560 John St, Paxton
Overall the best place to eat in Paxton.Your food is always hot and we have always had a great meal here. Never disappointed.The waitress is always friendly.
Recommended dishes: Cheese Crust, Breadsticks, Fries
The service was good with 1 waitress doing everything. The pizza was good and served hot after waiting a very long time. I ordered a side salad which is on the menu but was told I could not have a side salad. Only a salad bar for $7. So that killed my positive vibe. I'll only order carry out and make my own salad. They have ice cream and freeze dried candy which I found unusual.
The pizza was hot and very good. The service is excellent. The restaurant was very clean and shelves were orderly arranged. I will definitively go back.
Had a great meal, great
great food worth the wait. place is very nice inside. 110%
We had seen this place advertised on an Our Town local TV segment and wanted to try it (being a fan of deep dish). Overall it was good, but it could have been so much better. We ordered the garlic bread with cheese and loaded fries as appetizers. The garlic bread could have been much more toasted and have had way more garlic. The cheese on top was melted but could have been browned/broiled. The loaded fries weren't that hot and they were smothered with generic cheese sauce. We also ordered a 16" stuffed pizza. It took an hour to cook, which we understood, and we'd also just come in after a group party, so we knew it would take time and that was fine. The pizza was absolutely delicious but the center of it, although melted, was not hot. They did use a ton of cheese though so that was great. The server was super sweet but service was really slow, I think because she was the only person working the floor. I was really glad they had not only Coke and Dr. Pepper but also the Zero versions of them too. They were served in cans, but the drink price covered free refills/additional cans. They offer ice cream but we didn't get any - we were too full! I would return to this place, as it was just as good as Papa Del's and I think they are still finding their footing, and I would love to try their other pizzas (pan, thin). For three of us the total bill was only $47, which is very affordable, and we took home half the pizza!
Did not know how "deep" this pizza was. We ordered a large and it weighed at least 10lbs. The price seemed high but for what it was it was probably the best value for our dollar. Definitely recommend trying. The pizza was loaded with toppings and cheese.
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
The place smelled terrible when we walked in the door, like rotten meat. Service was terrible, it took over an hour to get our pizza & we were 1st ones here. The pizza crust was tough, you needed a knife to cut the crust & too much sauce. Don't even give you water for free. They bring out bottled water. It's an old Pizza Hut with moldy looking white brick walls. Don't know how this place gets good reviews. Way overpriced.
This is by far the best pizza around!
Got the thin crust with sausage. 16”. Took forever to get the pizza. Though there was one waitress and the place was about 1/4 to 1/2 full, this pizza shouldn’t have taken a little more than an hour to get. We went into the place not wanting the salad bar. But because of the wait we got the salad bar . I guess maybe it was their ploy with long wait to get this us to that salad bar . Don’t know. The pizza was not good. My wife liked it less than me. She gave it ( on a scale from one to ten) a 6. I gave it a 6.5. Was really hoping this was going to be a good place for there are not many options for a good pizza in our area. My wife said the pizza at Casey’s is much better. My advise find a good frozen pizza you like a lot or make your own. I would return and try the the fair style just to give them another chance.
picked up a stuffed pizza to go. They ask you to pick it up via the drive thru, that was a little difficult. There is a curb which prevents you from pulling up close to the window. So you get up out of your car anyway. Also they dont take credit cards... despite these things... the pizza was AWESOME!
Have not had it yet but after seeing the reviews in thinking the super stuff pan the way to go ,look forward to trying it
Was a miserable experience. Will never get that pizza again. Worst tasting pizza ever!
Awesome pizza!! We had Buffalo Chicken pizza and it was deliciousI do highly recommend.
560 John St, Paxton, IL 60957