This will be a mixed review… I’ll rate each item by category.Deep Dish Pizza 3 out of 5. It definitely wasn’t Chicago style deep dish but the flavor was very good! The photo showed like a deep bowl / pie style which is traditionally Chicago deep dish, what we got was much different than advertised. That’s the only reason I would drop it to a 3.Garlic Bread 5 out of 5 ExcellentHot wings 1 out of 5 poor. They had only a slight drizzle of sauce across them, it was a very sad display, nothing like Wingstop. I expected much more out of a Chicago Pizza place.Spaghetti 1 out of 5. It was watery, not seasoned, noodles tasted microwaved, not much sauce, definitely not authentic Fresh Italian. Spaghetti Os are much better.Regular Breadsticks 2 out of 5. They were hard, tasteless, no seasoning.Sauces 3 out of 5. Ranch was very good, Garlic Butter was tasty and the Nacho Cheese and Marinara was good.It saddens me to have to give a 3 out of 5 but I am averaging the food.If I find out changes are made to the other food items I would be happy to try it again and tempted to give up to a 5 out of 5 as some items were very good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Skull Hunter
First of all, really misleading. When you order a deep dish pizza. It is not a deep dish pizza. It's just a normal, Since the name of the restaurant is Chicago pizza, you order a deep dish pizza? You're imagining, it's a Chicago style deep dish and it is not. With that, we ordered spaghetti that was overcooked and very watery, garlic bread, that was all right.Let me be clear. The pizza was very good, but it was not what I expected. I think they would be amazing if they integrated Chicago deep dish style pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Brittney R.
This will be a mixed review... I'll rate each item by category. Deep Dish Pizza 3 out of 5. It definitely wasn't Chicago style deep dish but the flavor was very good! The photo showed like a deep bowl / pie style which is traditionally Chicago deep dish, what we got was much different than advertised. That's the only reason I would drop it to a 3. Garlic Bread 5 out of 5 Excellent Hot wings 1 out of 5 poor. They had only a slight drizzle of sauce across them, it was a very sad display, nothing like Wingstop. I expected much more out of a Chicago Pizza place. Spaghetti 1 out of 5. It was watery, not seasoned, noodles tasted microwaved, not much sauce, definitely not authentic Fresh Italian. Spaghetti Os are much better. Regular Breadsticks 2 out of 5. They were hard, tasteless, no seasoning. Sauces 3 out of 5. Ranch was very good, Garlic Butter was tasty and the Nacho Cheese and Marinara was good. It saddens me to have to give a 3 out of 5 but I am averaging the food. If I find out changes are made to the other food items I would be happy to try it again and tempted to give up to a 5 out of 5 as some items were very good.
Jordan M.
First of all, really misleading. When you order a deep dish pizza. It is not a deep dish pizza. It's just a normal, Since the name of the restaurant is Chicago pizza, you order a deep dish pizza? You're imagining, it's a Chicago style deep dish and it is not. With that, we ordered spaghetti that was overcooked and very watery, garlic bread, that was all right. Let me be clear. The pizza was very good, but it was not what I expected. I think they would be amazing if they integrated Chicago deep dish style pizza
JE S
This is a place from back in time it seams. Remember growing up actually sitting in a pizza place enjoying the jukebox playing and eating fresh and delicious pizza. This is that place. Staff are all great, very friendly, always checking in to see if you need anything. Very clean restaurant. This pizza just melts in your mouth. Bursting with fresh flavors. This is a Skyline hand tossed. Just a great place and I'm glad I stopped in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pamela P.
Pricing outrageous for the quality of this pizza. Though we were the only people in restaurant the waitress did not check on us or offer drink refills. Literally had to hunt her down. Red flags everywhere. Wish I'd have paid attention instead of spending nearly 60$ for 1 pizza, 2 orders of bread sticks and 2 sodas! Would not have minded the price if the food had been better and the staff wasn't rude and dismissive. I'll not make that mistake again.
