Amazing! I got the RUSTIC cut, because I like it thicker but I have had the classic and it's also great. Was fast fresh and awesome. So happy I found a go to pizza place !!
Amanda
FREE PIZZA!?!?! Download Nancy’s app sign up to get emails and in a few minutes you’ll get a free small pizza with a purchase of an appetizer! That is a great deal especially when we’re all broke as we are. Thanks Biden!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paige W.
After being referred to Nancy's by my dad's friend I finally tried this pizza for the first time and I wish I had tried sooner, it's one of the BEST I've ever had in my life. Addicted already!!! Friendly staff also.
Judie J.
We used to order from the old owners in Tinley of Nancy Pizza. This is the 2nd and last time I will order from this New Nancy's. Pizza was both times as close to being burnt that is humanly possible! Plus $42 for a 16" pizza is insane! Wish the quality would have been worth it!!
Busya
Picked up a pizza to go. The food food is just meh. The middle of the pizza was raw. Pizza sauce really has no flavor. The kids running the front of the house are incredibly rude and off-putting. Very short and unfriendly to me as well as the other customers. Either train them how to be polite or simply replace them. Between subpar food and obnoxious kids in the frong, we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mike Schwaller
Closed for 5 months for a "makeover," once more this 'new' Nancy's location doesn't disappoint! The service was fast, on time and very courteous. Oh yeah- the food was great too! As for "atmosphere" for a carry out place they did a great job on the "makeover." Compliments to the guy who waited on me, couldn't have been nicer. Thanks! I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roasted Italian Beef, Onion Rings, The Godmother, The Original Stuffed Pizza
M
Ordered a family extra thin pizza & the outer pizza was delicious, however the middle was raw. It's also a little pricey so we might try again but not anytime soon.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Robert Oostema (Walker Bob)
I really wish when they remodeled here that they would have added a dine in option. Love the food wish there was dine in.Vegetarian options: They have no problem providing no meat options. My wife is vegetarian and she is happy with the salads. She is ok with cheese but I think she would love a vegan cheese option.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
Thor Power
I've been ordering from Tinley park for years, after the remodel they do not deliver to my address and tried the pizza twice and it changed not for the better. The crust and sauce is different not as good. Ohh well I will order again later to see it changes back to normal, also the prices are kinda high.
Food: 2
Service: 3
stephanie paige
One of the best deep dish we’ve ever had. The thin crust is really good too <3
during reminding we tried plenty of pizzas, none compared to nancy's, but they finally opened, could not wait to order... yum, but to my surprise, it was the worst and honestly didn't even seem like a nancy's pizza. We have been a customer for years. They explained , because i called, that that's how corporate wants it. ☹️☹️☹️☹️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scarlet Andonov
Patiently waiting for the to reopen. Best pizza around!
kelly f
It’s been 2 months!!I miss my Friday night Nancys pizza!!!When will you be reopening?
Larry G.
Great pizza but you need to take a loan out to get one. Also their large stuffed is a 12 inch while most places are 14 inches.
eric johnson
There stuffed pizza is good.However, if you say you open at 4pm and I call at 430pm and nobody answers the phone that's a big strike.Has happened a few times.Get it together.
Amazing! I got the RUSTIC cut, because I like it thicker but I have had the classic and it's also great. Was fast fresh and awesome. So happy I found a go to pizza place !!
FREE PIZZA!?!?! Download Nancy’s app sign up to get emails and in a few minutes you’ll get a free small pizza with a purchase of an appetizer! That is a great deal especially when we’re all broke as we are. Thanks Biden!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After being referred to Nancy's by my dad's friend I finally tried this pizza for the first time and I wish I had tried sooner, it's one of the BEST I've ever had in my life. Addicted already!!! Friendly staff also.
We used to order from the old owners in Tinley of Nancy Pizza. This is the 2nd and last time I will order from this New Nancy's. Pizza was both times as close to being burnt that is humanly possible! Plus $42 for a 16" pizza is insane! Wish the quality would have been worth it!!
Picked up a pizza to go. The food food is just meh. The middle of the pizza was raw. Pizza sauce really has no flavor. The kids running the front of the house are incredibly rude and off-putting. Very short and unfriendly to me as well as the other customers. Either train them how to be polite or simply replace them. Between subpar food and obnoxious kids in the frong, we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Closed for 5 months for a "makeover," once more this 'new' Nancy's location doesn't disappoint! The service was fast, on time and very courteous. Oh yeah- the food was great too! As for "atmosphere" for a carry out place they did a great job on the "makeover." Compliments to the guy who waited on me, couldn't have been nicer. Thanks! I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roasted Italian Beef, Onion Rings, The Godmother, The Original Stuffed Pizza
Ordered a family extra thin pizza & the outer pizza was delicious, however the middle was raw. It's also a little pricey so we might try again but not anytime soon.
Food: 3
Service: 3
I really wish when they remodeled here that they would have added a dine in option. Love the food wish there was dine in.Vegetarian options: They have no problem providing no meat options. My wife is vegetarian and she is happy with the salads. She is ok with cheese but I think she would love a vegan cheese option.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
I've been ordering from Tinley park for years, after the remodel they do not deliver to my address and tried the pizza twice and it changed not for the better. The crust and sauce is different not as good. Ohh well I will order again later to see it changes back to normal, also the prices are kinda high.
Food: 2
Service: 3
One of the best deep dish we’ve ever had. The thin crust is really good too <3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
during reminding we tried plenty of pizzas, none compared to nancy's, but they finally opened, could not wait to order... yum, but to my surprise, it was the worst and honestly didn't even seem like a nancy's pizza. We have been a customer for years. They explained , because i called, that that's how corporate wants it. ☹️☹️☹️☹️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patiently waiting for the to reopen. Best pizza around!
It’s been 2 months!!I miss my Friday night Nancys pizza!!!When will you be reopening?
Great pizza but you need to take a loan out to get one. Also their large stuffed is a 12 inch while most places are 14 inches.
There stuffed pizza is good.However, if you say you open at 4pm and I call at 430pm and nobody answers the phone that's a big strike.Has happened a few times.Get it together.