J. Miller Steak Company
$$ • Steakhouses, American, Cocktail Bar
Hours:
211 2nd St, Aurora
(812) 926-1772
About J. Miller Steak Company
Customers' Favorites
J. Miller Steak Company Reviews
Share your opinion about J. Miller Steak Company
We decided to use a gift card we received from Christmas and so glad we did,service was great and so friendly , the wedge salad was delicious with the best blue cheese dressing I’ve ever had! So sweet of the waitress to ask if my grandson could have a sucker after he ate.
Medium rare steak came out extra well done, on the 2nd try medium rare steak came out mooing. As well as sweet tea was terrible, Caesar salad was comparable to Kroger bagged lettuce with dressing. Another medium rare steak for another person at our table comes out well extra well done, the second time it came back well done. The rice that came out with the salmon was crunchy. At least they gave a discount though.
We had dinner on New Years Eve. No reservation, but they said it would be 20 minutes before we could order because of a large party. That was no problem, appreciated the honesty and had a drink at the bar. This was our 1st time here, and we highly recommend it, and definitely will be back. The staff is awesome, very friendly and polite and the food was exceptional. Very neat place.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 5 - 8PM |
| Friday | 5 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 8PM |
People in Aurora Also Viewed
J. Miller Steak Company provides a mix of experiences for diners. Recent reviews highlight excellent service, with attentive and friendly staff making guests feel welcomed and cared for. The atmosphere is described as great, historic, and inviting, creating a warm environment for special occasions. The restaurant is praised for its flavorful filet, well-cooked steaks, and superb ribeye, which guests enjoyed without any issues. The strip steak is also a highlight, cooked to perfection with a smoky flavor. A complimentary birthday cheesecake adds a nice touch to celebrations. The staff, including servers like Melissa, are outstanding and attentive. The restaurant offers a pleasant dining experience, though some feel the portion sizes and pricing could be better aligned. Overall, J. Miller Steak Company is a good choice for good food and friendly service, with room for improvement in portion sizes and value.