Curt Durnil
Chicago’s Pizza has been a staple of Ellettsville since the late 80’s and for good reasons. The food, the service, the atmosphere and their support of the community. Wanna support local business? Chicago’s Pizza is the way to go!They make a calzone from scratch that is OUT OF THIS WORLD. I always get the Pepperoni Sausage & Mushroom and it is crazy good! The manager made sure we were served quickly and he even brought us our drinks.Great food, excellent service, and the staff was crazy helpful. Thank you so much for staying open and treating us like we were your most valuable customers!I recommend this Chicago’s, not just for the great pizza, but also for the customer service and the entire dining experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isaac Capshaw
You know it's not fine dinning but you know what to expect at a local pizza place such as this. I like consistency in my dinning experiences and this hits that button. I like supporting small locally owned businesses and this whas it. The whole family got full for a reasonable price. Good food, decent buffet, decent service, nice variety and on my trip the staff was top notch. Thank you for a good family lunch experience. I would recommend this spot in a heartbeat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Raw Pizza Buffet
Kim J “Wify” Enochs
Chicagos’s pizza is a ver family oriented restaurant! They welcome you with smiling faces and good customer service! They go above and beyond to do their jobs and do it to the best of their ability! They will do whatever it takes to make their customers happy and keep them coming back! We need more restaurants and employees like this one around Bloomington! I for sure recommend if you get the chance to stop by and check them out to do that!Vegetarian options: We have a veggie pizza that is very goodKid-friendliness: It is a good kid friendly place. They have kids menu, coloring sheets, crayons, and stickers for all the kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads, Party Pizza, Lasagna, Pepperoni Pizza, Meat Pizza
Angel Cat
We haven't dined-in since before COVID. We'd seen some stuff online that was negative awhile ago but thought we'd give them a chance. We'd been given a card for a free personal pizza only to be told that it was an hour too late to use it (personal pizzas are only served until 4, apparently). Ok, no big deal. I guess we'll use it next time. We went ahead and ordered. Our server was clearly not happy to be there and her young son was sitting at a separate booth watching TV. About 10 minutes after we ordered she left the building without a word to us. We sat another 20 minutes before another server asked us if she could get us anything. We asked her to check on our food. 10 minutes later (as the table close to us is served their food) we are asked by someone else to clarify our order. We waited another 20 minutes before asking about our food again. While waiting one of us used the restroom to find there was no hot water- even let it run for a bit. The napkin box on the table had a sticky residue and obvious dirt & grime, the cracks in the booth were full of dirt and junk, and the floor had food everywhere. (You have time to notice all of these things as you sit for an hour to get your food.) The food finally arrived and the young girl was doing what she could to make up for the wait. The food tasted pretty good and we were about 1/3 of the way into our food when we saw a cockroach crawling on our seat between us. We immediately got up, took a picture of the bug, and left our food. We walked to the register to be asked if we wanted a box. We said no and told them we saw a cockroach and wanted to pay and leave. The gentleman whom we told, offered to have the meal "on the house." We were really grateful to be able to leave quickly. We were really hoping they would have cleaned up their act. We're all so disgusted and won't be back even if the food was free. We left the card for the free pizza on the table.
tim did amazing with the gluten free pizza and got me a dessert pizza too!Dietary restrictions: celiac’s and he did great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Thomas F.
Thank you for the amazing pizza and breadsticks to celebrate our grandson's birthday with his kindergarten class. Delivered it exactly when we needed it. Will always use your place for any future get togethers. Tom and Kim Frazier
Ricky Shimkus
Owner rude, salad bar was messy and unattended. Place was full of used booths that never were cleaned while we were there and owner was rude. Won't be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Jennifer Dominguez
My boyfriend called to place an order and was told it would be a 70 minute wait, we called again when an hour and a half had passed. The worker had told us that they didn’t even place the order in the first place so we ended up canceling the order.
This will be a mixed review… I’ll rate each item by category.Deep Dish Pizza 3 out of 5. It definitely wasn’t Chicago style deep dish but the flavor was very good! The photo showed like a deep bowl / pie style which is traditionally Chicago deep dish, what we got was much different than advertised. That’s the only reason I would drop it to a 3.Garlic Bread 5 out of 5 ExcellentHot wings 1 out of 5 poor. They had only a slight drizzle of sauce across them, it was a very sad display, nothing like Wingstop. I expected much more out of a Chicago Pizza place.Spaghetti 1 out of 5. It was watery, not seasoned, noodles tasted microwaved, not much sauce, definitely not authentic Fresh Italian. Spaghetti Os are much better.Regular Breadsticks 2 out of 5. They were hard, tasteless, no seasoning.Sauces 3 out of 5. Ranch was very good, Garlic Butter was tasty and the Nacho Cheese and Marinara was good.It saddens me to have to give a 3 out of 5 but I am averaging the food.If I find out changes are made to the other food items I would be happy to try it again and tempted to give up to a 5 out of 5 as some items were very good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
First of all, really misleading. When you order a deep dish pizza. It is not a deep dish pizza. It's just a normal, Since the name of the restaurant is Chicago pizza, you order a deep dish pizza? You're imagining, it's a Chicago style deep dish and it is not. With that, we ordered spaghetti that was overcooked and very watery, garlic bread, that was all right.Let me be clear. The pizza was very good, but it was not what I expected. I think they would be amazing if they integrated Chicago deep dish style pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
This will be a mixed review... I'll rate each item by category. Deep Dish Pizza 3 out of 5. It definitely wasn't Chicago style deep dish but the flavor was very good! The photo showed like a deep bowl / pie style which is traditionally Chicago deep dish, what we got was much different than advertised. That's the only reason I would drop it to a 3. Garlic Bread 5 out of 5 Excellent Hot wings 1 out of 5 poor. They had only a slight drizzle of sauce across them, it was a very sad display, nothing like Wingstop. I expected much more out of a Chicago Pizza place. Spaghetti 1 out of 5. It was watery, not seasoned, noodles tasted microwaved, not much sauce, definitely not authentic Fresh Italian. Spaghetti Os are much better. Regular Breadsticks 2 out of 5. They were hard, tasteless, no seasoning. Sauces 3 out of 5. Ranch was very good, Garlic Butter was tasty and the Nacho Cheese and Marinara was good. It saddens me to have to give a 3 out of 5 but I am averaging the food. If I find out changes are made to the other food items I would be happy to try it again and tempted to give up to a 5 out of 5 as some items were very good.
