Papi's Pizza Pub

1710 S MacArthur Blvd, Springfield
(217) 921-7274

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kelly Briseno

Outstanding!!!! My husband asked for pizza and said “whatever you do don’t bring home another pepperoni I want something different”. Found Papi’s on DoorDash, so many different pizzas it was hard to choose! Ordered the Tropical and a Taco and a cheese bread for me. The Papi’s sauce is AMAZING and the combo of the tropical was unbelievably delicious! Even their ale son a taco was the best taco pizza ever! Will def be ordering again and can’t wait to try others!!

Kaylee

Got delivery and it's not very good. I ordered light sauce, and it was not light, I can't imagine what their normal amount is. Tasted like cheap frozen pizza.

Food: 2

Angie Dunning

Delivery of flatbread, garlic bread and garlic parmesan wings. The garlic bread was edible, but the dipping sauce has the consistency of wet concrete. The wings, wow. Just awful. Cold, soggy and looked like they were puked on. Just awful. Definitely not worth $50 (with tip)

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Billy Allen

Great food and price. Service was excellent but unfortunately I didn't catch the name of the lady that was waiting tables and bartending. She was excellent. She was working at 6:00 P.M. on Tuesday October 22nd if the owners are reading this and are curious. Atmosphere was great. Loved our whole experience. There was 6 of us and everyone was completely satisfied. Will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Molly Hatchett

I just ordered from this restaurant. I'm sorry to say, however you want and order your pizza seems irrelevant in my experience. I ordered a "margarita pizza" which universally is: tomatoes, basil, mozzarella, and sauce. I got a pizza hard crust, no cheese except a few crumbs of GOAT CHEESE, WITH A HOT KIND OF HABANERO SAUCE ALL OVER THE TOP! I know not all pizzas are the same when they have universal labels, but the photo in the menu is classic margarita pizza. Not sure why they'd put whatever on it. I also customized it on Doordash. Hungry tonight I guess. ?‍♀️

Food: 1

Service: 1

William Skaggs

Great Atmosphere, Great food! 10/10 We will be back!

Sarah Maddox Graham

Papi’s did a great job accommodating a baseball team last minute. Also great pizza and good service.

John

Wings took 15 longer than pizza, but in the end were decent.
Pizza was cold and undercooked; Italian sausage was spicy.
Service was dismissive at best.
Been a few times and food/service has been ok - hopefully this was just a bad night.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Brittany

Thought this place was great. I was fully expecting a commercial/chain restaurant from the outside, so I was pleasantly surprised by the more local bar/restaurant feel inside. Pizza was delicious, had the hot honey with chicken. Also had an order of hot wings. I prefer my wings to have some crunch or crisp, just some minor feedback. Would love to see this place fill up more and could see it as a nice bar hangout and good for catching a game on the big screens . The menu has plenty of options (pizza, wings, apps, sandwiches, and dessert). Will certainly be back ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pacert Smith

Went here Friday afternoon around 130pm. First time here, but had heard good things. The young man that took our oder was great. The goat cheese salad is hands down the best salad I have ever had ( minus the onions). Our pizza took a little longer to get to our table, but it wasn't me that complained. The young man came to my table and apologized for the wait, but again I had not said a word. Now this is where things go from I like this place, to I love this place. Without missing a beat, he said the salads are on the house. I remind you thar I was perfectly fine with the wait. The pizza is amazing. The service us amazing. All 3 gentlemen there thanked us for coming in. This is what a good customer experience should be like. Another gentlemen came in looking for a job..not that I was being nosey, but we were the only table there at the time so it was easy to hear. Instead of the employee being rude and dismissive to the man, he actually sat and talked to him. He was kind and genuinely interested to talk to him. I was completely blown away. In a time when people are so mean to each other, this was refreshing. I will definitely go back . Thank you for the amazing service, and the great food. Job well done. This place deserves 10 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebecca Lynn

We were not impressed with their food. The salads were served with plastic forks and knives which made them hard to eat. The sandwiches and pizzas we ordered were flavorless and overcooked. We won’t be back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Casisyum

The best pizza I’ve had in a while and it was fresh and hot!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rodney Yoswig

Grabbed a to go order, pizza and salad were pretty good.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Suha Snober

I ordered 5 large pizzas for my son birthday party, and it was the worst pizza every one in the party eat ever.

Food: 1

Michael David Taapken

Terrible and rude customer service,messed up my order and then lied about offering online ordering for delivery even though they do on their website on then hung up on me

Loading...