Theo's Ice Cream

3633 N Gale Ave, Peoria
(309) 688-5854

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gloria DeVault

Delicious treat and sweet staff!!! THANK YOU!

Chrys McK-C

Always go for the twist in a waffle cone. Always happy!

Devonte Lyric Daniel

I found a roach in my ice cream. I just came up there having a really great day with my daughter. She bought me ice cream and when it was melting as I moved the Oreos around, I saw a freaking roach!!!!

jeff ferrel

Smores shake was great. Wife rocky rock was a lot of chocolate.

Don & Betty Brooks

We love Theos. Great place & the owners are great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jessica

Delicious!

Tasha Nicole

We love Theo's & try to go as often as possible. Their icebergs are so good with toppings to the bottom, amazing 🤗

Jeff N.

Holy crap! Here you can pay for the most expensive shake ever and get a heaping serving of bad attitude from the owner when you raise your eyebrows in shock at the price! $9.65 for an extra large shake! ... And he starts rudely telling you that he'll give you a refund if you don't like the price... "Is there a problem... Is there a problem? With the attitude like he's going to make a problem if you say yes...well, I won't be going back to that place that I've frequented many times since living here. This owner makes Seinfeld's Soup Nazi look like a charm school graduate...

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Mike Smith

Cash only, great little ice cream place

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elisabeth Rauen

Kyleigh took my order and i received my food quickly and it was delicious as always. Employees are always friendly and pleasant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cecily Demanes-Entwistle

Best icebergs (blizzards) around! Really good burgers too! Staff is always really friendly!

Michelle W. (Michelle)

The parking lot was clean and tidy despite it beyond the corner of a busy street. They actually put the mixture in your ice cream and the toppings for your nachos on your chips, unlike other places. It is CASH ONLY like a lot of the ice cream shops nowadays. I would definitely recommend this place!

Parking: Limited free parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Nachos

Jessica Rauen

Theos has been my go to ice cream spot for years. Kyleigh most recently took and prepared my order, it was perfect! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Travis Critten

I pulled into Theos with people in line. The parking lot smelled of weed and then were told after waiting to have order taken that “If we are ready to order, we can’t help you”. We are closed. They then closed the window and shut the lights off. This was my first and last experience here.

Tanaria Ware

Went today with my son , guy working today was EXTREMELY RUDE to me and my son while ordering. They need better workers with come customer service skills

Loading...