Vitale’s Pizza Cellar

402 S Main St, Princeton
(815) 879-7671

Recent Reviews

Sort by
connor harlan

Very good pizza and a Good Atmosphere. You enjoy It I promise you guys!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

andrew n

It was hot but took me back to when I was a kid. Pizza is really good but my personal taste is thought the sauce is a little sweet. I loved the crust and the cheese. I like that they used real sausage chunks. Great service, good price. I'd recommend

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

David

My favorite pizza. Try this pizza if you’re in the area

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Morris

Great thin crust pizza. Their sausage jalapeño pizza is 5 star

Keirstyn Charles

I love Pizza Cellar! I have been going here since I was a kid and I have never once noticed a change in recipes like other places like to do to “change things up.” Pizza Cellar pizza has great flavor and it’s by far a favorite of mine. It’s family fun and definitely worth supporting! They have a variety of other things on the menu as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heather Hoxie

Just not my type of pizza, I love the thin crust but it was over cheesy and very wet from excess grease. Staff was friendly and welcoming.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Jeffrey Schriver

Food was great! Had Italian beefs. Long big sandwich with A LOT of meat on it. Big cup of sauce to dip it in. Service wasn't too good however. We waited 10-15 minutes just to get noticed for them to take our order. They took it and waited a bit for the food. THEN, had to get her attention to get our check. Just glad we didn't need refills. Good thing the food was delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Steve Speakman

Was in here a couple weeks ago with my good friends John and Colleen Dodd. Absolutely the Best pizza I've had in years. Incredibly Delicious. Wish it was closer to Joliet, I'd be there every day!!

Michael Tumbleson

Love johns pizza....great place to dine

rick bornsheuer

Best pizza ever

Eva Smallhorn

Wish everyone had pizza this good!

Michael Baker

We decided to try this place again and nothing has changed. Not very good

Lora Wetsel

Great pizza. Fast and friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amber Killian

I called tonight to order for my family. I asked if they had regular burgers on regular buns bc their burger is long and served on a long roll and I was ordering for my child so just wondered if maybe it was a kid menu item. the lady who was taking my order didn't know so I could hear her asking another woman in the background... the woman in the background said (very snotty and rude) " no I don't carry regular buns so that's a no... tell them to call McDonald's" ..I replied " wow that was extremely rude! I heard what she just said, I'll call elsewhere" ... treating a customer that way for a simple yes or no answer was uncalled for.. I was just asking..i would have ordered my kid something else..sheesh!! rude as hell

Emily Stevenson

We waited over an hour and half for a pizza, Chicago dog and sausage sandwich- dine in. We ordered three orders of cheesy bread as entrees and they came out after maybe 30 mins of waiting. So, half of us were done eating way before the rest of everyone’s food made it out. The waitress, which I believe is an owner, was so beyond not pleasant. She didn’t give us menus, but asked us what we wanted to order and after we asked for menus she huffed and puffed like it was an out of the way thing to ask. She never asked us if we needed refills on drinks and never bothered to apologize for the extremely long wait for the food. I understand everyone has bad days, but the lack of decent service we received was ridiculous.

Loading...