This is my first time trying Classic Cakes. I can confidently say Classic Cakes will be my to go to cake shop for my wife’s and I wedding anniversaries and future special occasions. Staff were friendly and also seemed passionate about their work which added an extra layer of sweetness. The cake takes a rating from “Excellent” to “Beyond This World”. Here are my reasons: 1. The balance between cake, filling, and icing was just right. 2. The sweetness was the kind to enjoy and not the kind that makes someone stuffed. 3. My wife who has been sick with flu was actually able to enjoy it and taste all the goodness in it.
For those reasons I will be back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan Wiltgen
My wife and I are choosing Classic Cakes for our wedding cake simply because the new owner is Amazing! Shes efficient, has great communication, and her cakes are delicious, moist and wonderful. Highly recommend this business for any special occasion or simply for a cupcakes for a after dinner dessert. You wont be disappointed. ~Bryan W.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Woke Bae
5 stars because we are new here from GA and had high expectations lol I asked my friend who was the best for cake decorating and was told Classic Cakes. Perfectly Beautiful, delicious, and great timing. We had one pink heart with ribbons and an under the sea theme for my 4 year olds birthday and everyone asked for the cake place. I usually gate-keep my party info but I was glad to share the info with my guests.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristy Leary
Classic Cakes took our vision for our wedding cake and absolutely ran with it! It was everything we hoped for and more. Not to mention how delicious it was-- we got SO many compliments from guests. We can hardly wait a year to dig in to our top tier :) I'd recommend them a thousand times over!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roseline Cardenas
I hired this place for my wedding cake on 08/25. I tried many places and I really liked the taste of their cake, but unfortunately it was not what I ordered or what we had agreed on. The bakery had asked me to bring the flowers so they could place them on the cake, so I arrived at the venue at 1:55 pm (the rental started at 2:00 pm). However, when I got there, the cake had already been delivered before the agreed time, without any notice or communication. It was left there without decoration or flowers, which caused me a collapse with a lot of stress on my own wedding day. I had to find last-minute help to fix the situation. The cake tasted good, but the lack of communication, responsibility, and compliance left me deeply disappointed.
Karen Kari Wong
It taste just as good as it looks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Duchemin
We are so grateful to Classic Cakes for creating the most beautiful and delicious cake for our spring wedding! From the very beginning, they listened closely to our vision and truly brought it to life. We wanted a design that captured our wildflower theme — and they absolutely nailed it. The cake was not only stunning but felt like a perfect extension of the rest of our day. And the flavors... wow! The lemon and raspberry rose were both out of this world — light, fresh, and full of flavor. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about how good it was (and we completely agree)! Classic Cakes exceeded all of our expectations, both in taste and presentation. Thank you for being such an important and memorable part of our wedding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Glynis Armentrout
Why do your past employees report their payroll checks continuously bounced? 🤔 Sounds like theft.
Munni Begum
We placed an order for a wedding cake with Classic Cake online about 3-4 months ahead of time to give them plenty of time. Megan followed up with us promptly and offered several dates for taste checking. She was very professional and warm and brought all the flavors and fillings we requested for. On the event day the cake was delivered right on time and was sitting on the table when I entered the room. It was a beautiful scene to look. With her help we chose the perfect cake for our daughter's reception. The texture, flavor and above all the tase were awesome. We highly recommend Classic Cake for specialty events.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barb Summers
I purchased cakes from classic cakes for many many many years when my children were smaller and then into adulthood for birthdays, graduations, and other events. The cakes were always delicious and beautiful however, there is one designer that does not listen to what you ask for. When you tell her, the team colors are red, she made the cake green. When I told her I needed a sculpture of a specific dog and even sent a picture she made it anything but that dog. I realize that a certain amount of artistic license goes into this, but there were at least 10 times when the cakes were not what was ordered, and I didn’t say anything because I needed to pick them up and take them to the event the day that I picked them up and what do you do when the cake is wrong and you need it that day? Everybody said the cakes tasted good so we were fine, but it is disappointing to not get what you ordered.
Never responded to my inquiry for a quote. I received a thank you email stating that they would get back to me and never did. This was over 3 weeks ago. There is something going on with this company, things have drastically changed since changing ownership.
Rhyanne
Our wedding cake from Classic Cakes was beautifully done just the way we wanted it to look. The details were perfect, and the custom gum paste flowers were a great alternative to real flowers. We also received a lot of compliments from our guests on how delicious it was! During our tasting, we couldn’t choose just one flavor, so we were very happy to be able to pick two (classic white and red velvet). Both were very fresh and tasty!
There was a little difficulty with communication via e-mail, but Megan is a hard worker and her dedication to her business does not go unnoticed. The final product definitely did not fall short of our expectations. We would recommend Classic Cakes for any cake needs!
Eddie bankhead
We had a Cake tasting in preparation for an upcoming Graduation Open house. They make my wedding Cake and just as expected we experienced the best customer service, extremely great tasting Cake (best in Indy) and wonderful atmosphere
Danette H'Bey
It was great & tasty!
Chris Kelly
Megan and her team are amazing! They created a birthday cake for my wife that was simply stunning. Their attention to detail is second to none. Do yourself a favor and go to Classic Cakes. I promise you will not be disappointed.
