Prime Quarter Steak House

250 Backbone Rd E, Princeton
(815) 872-3500

Recent Reviews

Ashley Kropf

Here for my brother’s 20th birthday Delicious food?great service ??

Curtis Laster

It was a great experience. It was my first visit. For a Sunday evening, it was pretty busy, the pit area was a bit small, so it was crowded. The various cuts of meat were ample. We had the choice of preparing the steaks or having in-house staff doing the heavy lifting.The salad bar was well stocked and had plenty of options. I would recommend it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Grill Your Own, Cook Your Own Steak Dinner, Texas Toast, Garlic Toast, Onion and Mushroom

Wanda K

We had yo wait a while for our table so the manager brought us a plate of appetizers. Our group were celebrating our 50th anniversary and thr restaurant brought us a large piece of cheesecake with Happy 50th Anniversary written in chocolate on the plate. Thank you for both!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

amie nelle

Ben was our chef he was phenomenal! Our steaks were cooked perfectly exactly how we ordered them! Highly recommend him! Lindsay B was our server. She was attentive and paid close attention to detail. Will be returning.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rib Eye Delmonico

Eric

Love this place. Massive steaks you grill yourself (or can pay a small fee for the chefs to do it) on their giant grills. Nice small salad bar that's included as well. Cocktails are great and reasonably priced. Waitresses are always attentive and helpful. Make the extra drive for this gem!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DJ L'Monte

Good food and good staff! We drove 2 hours to

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cook Your Own Steak Dinner

Tracy Adams

We did not cook our own steaks. But the salad bar was good are the steak were cooked perfectly. It was very busy and the staff was struggling a bit. All in all it was a good experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Mario Sisto

Went on Valentine’s Day with my wife, staff was busy but still took good care of us. Steak was amazing! Overall great time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cook Your Own Steak Dinner, Texas Toast

John Mignone

Great Place!! The Steaks? were fantastic and they have a nice Salad Bar, lots of options. Highly Recommend if you looking for a Night out to eat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Texas Toast, Beets and Salad, All Steaks

Rae Rae

We reserved a party of about 25, they definitely were not prepared for us, we were here for 2 hours before we even got our food and a couple of our steaks were just not good at all, not cooked right and very bland, will not be back

D M.

Old school great! On the pricey side. Come hungry. Salad bar and grille your own steak

Aaron Brunoehler

It's crazy how this place is 2x the price of Texas Roadhouse or Longhorn and it's half as good. The grill is run by high schoolers and the damn t bone I had was paler than me off the grill.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Kenneth Booth

Good salad bar. Rib eye steak was a good size and very presentable. Ordered medium rare and it came out real rare which was doable if I could eat it.So damn tough could not eat it, only chew on it for a while. Very disappointing that their meat isn't a better quality.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Salad Bar

Sheila B.

The restaurant wS so relaxing. You can cook your own steak or they will cook for you. We chose to let them so we could visit with family. The salad bar was very good with a great variety of dishes (potatoe salad, cottage cheese, beets, pasta, lettuce, and plenty of fresh vegetables,eggs,ham,etc. You have to make sure you leave room for the meat and potatoes. If you dont like steak, there are other options on the menu. And of course, a dessert which we had to pass on. The waitess was so nice and did a great job. Had great service. Dress is casual to business, very clean inside with lots of parking. This is a great place for a fine night to enjoy. Price about $30 per person. Prime Quarters is also in Janesville Wi and Green Bay, Wi. You must try.

Tami K.

We had a party of 23 for a birthday celebration and we were well taken care of. From making the reservation to being called back the day of to confirm our reservation their customer service was on point. The wait staff did a nice job of meeting everyones needs and they took great care of our group. They had a nice selection of steaks and those grilled their own as well as those who ordered chef cooked steaks were pleased. We will definitely be back!!!

Load More