The hostess had our table ready for us and our guests. The server, Olivia, was just fantastic answering any question my guests had on different items on the menu because it was their first time there. The service, drinks and food were above the top as usual because we go there often and the owner, Tony, give us a complimentary desert. I would recommend Pennyville Station to anyone and I know once you go there, you will come back. Jimmy and Yvette
Loading...