This is my first time trying Classic Cakes. I can confidently say Classic Cakes will be my to go to cake shop for my wife’s and I wedding anniversaries and future special occasions. Staff were friendly and also seemed passionate about their work which added an extra layer of sweetness. The cake takes a rating from “Excellent” to “Beyond This World”. Here are my reasons:
1. The balance between cake, filling, and icing was just right.
2. The sweetness was the kind to enjoy and not the kind that makes someone stuffed.
3. My wife who has been sick with flu was actually able to enjoy it and taste all the goodness in it.
For those reasons I will be back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I are choosing Classic Cakes for our wedding cake simply because the new owner is Amazing! Shes efficient, has great communication, and her cakes are delicious, moist and wonderful. Highly recommend this business for any special occasion or simply for a cupcakes for a after dinner dessert. You wont be disappointed.
~Bryan W.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
5 stars because we are new here from GA and had high expectations lol I asked my friend who was the best for cake decorating and was told Classic Cakes. Perfectly Beautiful, delicious, and great timing. We had one pink heart with ribbons and an under the sea theme for my 4 year olds birthday and everyone asked for the cake place. I usually gate-keep my party info but I was glad to share the info with my guests.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Classic Cakes took our vision for our wedding cake and absolutely ran with it! It was everything we hoped for and more. Not to mention how delicious it was-- we got SO many compliments from guests. We can hardly wait a year to dig in to our top tier :) I'd recommend them a thousand times over!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I hired this place for my wedding cake on 08/25. I tried many places and I really liked the taste of their cake, but unfortunately it was not what I ordered or what we had agreed on. The bakery had asked me to bring the flowers so they could place them on the cake, so I arrived at the venue at 1:55 pm (the rental started at 2:00 pm). However, when I got there, the cake had already been delivered before the agreed time, without any notice or communication. It was left there without decoration or flowers, which caused me a collapse with a lot of stress on my own wedding day. I had to find last-minute help to fix the situation. The cake tasted good, but the lack of communication, responsibility, and compliance left me deeply disappointed.
It taste just as good as it looks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We are so grateful to Classic Cakes for creating the most beautiful and delicious cake for our spring wedding! From the very beginning, they listened closely to our vision and truly brought it to life. We wanted a design that captured our wildflower theme — and they absolutely nailed it. The cake was not only stunning but felt like a perfect extension of the rest of our day. And the flavors... wow! The lemon and raspberry rose were both out of this world — light, fresh, and full of flavor. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about how good it was (and we completely agree)! Classic Cakes exceeded all of our expectations, both in taste and presentation. Thank you for being such an important and memorable part of our wedding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Why do your past employees report their payroll checks continuously bounced? 🤔 Sounds like theft.
We placed an order for a wedding cake with Classic Cake online about 3-4 months ahead of time to give them plenty of time. Megan followed up with us promptly and offered several dates for taste checking. She was very professional and warm and brought all the flavors and fillings we requested for. On the event day the cake was delivered right on time and was sitting on the table when I entered the room. It was a beautiful scene to look. With her help we chose the perfect cake for our daughter's reception. The texture, flavor and above all the tase were awesome. We highly recommend Classic Cake for specialty events.
Food: 5
Service: 5
I purchased cakes from classic cakes for many many many years when my children were smaller and then into adulthood for birthdays, graduations, and other events. The cakes were always delicious and beautiful however, there is one designer that does not listen to what you ask for. When you tell her, the team colors are red, she made the cake green. When I told her I needed a sculpture of a specific dog and even sent a picture she made it anything but that dog. I realize that a certain amount of artistic license goes into this, but there were at least 10 times when the cakes were not what was ordered, and I didn’t say anything because I needed to pick them up and take them to the event the day that I picked them up and what do you do when the cake is wrong and you need it that day? Everybody said the cakes tasted good so we were fine, but it is disappointing to not get what you ordered.
Restaurantji Recommends
Never responded to my inquiry for a quote. I received a thank you email stating that they would get back to me and never did. This was over 3 weeks ago. There is something going on with this company, things have drastically changed since changing ownership.
Our wedding cake from Classic Cakes was beautifully done just the way we wanted it to look. The details were perfect, and the custom gum paste flowers were a great alternative to real flowers. We also received a lot of compliments from our guests on how delicious it was! During our tasting, we couldn’t choose just one flavor, so we were very happy to be able to pick two (classic white and red velvet). Both were very fresh and tasty!
There was a little difficulty with communication via e-mail, but Megan is a hard worker and her dedication to her business does not go unnoticed. The final product definitely did not fall short of our expectations. We would recommend Classic Cakes for any cake needs!
We had a Cake tasting in preparation for an upcoming Graduation Open house. They make my wedding Cake and just as expected we experienced the best customer service, extremely great tasting Cake (best in Indy) and wonderful atmosphere
It was great & tasty!
Megan and her team are amazing! They created a birthday cake for my wife that was simply stunning. Their attention to detail is second to none. Do yourself a favor and go to Classic Cakes. I promise you will not be disappointed.
Loading...