Papa Johns Pizza

930 N Bourland Ave, Peoria
(309) 673-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mark

Thought I’d leave a review because I was kind of scared to go here because of previous reviews. Every papa johns in this area has bad reviews so maybe it’s hit or miss. But our food was great. The pizza was cooked perfectly and good amount of cheese. The garlic knots were a little over cooked which wasn’t great but they still tasted good. I did tip $8 so maybe that helps.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Clinton Holaday

I accidentally delivered to the wrong location on Saturday night. The delivery driver called, was happy to be redirected to the correct address across town, and still accomplished the mission. And the pizza was still hot. What a legend.

Food: 5

Service: 5

angela mcbride

I WAS ORDERING FROM THIS LOCATION BUT AFTER RECEIVING BURNT GARLIC KNOTS SEVERAL TIMES, I PLACED MY ORDER THAN I CALLED TO ASK THAT THEY NOT BE BLACK IN COLOR(bcz it’s happen 3 times) AUTOMATICALLY LOUD AND RUDE, THE MANAGER TAMEEKA IS VERY UNPROFESSIONAL AND SO IS ONE OF THE EMPLOYEES SHE HAS WORKING TODAY 7/29/25. SAYS SHE HAS NO CONTROL OVER THE OVEN. TALKED RIGHT OVER ME THEN HUNG UP ON ME BCZ SHE HOT AND THE AIR WZNT WORKN? THESE PPL ARE THE SADDEST TPYE OF CUSTOMER SERVICE PPL. U JUST DONT GET LOUD AND RUDE WITH THE CUSTOMER. I JUST WANT TO PAY FOR FOOD I CAN EAT. I WILL NEVER SPEND $$ THER AGAIN!! CANT TRUST ANGRY SOULS. IM A CUSTOMER SERVICE LEAD AND WOULD NEVER #HER😩😬

K Watkins

I went in today to pick up a pizza and it was ready on time, quality was great and the woman working was extremely friendly and kind would definitely go back again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sophia Ann

Are you frickin kidding me???? This was for my daughter it was half cheese and half pepperoni where the hell is the CHEESE?????!!! I WANT A REFUND

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

the pitbull family

Never got food had to cancel to get money back. And they lied when I called them

Willie Hamlet

Spoke with the GM was very rude and considerate was not listening to me try to explain to her what was going on she was not listening very rude would like a district manager to give me a call

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lisa Jones

I ordered a large pizza.The works thin crust and bone in hot lemon pepper Chicken wings I received boneless hot lemon pepper chicken wings. I called to let them know that I got the wrong chicken wings and they told me they couldn't refund or anything because they can't do that with chicken wings.Then they try To say I was lying basically Because he said the driver picked up the right Wings with order and I said no, they didn't these chicken wings.I got are nasty They don't even taste like chicken I asked.
To speak to the manager because I was speaking with the assistant manager. And he said she's busy so don't ever order from Papa. John's, they're not all that anyway.!!! And I spend 47.89 with taxs and tip for driver

Food: 2

Service: 1

Genevieve Saxton

I happened to walk by and stopped in to get a pizza for dinner. It was very good. The oreo cookie bites were not good, no fault of the employees
..it's just not a good recipe. The pizza is great tho. Manager was working and she was really down to Earth. Cashier was proactive in telling me about specials.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Tonya Williams

I used to love Papa John's this would be the only place that my family would order from.. however not so much it now seems like there's not a lot of effort to even put a pizza of together.. I will not be going back for a while I was not satisfied I was very disappointed customer

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Derek G

The food wasn't bad, chicken wings were excellent but the problem was that zesty Italian pizza, it's supposed to be covered with banana peppers but it seems they've put chopped pepperrocini instead wich isn't dramatic in itself but man why also put stems though? Whoever was working sunday the 25th of august at around 23H is either really not bright or very disrespectful of customers for putting effing pepperrocini stems all over my pizza, I've found like 5 detached cooked stems. I won't be ordering back from this location

Food: 3

Service: 1

Jacclyn Arnold

I ordered their pizza through doordash and I ordered extra pepperocinis. I received a whole container full of them and the pizza is beautiful. Had to leave a review. ? impressed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jaxx A

I ordered their pizza through doordash and I ordered extra pepperocinis. I received a whole container full of them and the pizza is beautiful. Had to leave a review. 💯 impressed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Nelson

My pizza was done sooner than expected. The gentleman working there was great and his customer service was refreshing. It's hard to find people that gives good customer service let alone great customer service like he does. Oh and the pizza was good too.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew Stidham

Nasty, drug dealing Nick Kinman spit all over my food tonight! They just lost a life long customer. I can’t even believe anyone would hire this trash it says a lot about your company! Disgusting appearance, rude and disrespectful. I’ll be calling the health department tomorrow.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...