Vitale’s Pizza Cellar
$ • Pizza
Hours:
402 S Main St, Princeton
(815) 879-7671
About Vitale’s Pizza Cellar
Customers' Favorites
Vitale’s Pizza Cellar Reviews
Share your opinion about Vitale’s Pizza Cellar
Horrible experience, this place was not busy at all. Not only did we Wait over 1 hour for are food the food was wrong making us to wait longer and then when asking for some sort of compensation we were told no after explaining are experience with our sever. If you would like your straws thrown on your table and have to ask for refills and like to get ignored by your waiter I would recommend 100% but if not I would not recommend at all.
I called tonight to order for my family. I asked if they had regular burgers on regular buns bc their burger is long and served on a long roll and I was ordering for my child so just wondered if maybe it was a kid menu item. the lady who was taking my order didn't know so I could hear her asking another woman in the background... the woman in the background said (very snotty and rude) " no I don't carry regular buns so that's a no... tell them to call McDonald's" ..I replied...read full review
We waited over an hour and half for a pizza, Chicago dog and sausage sandwich- dine in. We ordered three orders of cheesy bread as entrees and they came out after maybe 30 mins of waiting. So, half of us were done eating way before the rest of everyone’s food made it out. The waitress, which I believe is an owner, was so beyond not pleasant. She didn’t give us menus, but asked us what we wanted to order and after we asked for menus she huffed and puffed like it was an out...read full review
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9:30PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9:30PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9:30PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 9PM |
People in Princeton Also Viewed
Vitale’s Pizza Cellar is a popular local restaurant known for its tasty pizza, especially the thin crust variety and delicious cheese bread. Many customers say it’s a favorite spot for tasting a classic, hometown pizza experience. The sweet sauce is a key feature, though some people find it a little sweet. The crust and cheese are highly praised, with one customer mentioning the use of real sausage chunks. The staff, especially the younger members, are friendly and provide good service. Prices are considered fair, and the restaurant offers a variety of menu items beyond pizza. Although some feel the crust could be crisper, overall, Vitale’s Pizza Cellar remains a beloved place for those who want a good pizza and a family-friendly atmosphere.