Nothing bad to say about this place. Didn't have the pizza yet but will be stopping back for it. We had the Italian beef because of what we had heard of them, and a meatball sandwich. The Italian beef was amazing, came out a crusty sub roll and looked simple, not like a roll stuffed with meat and soaked in au jus, but took that first bite without even dipping in the juice and wow the flavor was amazing. Add in the densely flavored au jus and it just got better. The meatball sandwich was also really good, the marinara to dip was great. My wife said the meatballs reminded her of SpaghettiOs's and Meatballs, meatballs but in a really good way she said. I just thought they were really good in general.There was just the owner working when we were there and she was nothing but friendly, and had great customer service. Will definitely be back to try the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gail McWorthy
Very good pizza this was our 1st time We had a birthday party here . When we are camping at Blackhawk Campground we will be in for pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kasey Myers
Was in last week, great pizza & great hospitality. This is my second time there. Looks like the strip mall in New Milford is on the up tick. great to see that business is back on 251 in New Milford!
Randal Sunday
Way to much crust like 2 inches around with no toppings so that made my large pizza a medium. Didn't care for the sauce and waited over an hour to pickup and it wasn't busy at
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
M Al D
I met Frank while visiting an estate sale and we got to talking and Frank mentioned his pizzeria. His expression said a lot to me while he spoke about his hand-made crust, sauce and fresh ingredients so I decided to take the 20 minute ride there the next day; wife in tow. We were not disappointed. The pizza is wonderful, the salad fresh and the beer cold. We really enjoyed our meal and look forward to going back. Near our home there simply isn't any decent pizza but glad to know that we now have a place to go and enjoy a delicious meal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sharron Bock
Great hospitality. I feel welcome and the food tastes great. Smiles all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Fisher
Pizza was fantastic. Been dying to try this place and was left very satisfied. Crust was fantastic, toppings were super fresh. Definitely one of the better pizzas in the area. Great job Frank!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
hardin bills
Just got home from a road trip and looked for a quick local place and landed here. Ordered a large 14" cheese pizza for delivery and was told it was $22 + tax and I left a 3 dollar delivery tip. Got the pizza and the box was smaller than I was hoping. Cracked it open and it was mostly sauce....I measured it and it was only 12 inches. My wife then informed me the large was only $14 so I called. I was told the pizza was $14 but there was a $7 delivery fee for "out of town"....im 1 town over and wasn't even told about this charge. My information was given to the manager or owner and I was called back. I was explained the charges like I was a child who didn't understand what was going on and then I was told that the pizza shrunk when cooking. I paid for 14....not 12, your pizza shrinking is not my problem. The least they could have done was adjust my price for a 12 inch...but I was told nothing would happen.Not going to recommend or return ?***EDIT***I got a phone call from Frank, one of the owners who was more than understanding of my issue and was more than happy to rectify the issue by hand deliving a new pizza and a 2 liter to me after hrs. It was very much appreciated and I let him know that several times over. The last thing anyone wants is to feel taken advantage of especially from a local business. Thank you Frank!
Food: 4
Service: 5
S Andrew
Excellent waitress. Pizza was great. Cheese sticks were good. Pasta was average. Something was lacking a bit there. For a great pizza definitely worth a stop.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pepperoni Pizza
Craig
Awesome pizza, hockey & football on TV.Two pizza deal was consumed and enjoyed by all. Great service.
I come here multiple times in a month for the family!! Great location and people and they deliver to the country side if needed!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan N
Love this pizza. A close by go to for us. Never disappoints!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nowyou Seeme (Richard)
Disappointed, to begin i am from chicago and thin crust is a place to go to. but i tried it and it might be my last time trying this pizza. The sauce was sweet from different slices and sausage had no season. I rate the pizza 2 out of 5.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
William Donato
Quite possibly the best pizza in the Rockford area. Frankie and his family are great people too. I highly recommend this spot!
We have driven by this place weekly on our way to the free Wednesday Blues shows at the Burpee Museum, and finally had the chance to drop in after Red White and Blues Fest to honor veterans at Lyran Park this last Saturday.This is in the corner of a strip mall, close to Holcomb Bank. You pull off onto a frontage road, and then into the strip mall. More than adequate free parking is available.We were greeted at the door, and seated promptly. I had their Root Beer (which never got a chance to be empty - the server was very attentive) and my wife had their unsweetened tea and had the same service.Looking around the place, you have TVs (2) and décor on the walls, from spoons to pictures to signs. There is a Bullshooter dart game, and a Big Buck Hunter flat screen deer and other critter (including ZOMBIES!) hunting game. Some pictures are of customers, as the restaurant considers everyone who comes in for food part of their family. Speaking of service, our server informed us (apart in time, since I was using the rest room, which was very clean) that this is a woman owned business, and that the chef (the owners husband) makes sure the sauce and the crust are right for sensitive stomachs, and that everything from the dough to the sauce is made fresh daily. Talk about setting some high expectations.After looking through the menu, we decided to get their Everything Special Large pizza, which came with sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, green olives, pepperoni, bacon and anchovies.The pizza hit the table nice and hot, clearly fresh from the oven. Hint: Go after the corner pieces first - they cool faster, then the edge pieces.The crust is crispy which helps support the toppings and sauce, and since this pizza was loaded, it needed the support. However, that means you'll need to use your knife and fork if you are cutting up your squares of pizza to cool them off a bit.We had some leftovers and a nice foam box was provided for those. They reheated nicely the next day by the way.The owner came by and was checking in - we agreed the pizza was good. I think you will too!
