Really satisfying “small” root beer float!I think they used MUG’s root beer. $4
Brian Korte
As good as always such a variety of flavors which is nice and friendly staff which makes the experience that much better we love this place
Misti K.
We are fairly new to town and were so happy to discover Sislers! The ice cream and waffle bowls always taste fresh, and the service is always fast and friendly. We haven't had a flavor that we didn't like yet!
Jeff Rout
We got coffee espresso and festive cheese cake. Upon first glance the ice cream looks very good. After eating it we noticed that both ice creams were very bland and nearly just tasted like vanilla ice cream for both cones. If the ice creams had flavor this place would be amazing!
Sean Hughes
Best ice cream around!! Very friendly staff and like that they let you browse instead of making you feel rushed. The taste testing is great especially if you have kids.
Jamie P
This is the kind of ice cream place I like! The flavors I've tasted were all very good so far. I'm not a fan of making an ice cream treat that's mostly candy and mix-ins instead of the ice cream being the star.In comparison to other ice cream and dessert shops I also think the prices are perfectly reasonable. One scoop is a generous scoop! More than enough for me to eat in one sitting. Inside has been clean and comfortable.
Gene Finn
I hadn't had Sislers for 31 years, ever since my grandma passed away. But one thing I always remember from being a kid was the half gallon of Sislers in the freezer. Ever since I've told many friends and colleagues about the fantastic ice cream of my childhood. So on a recent trip back to Princeton I couldn't resist the opportunity to make sure the real thing was as good as the memory. Well....I was not disappointed. I have had countless ice creams over the years, even fresh gilato in Italy....but for me none of them hold a candle to Sislers chocolate ice cream. Truly world class!! I wish the owners every success and good fortune for the future.
Valerie Keener
Delicious! Friendly staff!
Melissa B.
Loved that we were able to sample flavors before we ordered since a great variety of amazing flavors. Ice cream tasted amazing and we loved the history wall and vibe of the shop. We will definitely be back!
What a great little hometown place with incredible ice cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madison Miranda
Fantastic job on our christmas ice cream cake. The peppermint ice cream was AMAZING!
Nathalia Parra
Very good customer service and the ice cream was delicious. A little bit of a wait as they seem short staffed and slightly over priced but all in all pretty decent.
Nicole Holland
Love this local ice cream shop! By far the best shakes around!
Rachel Berry
Yummy ice cream, good service, and a cool, small business history lesson
Great little ice cream shop!
Really satisfying “small” root beer float!I think they used MUG’s root beer. $4
As good as always such a variety of flavors which is nice and friendly staff which makes the experience that much better we love this place
We are fairly new to town and were so happy to discover Sislers! The ice cream and waffle bowls always taste fresh, and the service is always fast and friendly. We haven't had a flavor that we didn't like yet!
We got coffee espresso and festive cheese cake. Upon first glance the ice cream looks very good. After eating it we noticed that both ice creams were very bland and nearly just tasted like vanilla ice cream for both cones. If the ice creams had flavor this place would be amazing!
Best ice cream around!! Very friendly staff and like that they let you browse instead of making you feel rushed. The taste testing is great especially if you have kids.
This is the kind of ice cream place I like! The flavors I've tasted were all very good so far. I'm not a fan of making an ice cream treat that's mostly candy and mix-ins instead of the ice cream being the star.In comparison to other ice cream and dessert shops I also think the prices are perfectly reasonable. One scoop is a generous scoop! More than enough for me to eat in one sitting. Inside has been clean and comfortable.
I hadn't had Sislers for 31 years, ever since my grandma passed away. But one thing I always remember from being a kid was the half gallon of Sislers in the freezer. Ever since I've told many friends and colleagues about the fantastic ice cream of my childhood. So on a recent trip back to Princeton I couldn't resist the opportunity to make sure the real thing was as good as the memory. Well....I was not disappointed. I have had countless ice creams over the years, even fresh gilato in Italy....but for me none of them hold a candle to Sislers chocolate ice cream. Truly world class!! I wish the owners every success and good fortune for the future.
Delicious! Friendly staff!
Loved that we were able to sample flavors before we ordered since a great variety of amazing flavors. Ice cream tasted amazing and we loved the history wall and vibe of the shop. We will definitely be back!
Restaurantji Recommends
What a great little hometown place with incredible ice cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic job on our christmas ice cream cake. The peppermint ice cream was AMAZING!
Very good customer service and the ice cream was delicious. A little bit of a wait as they seem short staffed and slightly over priced but all in all pretty decent.
Love this local ice cream shop! By far the best shakes around!
Yummy ice cream, good service, and a cool, small business history lesson
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4