Aurelio's Pizza Tinley Park

Elly and the staff at Aurelio’s went above and beyond to ensure that our luncheon following our son’s baptism went off without a hitch! The pizza and appetizers are always delicious, but the atmosphere in the party room made the food taste even better. Would highly recommend utilizing this restaurant for your family parties!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Worst pizza EVER. They don't use the same sauce, sausage or cheese as the original Aurelios!!!!
Just does not have that taste, i actually got an upset stomach 3 slices into it ? !! I will never order from tinlry or go there again. Homewood Aurelios is the BEST!!!

Great food and friendly staff! My west coast kids have to have it every time they visit!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good food. Pizza was Aurelio's to "T". Awesome spread and the staff was attentive and friendly. And bilingual. Our server went above and beyond to make us feel welcome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet

good pizza

I came with family for my nieces birthday. We did get there a couple hours before closing, but they were aware we were coming. The pizza taste completely different from the delicious Aurelio’s pizza place in Homewood. That spot was a 10 out of 10 in every way so to come here and be completely disappointed like this was insane. The pizza at this place seemed a tad bit undercooked. The crust was very soft and flimsy. While I do understand that they probably rushed because it was Sunday and they had to close by 9 I would have still hoped that they did their absolute best to make sure things were top tier! The waitress was extremely nice so I won’t add her name but what I will say is the worst part of my experience their was when I ordered wings to go (because their wings are to die for or at least the ones at the other spot in Homewood are) and the waiter asked if I wanted boneless or bone in…I hate ANYTHING without a bone and I have never in my entire life purchased boneless chicken in any form so naturally I said BONE-IN. I’ll give her the benefit of the doubt and say she just didn’t hear me correctly. I sent my husband into the restaurant because I came outside after ordering the wings to wait on the rest of my family to be done. By the time I sent him in for the wings majority of my family if not all had already come out and I had just remembered my wings. My husband pays for them and then hurry’s to leave because they are closing. Once I get all the way across the world to my home the place is now closed and these people have made me boneless chicken (because those are not WINGS!) when I say the amount for those bite size droplets that I NEVER ORDER really sent me! I literally only agreed to eat there because of the BONE-IN wings! Since my money 16 dollars and some change paid for those 6 pieces of nothing I tried to eat it. Keep in mind I already DO NOT LIKE boneless chicken. They were extremely soft and artificial tasting (part of the reason I DONT EAT BONELESS CHICKEN) I had a small bite and just trashed them! I would have loved a refund but I live no where remotely close to that place so I just took the loss and said well…. I’ll Write a honest review instead!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

I ordered a pizza with sausage, green peppers, onions and mushrooms.
What I got was exactly that , but the sause tasted spoiled , the cheese was very different from any pizza I’ve ever had, and the crust was….unusual to say the least. Like cornbread or similar. I paid $35 and tossed it in the trash after just a couple of bites. I called them and said there was something terribly wrong with the pizza because it tasted extremely unusual. I was told “you can have a $17.50 future credit ! So I lose 1/2 the price I paid ? When I finally went to get another pizza thinking that terrible pizza couldn’t happen twice, I was told NO, you will have to settle for $16 Credit.
Keep in mind, I paid $35, they messed up the pizza and I lose my $. Never going back. Very bad customer service or consideration. They never even asked what was wrong with the pizza. They didn’t care. It was almost like they had this same complaint many time before.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Can't comment on the pizza but they wouldn't let me place a pick up order without giving a credit card over the phone. Explained I couldn't do that in this situation but was only 8 minutes away.
Wouldn't cut me an exception for a $51 order so they missed out on our business. So dumb

Service: 1

Went for lunch buffet. Decent for the price but nothing special. Had a weird combination of dishes. Soup was fantastic.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Chicken Minestrone Soup

So glad that arelio's brought back their lunch buffet. Everything was very good although it is not quite as extensive as it was before. The buffet consisted of sauteed vegetables, spaghetti breaded chicken strips, a salad bar dessert. Soup and 4 types of pizza. The price is reasonable and the staff was beyond friendly. This food was high quality and the atmosphere was wonderful. The staff particularly our server who. Also served as the hostess was an absolute sweet girl. Thank you, arilio's. I would recommend to my family and friends. I look forward to coming back soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place has the best garlic parm wings in the world

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The buffet was perfect! They even had antipasto salad.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a private luncheon party here and Ellie & her staff were great! The hot pizzas kept coming and there was plenty of food for our guests, at a reasonable price too. Very friendly and attentive staff. Thank you Ellie for making our memorial lunch go so smoothly!

Our server was very good, but management is not the best.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Decent place, friendly staff. Clean. The food was good. This was our first time actually eating in their restaurant. We have had their food several times before. They might want to reconsider their signs. Two younger boys had to use the washroom, so they found the sign that stated where the washroom was, but they stopped when the other sign said no one under 21 allowed in the room. Lol. Luckily, a staff member came over and directed them to continue on to the washroom.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Family Thin Crust Sausage and Cheese Pizza, Garlic Bread