First of all, really misleading. When you order a deep dish pizza. It is not a deep dish pizza. It's just a normal, Since the name of the restaurant is Chicago pizza, you order a deep dish pizza? You're imagining, it's a Chicago style deep dish and it is not. With that, we ordered spaghetti that was overcooked and very watery, garlic bread, that was all right. Let me be clear. The pizza was very good, but it was not what I expected. I think they would be amazing if they integrated Chicago deep dish style pizza
This is a place from back in time it seams. Remember growing up actually sitting in a pizza place enjoying the jukebox playing and eating fresh and delicious pizza. This is that place. Staff are all great, very friendly, always checking in to see if you need anything. Very clean restaurant. This pizza just melts in your mouth. Bursting with fresh flavors. This is a Skyline hand tossed. Just a great place and I'm glad I stopped in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pricing outrageous for the quality of this pizza. Though we were the only people in restaurant the waitress did not check on us or offer drink refills. Literally had to hunt her down. Red flags everywhere. Wish I'd have paid attention instead of spending nearly 60$ for 1 pizza, 2 orders of bread sticks and 2 sodas! Would not have minded the price if the food had been better and the staff wasn't rude and dismissive. I'll not make that mistake again.
Chicago’s Pizza has been a staple of Ellettsville since the late 80’s and for good reasons. The food, the service, the atmosphere and their support of the community. Wanna support local business? Chicago’s Pizza is the way to go!They make a calzone from scratch that is OUT OF THIS WORLD. I always get the Pepperoni Sausage & Mushroom and it is crazy good! The manager made sure we were served quickly and he even brought us our drinks.Great food, excellent service, and the staff was crazy helpful. Thank you so much for staying open and treating us like we were your most valuable customers!I recommend this Chicago’s, not just for the great pizza, but also for the customer service and the entire dining experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You know it's not fine dinning but you know what to expect at a local pizza place such as this. I like consistency in my dinning experiences and this hits that button. I like supporting small locally owned businesses and this whas it. The whole family got full for a reasonable price. Good food, decent buffet, decent service, nice variety and on my trip the staff was top notch. Thank you for a good family lunch experience. I would recommend this spot in a heartbeat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Raw Pizza Buffet
Chicagos’s pizza is a ver family oriented restaurant! They welcome you with smiling faces and good customer service! They go above and beyond to do their jobs and do it to the best of their ability! They will do whatever it takes to make their customers happy and keep them coming back! We need more restaurants and employees like this one around Bloomington! I for sure recommend if you get the chance to stop by and check them out to do that!Vegetarian options: We have a veggie pizza that is very goodKid-friendliness: It is a good kid friendly place. They have kids menu, coloring sheets, crayons, and stickers for all the kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads, Party Pizza, Lasagna, Pepperoni Pizza, Meat Pizza
We haven't dined-in since before COVID. We'd seen some stuff online that was negative awhile ago but thought we'd give them a chance. We'd been given a card for a free personal pizza only to be told that it was an hour too late to use it (personal pizzas are only served until 4, apparently). Ok, no big deal. I guess we'll use it next time. We went ahead and ordered. Our server was clearly not happy to be there and her young son was sitting at a separate booth watching TV. About 10 minutes after we ordered she left the building without a word to us. We sat another 20 minutes before another server asked us if she could get us anything. We asked her to check on our food. 10 minutes later (as the table close to us is served their food) we are asked by someone else to clarify our order. We waited another 20 minutes before asking about our food again. While waiting one of us used the restroom to find there was no hot water- even let it run for a bit. The napkin box on the table had a sticky residue and obvious dirt & grime, the cracks in the booth were full of dirt and junk, and the floor had food everywhere. (You have time to notice all of these things as you sit for an hour to get your food.) The food finally arrived and the young girl was doing what she could to make up for the wait. The food tasted pretty good and we were about 1/3 of the way into our food when we saw a cockroach crawling on our seat between us. We immediately got up, took a picture of the bug, and left our food. We walked to the register to be asked if we wanted a box. We said no and told them we saw a cockroach and wanted to pay and leave. The gentleman whom we told, offered to have the meal "on the house." We were really grateful to be able to leave quickly. We were really hoping they would have cleaned up their act. We're all so disgusted and won't be back even if the food was free. We left the card for the free pizza on the table.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
tim did amazing with the gluten free pizza and got me a dessert pizza too!Dietary restrictions: celiac’s and he did great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Thank you for the amazing pizza and breadsticks to celebrate our grandson's birthday with his kindergarten class. Delivered it exactly when we needed it. Will always use your place for any future get togethers. Tom and Kim Frazier
Owner rude, salad bar was messy and unattended. Place was full of used booths that never were cleaned while we were there and owner was rude. Won't be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
My boyfriend called to place an order and was told it would be a 70 minute wait, we called again when an hour and a half had passed. The worker had told us that they didn’t even place the order in the first place so we ended up canceling the order.
Service: 1
LOVE my CHICAGO'S pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5