The pizza is the best in town in our opinion. Big Tomato is a long-time favorite of ours. They lose a star because delivery is chronically late. If we order for pick-up, they're really timely. Delivery is a problem. It's become routine for us to call 15 minutes after our order was due and have the delivery made a few minutes after we call. How long has our food been sitting there before they have to be reminded to deliver it? It's incredibly frustrating. Recommend you schedule your delivery order for much earlier than you need it, then plan to call them to remind them to send it out.
Jennifer McDonough
The absolute kindess owner! Pizza is delicious and Alberto makes special shaped pizzas for our daughter that is special needs.Vegetarian options: Fresh ingredientsKid-friendliness: My daughter can’t wait to see Alberto and has her birthday parties there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garden Salad, House Salad, Vegetarian Pizza, Kids Pizza
Artsiom Shalonik
Bought it because of many good reviews. Took it to go. Pizza wasn’t cooked long enough. Cheese was salty. I don’t understand why the place has so many good reviews. Probably because of the price. It’s low.We couldn’t eat it. I’m
Food: 1
Richard M.
Favorite family place in Wilmette. Great spinach pan pizza! Wonderful service, friendly. BYOB too. Nice people running a comfy restaurant at good prices.
Ana A. Ayala
Most delicious pizza we've had! The crust is thin, extra crispy and flavourful. Definitely recommend.Kid-friendliness: Loved the dino, butterfly, teddy themed pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Catie Huggins
The delivery times have become ridiculous. Slice notified me it was on its way at five minutes to 7. It's now 7:30. My kid's prefer this because it's definitely kid friendly- cracker crust, not spicy. But Lefty's is tastier and faster!! The 5 year old will have to get over the dino shaped slice.Kid-friendliness: Dino shaped pizza
Food: 3
Eliza Stubbs
So confused why this place has so many stars?! The pizza is like cardboard. Absolutely the worst we've ever had - reminds me of school pizza (the kind you had on a cracker). Definitely will not order from here again.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Jana Bennett
We LOVE Big Tomato pizza! Truly my favorite. Al is so kind, and it’s a big hit with all of my students! I’m also a fan of their salads and soups. You cannot go wrong at Big Tomato!
Brian J
Great pizza and pasta. Friendly staff and owner. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for cheaper options compared to Napolita.
Emily ET McLean
We love Big Tomato pizza. Their pizza is straightforward and delicious at a fair price. We usually do delivery, and they've always arrived ahead of their estimated time. On our last order, they accidently sent us mozzarella sticks instead of the fries. I called to let them know, they apologized for the mistake, gave me the option of a refund or a delayed delivery of the fries, and let us keep the mozzarella sticks. We opted to wait for fries, and they arrived within 10 minutes. They showed that they cared about our experience, which means everything. Thanks, Big Tomato! We'll be back.
Great service, very kind. We got the Philly style pizza (unsure what it was called); it was delicious and would recommend. My husband and I ate the entire large in one sitting. They also gave our toddler a cute little cheese pizza. Their food is egg allergy friendly (only egg is in Alfredo sauce). Their bathrooms are baby/toddler friendly and they have toys.
Emma Tumminello
We love Big Tomato pizza. Their pizza is straightforward and delicious at a fair price. We usually do delivery, and they've always arrived ahead of their estimated time. On our last order, they accidently sent us mozzarella sticks instead of the fries. I called to let them know, they apologized for the mistake, gave me the option of a refund or a delayed delivery of the fries, and let us keep the mozzarella sticks. We opted to wait for fries, and they arrived within 10 minutes. They showed that they cared about our experience, which means everything. Thanks, Big Tomato! We'll be back.
rebecca rodriguez
We love Big Tomato Pizzeria! It always tastes great and the crust is so yummy!
Marc Butiong
Big Tomato will always be a staple in the realm of pizza. Their pan is always consistently delicious and we always leave feeling full. The price is just right and they prepare the pizzas wonderfully. 5 stars!!!
Angela P.
This place is such a hidden gem! The deep dish is amazing and it's BYOB!! It's great!! It's kid friendly a great place for a bite after the movies or something. I've been coming here for years and will never stop. If you want the best deep dish pizza, you need to try this place!
