Anthony’s Chophouse

201 W Main St, Carmel
(317) 740-0900

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Matt

Adam and Carter took care of us at our table. They were very helpful and attentive to making our dinner a memorable one. We will definitely be back.

Roy and Janet

Wonderful building and atmosphere. Excellent and attentive service. We received a personalized welcome card from staff in regard to our anniversary, plus complimentary champagne and dessert. Our order of chops and steak were prepared well, most and flavorful. We will definitely return.

Jordan

Celebrated our 11 year anniversary and everything was spectacular. Our server Anthony was knowledgeable and friendly and kept our glasses full. Our grass fed filets were cooked perfectly and the potato's were so creamy and flavorful. You HAVE to save room for the bourbon bread pudding though. Can't wait for our next visit.

Celeste

We had a wonderful time at Anthony's Chophouse. The wagyu meatballs were delicious and everything else tasted wonderful. Our server Olaf was very nice and made sure we were taken care of. We will definitely be back!

Christine

The food was excellent and we enjoyed not being rushed through the meal. We were given time to enjoy each course and our time together. The crab cakes were the best we've ever had and the macaroni and cheese is next level. The steaks were delicious and perfectly cooked.

Sarah

Food was amazing but honestly, the service level provided by Max pushed the entire experience over the top.

Liz

We were very disappointed with Anthony's especially since it was our first visit to this restaurant. We expected excellent service, food, and ambiance. We were celebrating our anniversary. We were seated at a larger table next to the kitchen with lots of activity happening right on top of us. It took our waiter at least 10 minutes before he even approached our table. He was inattentive throughout the dinner - didn't ask if we'd like another drink, didn't offer bread, etc. We received a note on the table wishing us a happy anniversary but the waiter never even mentioned it. We have tried many other upscale restaurants in the Carmel area for celebrations and Anthony's was a big disappointment.

Brad

Celebrated my son's first job and based on a friend's recommendation we made a reservation at Anthony's. Alex took great care of us. Even brought us some champagne to honor the occasion. I'm also celiac, so needed a few GF options and Alex navigated us through the menu. Definitely try the flight of steak! It was incredible.

Anne

The experience at restaurant was sheer perfection... the wagyu tartare and spinalis was amazing... save room for the bread pudding! We are always happy when Chris is our waiter!

Kirk

The food, ambiance, and service was IMPECCABLE! I would highly recommend this restaurant to all!

Zara

They no longer have the Halal options, which was really disappointing. It was extremely noisy. 

Danielle

Our server Sarah was exceptional. Our steaks prepared wonderfully. The Waygu tartare was excellent. Our only disappointment was the wedge salad, missed on flavor.

Erik

Visited for a 50th birthday celebration and everything was great. We were seated promptly, our waiter was fantastic, and the food and drinks were delicious. Thanks for the evening. We will definitely be returning!

Dave

We had a lovely dinner. Great good, extremely attentive service, nice atmosphere though just a bit loud.

Jimmy

It was our first time to Anthony's and we will be back. Very nice restaurant. The drinks were amazing! We really appreciated how each cocktail had a photo of the glass it came in. That's important to us. The wedge salad was the best I've ever had! It was packed with flavor. The bisque was savory and sweet. The crab cakes were very good and the mac and cheese was creamy with a slight kick of heat in some bites. I enjoyed my steak and the temp was perfect! It was pretty salty in parts and luckily the egg yolk cut down on that some. Still good though. Again, we will be coming back and looking forward to it. Staff was very nice and on top of things.

Loading...