That's My Jam LLC

2900 N Sheridan Rd R, Peoria
(309) 242-8711

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tamara Masters

Fantastic breads and jams and pickles! Sourdough is stratospherically off the charts (not too sour either!) Add their jam and it perfection! The fresh baked Bagels are a must eat as well!

Kyle Yap

The bagels are top notch!

Haley Foley

I just picked up my sourdough order in Peoria as I was recommended to them by a coworker! 10/10 affordable and fresh when picked up! He answered all the questions I had about the starter I ordered. Was delish definitely happy with what I got!

Erinn Setterlund-Ambrosch

The sourdough is absolutely delicious as well as the bagels! So amazing and with wholesome ingredients! Love the pickles and jams as well. Can’t go wrong!

Lindsey Ruder

So delicious! And what a treat to have free delivery service! Telling local family and friends now...

Kailey Parks

C & J make the best sourdough available in Central IL! They are a must-stop spot during the Bloomington Farmers market season, and during the winter I look forward to their delivery every Monday! Their bread for breakfast is truly the highlight of my days! Consistently high quality and such kind people.

LeAnn Trana

We love the sourdough bread (with peach jam!) and GF breakfast cookies! So delicious! Will try the blueberry vanilla honey jam next. Jake and Claire are so warm and welcoming. They are very knowledgeable and passionate about their craft. A pleasure to purchase from them at the Downtown Bloomington farmers market!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandon Petrakis

Very delicious product, and nice vibes. Jake and. Claire know thier craft well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gypsy Russ

Best sourdough bread I've ever had!
Amazing, especially toasted

Food: 5

Sally Flynn

Everything they make is wonderful. You can’t go wrong

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gregory

I missed my pickup because of an unplanned business trip and they contacted me and let me know when and how to pick it up. They even froze the fresh baked items. Truly great customer service. Looking forward to trying the bagels and cookies.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Ernst

The best sourdough I’ve ever had, hands down. Going to the Sheridan market to get my sourdough every Wednesday is now the highlight of my week. Super sweet, friendly people. Out of this world bread! Can’t wait to try my bagels and my jam 😍

Russell Smith

Great breads and jams!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacqueline Gauthier

Oh my goodness! Crazy amazing pickles! Mmmmm!

Food: 5

Steve Hollaway

These are some of the best homemade bagels I have had in Peoria. The quality is excellent, they deliver them on Monday mornings for free, and I have to tell myself not to eat them all before Tuesday. Highly recommend everyone give these a try at least once.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...