Saylor Mick's Pizza & Pub
2020 US-12, Spring Grove
(815) 581-0190
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Their Broasted Chicken Dinner is fantastic.
Food: 5
Came in as first time guests. Place was almost completely empty except for a small party in the back that was leaving. Thought it was unusual for a Saturday. Sat at a high top. Took the bartender (there were 3) about 5 minutes to come over. We ordered the egg rolls as an appetizer and a medium thin 2-top pizza along with a soda and beer. Got the drinks but the soda was wrong with either the wrong drink or too much syrup. A runner delivered all the food at once. Asked for a water to replace the soda. Runner brought the water. Bartender never came back to refill either drink. We paid and left. Will Order pizza for take out in the future but that’s all. Horrible service when they weren’t even busy. Maybe 10 people in the place the whole time.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
great atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was delicious, service was friendly and attentive. Loud music detracted from the atmosphere a bit.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Me and my mom went there tonight for fish.Absolutely the worst ever. The fish was bland and greasy. We will not return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
The staff here is a step above most places-they make you feel like you belong there. The pizza is wonderful, however the rest of the menu is only slightly above average. Cool open vibe with sports on the many TVs, music, and three pool tables. Great local sports bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
First time and definitely not the last. Wife and I ordered boneless wings and 16” pepperoni, sausage, bacon thin crust pizza. Food was great, beer was cold. No complaints! Place was crowded and everyone seemed to enjoy themselves. Btw Andy you rock!!😎
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you're looking for a laid-back spot with seriously good food and welcoming vibes, this place nails it. From the moment we walked in, we felt like regulars—thanks in large part to the owner's son, who went out of his way to make sure we had everything we needed. Friendly, genuine, and clearly passionate about the place—he’s a big part of what makes this joint special.
Now let’s talk food: the pizza is absolutely killer—crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and fresh toppings that hit just right. But the real star of the show? The HUGE pretzels. We're talking soft, warm, and perfectly salted with just the right amount of chew. Pair one with a cold draft beer or their house-made dipping sauces, and you've got a winner.
Great atmosphere, even better service, and food that keeps you coming back. Whether you're catching a game, grabbing a casual dinner, or just in the mood for a great pretzel and a pint, this place delivers every time.
Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizzas were late. Driver got lost. I understand how it goes as I use to deliver when I was young. I felt bad for the kid and gave a 20.00 tip. Then he almost left the pizza bag afterwards. We got in the house, opened the pizzas up and both were dropped at some point. Pizzas were mushed all the way to one side and inedible... Horrible that he did not tell us that happened when we gave him a 20$ tip.. Very rude and dishonest. The kid seemed very nervous and in a hurry, we see why now.. Called the place and they said they would speak to management and call back. No call back. Will be going in there today for full refund.
It's pretty sad and also pretty telling when the bartender offers to buy our entire meal because the son of the owner is too busy socializing instead of cooking.
We ordered a double dough pizza. The place was NOT busy and yet it took over a half hour to get a football shaped, non-double dough pizza with the wrong toppings. After the bartender reluctantly dropped the pizza at our table, we looked at the football and didn't touch it. We thought she brought us the wrong pizza. She returned quickly, knowing it wasn't ok, and offered to cover our bill while we waited for another one. She said she has had multiple problems with the owners son not taking the business seriously.
We decided not to wait for another pizza and just wanted to pay for our appetizer so we could tip her, as we didn't bring cash. Then the owners son comes over and tells us that there is nothing wrong with the Pizza but still offered to make another one while we waited.
Here was the kicker. He thought it was a good idea to tell us he was the owners son, and that we were wrong about the pizza and that it was indeed a double dough crust, when it very clearly wasn't AND had the wrong toppings on it.
Sorry guys. But the fact that THE OWNERS SON is a part of that operation means we won't be going back.
Restaurantji Recommends
I booked a party here a few weeks ago. It was for 20-25. The owner I spoke was super nice when booking and gave me all the info I needed. I was so excited. Party day arrived. I was a wreck and nothing was going the way I had planned . Nothing to do with the restaurant just outside things including only 6 people showing up. I had pre ordered 6 large pizzas that we didn’t obviously need that many. They were already cooked and came out before people arrived. Due to my planning wrong. Everyone went above and beyond and was more than accommodating. They remade the pizzas at no charge when the guests that came did arrive. I was in tears and overwhelmed but the way everything was handled helped relieve some stress and anxiety. Definitely recommend and will be coming back to host another event here in the future! Oh yeah and pizza was beyond amazing according to my son with autism who is picky with pizza lol 🤣
Service was great!! Food was very good. Highly recommend!!
Place was packed, 2 parties happening. One server and 2 bartenders. Drinks took a long time for table service and so did the food. Understandable with one server. Our of initial order so ordered fish fry with potato pancakes. Tarter sauce was basically just mayo and pancakes tasted burnt. Requested apple sauce, came with mold. Asked for a manager and was told one was not on duty. That could explain the very loud music (it was only 6:30) and extreamly messy bathrooms.
Such a great bar and good food! Sam Is my favorite bartender! She’s always so attentive whether it’s crazy busy or a slower time! She always makes customers feel seen and their needs met! Definitely will be back!!
Friendly staff and the best Italian beef I’ve ever had. Wisconsin should consider themselves lucky to be so close
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...