The pizza is the best in town in our opinion. Big Tomato is a long-time favorite of ours. They lose a star because delivery is chronically late. If we order for pick-up, they're really timely. Delivery is a problem. It's become routine for us to call 15 minutes after our order was due and have the delivery made a few minutes after we call. How long has our food been sitting there before they have to be reminded to deliver it? It's incredibly frustrating. Recommend you schedule your delivery order for much earlier than you need it, then plan to call them to remind them to send it out.
The absolute kindess owner! Pizza is delicious and Alberto makes special shaped pizzas for our daughter that is special needs.Vegetarian options: Fresh ingredientsKid-friendliness: My daughter can’t wait to see Alberto and has her birthday parties there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garden Salad, House Salad, Vegetarian Pizza, Kids Pizza
Bought it because of many good reviews. Took it to go. Pizza wasn’t cooked long enough. Cheese was salty. I don’t understand why the place has so many good reviews. Probably because of the price. It’s low.We couldn’t eat it. I’m
Food: 1
Favorite family place in Wilmette. Great spinach pan pizza! Wonderful service, friendly. BYOB too. Nice people running a comfy restaurant at good prices.
Most delicious pizza we've had! The crust is thin, extra crispy and flavourful. Definitely recommend.Kid-friendliness: Loved the dino, butterfly, teddy themed pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The delivery times have become ridiculous. Slice notified me it was on its way at five minutes to 7. It's now 7:30. My kid's prefer this because it's definitely kid friendly- cracker crust, not spicy. But Lefty's is tastier and faster!! The 5 year old will have to get over the dino shaped slice.Kid-friendliness: Dino shaped pizza
Food: 3
So confused why this place has so many stars?! The pizza is like cardboard. Absolutely the worst we've ever had - reminds me of school pizza (the kind you had on a cracker). Definitely will not order from here again.
Food: 1
Service: 5
We LOVE Big Tomato pizza! Truly my favorite. Al is so kind, and it’s a big hit with all of my students! I’m also a fan of their salads and soups. You cannot go wrong at Big Tomato!
Great pizza and pasta. Friendly staff and owner. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for cheaper options compared to Napolita.
We love Big Tomato pizza. Their pizza is straightforward and delicious at a fair price. We usually do delivery, and they've always arrived ahead of their estimated time. On our last order, they accidently sent us mozzarella sticks instead of the fries. I called to let them know, they apologized for the mistake, gave me the option of a refund or a delayed delivery of the fries, and let us keep the mozzarella sticks. We opted to wait for fries, and they arrived within 10 minutes. They showed that they cared about our experience, which means everything. Thanks, Big Tomato! We'll be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garden Salad, Cheese Pizza Thin Crust Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Great service, very kind. We got the Philly style pizza (unsure what it was called); it was delicious and would recommend. My husband and I ate the entire large in one sitting. They also gave our toddler a cute little cheese pizza. Their food is egg allergy friendly (only egg is in Alfredo sauce). Their bathrooms are baby/toddler friendly and they have toys.
We love Big Tomato pizza. Their pizza is straightforward and delicious at a fair price. We usually do delivery, and they've always arrived ahead of their estimated time. On our last order, they accidently sent us mozzarella sticks instead of the fries. I called to let them know, they apologized for the mistake, gave me the option of a refund or a delayed delivery of the fries, and let us keep the mozzarella sticks. We opted to wait for fries, and they arrived within 10 minutes. They showed that they cared about our experience, which means everything. Thanks, Big Tomato! We'll be back.
We love Big Tomato Pizzeria! It always tastes great and the crust is so yummy!
Big Tomato will always be a staple in the realm of pizza. Their pan is always consistently delicious and we always leave feeling full. The price is just right and they prepare the pizzas wonderfully. 5 stars!!!
This place is such a hidden gem! The deep dish is amazing and it's BYOB!! It's great!! It's kid friendly a great place for a bite after the movies or something. I've been coming here for years and will never stop. If you want the best deep dish pizza, you need to try this place!