Nothing bad to say about this place. Didn't have the pizza yet but will be stopping back for it. We had the Italian beef because of what we had heard of them, and a meatball sandwich. The Italian beef was amazing, came out a crusty sub roll and looked simple, not like a roll stuffed with meat and soaked in au jus, but took that first bite without even dipping in the juice and wow the flavor was amazing. Add in the densely flavored au jus and it just got better. The meatball sandwich was also really good, the marinara to dip was great. My wife said the meatballs reminded her of SpaghettiOs's and Meatballs, meatballs but in a really good way she said. I just thought they were really good in general.There was just the owner working when we were there and she was nothing but friendly, and had great customer service. Will definitely be back to try the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good pizza this was our 1st time We had a birthday party here . When we are camping at Blackhawk Campground we will be in for pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was in last week, great pizza & great hospitality. This is my second time there. Looks like the strip mall in New Milford is on the up tick. great to see that business is back on 251 in New Milford!
Way to much crust like 2 inches around with no toppings so that made my large pizza a medium. Didn't care for the sauce and waited over an hour to pickup and it wasn't busy at
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
I met Frank while visiting an estate sale and we got to talking and Frank mentioned his pizzeria. His expression said a lot to me while he spoke about his hand-made crust, sauce and fresh ingredients so I decided to take the 20 minute ride there the next day; wife in tow. We were not disappointed. The pizza is wonderful, the salad fresh and the beer cold. We really enjoyed our meal and look forward to going back. Near our home there simply isn't any decent pizza but glad to know that we now have a place to go and enjoy a delicious meal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great hospitality. I feel welcome and the food tastes great. Smiles all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was fantastic. Been dying to try this place and was left very satisfied. Crust was fantastic, toppings were super fresh. Definitely one of the better pizzas in the area. Great job Frank!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just got home from a road trip and looked for a quick local place and landed here. Ordered a large 14" cheese pizza for delivery and was told it was $22 + tax and I left a 3 dollar delivery tip. Got the pizza and the box was smaller than I was hoping. Cracked it open and it was mostly sauce....I measured it and it was only 12 inches. My wife then informed me the large was only $14 so I called. I was told the pizza was $14 but there was a $7 delivery fee for "out of town"....im 1 town over and wasn't even told about this charge. My information was given to the manager or owner and I was called back. I was explained the charges like I was a child who didn't understand what was going on and then I was told that the pizza shrunk when cooking. I paid for 14....not 12, your pizza shrinking is not my problem. The least they could have done was adjust my price for a 12 inch...but I was told nothing would happen.Not going to recommend or return ?***EDIT***I got a phone call from Frank, one of the owners who was more than understanding of my issue and was more than happy to rectify the issue by hand deliving a new pizza and a 2 liter to me after hrs. It was very much appreciated and I let him know that several times over. The last thing anyone wants is to feel taken advantage of especially from a local business. Thank you Frank!
Food: 4
Service: 5
Excellent waitress. Pizza was great. Cheese sticks were good. Pasta was average. Something was lacking a bit there. For a great pizza definitely worth a stop.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pepperoni Pizza
Awesome pizza, hockey & football on TV.Two pizza deal was consumed and enjoyed by all. Great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I come here multiple times in a month for the family!! Great location and people and they deliver to the country side if needed!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this pizza. A close by go to for us. Never disappoints!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Disappointed, to begin i am from chicago and thin crust is a place to go to. but i tried it and it might be my last time trying this pizza. The sauce was sweet from different slices and sausage had no season. I rate the pizza 2 out of 5.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Quite possibly the best pizza in the Rockford area. Frankie and his family are great people too. I highly recommend this spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza, Cheesy Garlic Bread Sticks, Everything Special
We have driven by this place weekly on our way to the free Wednesday Blues shows at the Burpee Museum, and finally had the chance to drop in after Red White and Blues Fest to honor veterans at Lyran Park this last Saturday.This is in the corner of a strip mall, close to Holcomb Bank. You pull off onto a frontage road, and then into the strip mall. More than adequate free parking is available.We were greeted at the door, and seated promptly. I had their Root Beer (which never got a chance to be empty - the server was very attentive) and my wife had their unsweetened tea and had the same service.Looking around the place, you have TVs (2) and décor on the walls, from spoons to pictures to signs. There is a Bullshooter dart game, and a Big Buck Hunter flat screen deer and other critter (including ZOMBIES!) hunting game. Some pictures are of customers, as the restaurant considers everyone who comes in for food part of their family. Speaking of service, our server informed us (apart in time, since I was using the rest room, which was very clean) that this is a woman owned business, and that the chef (the owners husband) makes sure the sauce and the crust are right for sensitive stomachs, and that everything from the dough to the sauce is made fresh daily. Talk about setting some high expectations.After looking through the menu, we decided to get their Everything Special Large pizza, which came with sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, green olives, pepperoni, bacon and anchovies.The pizza hit the table nice and hot, clearly fresh from the oven. Hint: Go after the corner pieces first - they cool faster, then the edge pieces.The crust is crispy which helps support the toppings and sauce, and since this pizza was loaded, it needed the support. However, that means you'll need to use your knife and fork if you are cutting up your squares of pizza to cool them off a bit.We had some leftovers and a nice foam box was provided for those. They reheated nicely the next day by the way.The owner came by and was checking in - we agreed the pizza was good. I think you will too!