Classic Cakes

1752 E 116th St, Carmel
(317) 844-6901

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Birthday Cake Strawberry Cake

Velvet Cream Cheese Cake

Chocolate Cake

Wedding Cake

Cake Tasting

Cupcake

Photos

+86 photos

+85 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Classic Cakes

Recent Reviews

This is my first time trying Classic Cakes. I can confidently say Classic Cakes will be my to go to cake shop for my wife’s and I wedding anniversaries and future special occasions. Staff were friendly and also seemed passionate about their work which added an extra layer of sweetness. The cake takes a rating from “Excellent” to “Beyond This World”. Here are my reasons:
1. The balance between cake, filling, and icing was just right.
2. The sweetness...

January 2026

My wife and I are choosing Classic Cakes for our wedding cake simply because the new owner is Amazing! Shes efficient, has great communication, and her cakes are delicious, moist and wonderful. Highly recommend this business for any special occasion or simply for a cupcakes for a after dinner dessert. You wont be disappointed.
~Bryan W.

January 2026

5 stars because we are new here from GA and had high expectations lol I asked my friend who was the best for cake decorating and was told Classic Cakes. Perfectly Beautiful, delicious, and great timing. We had one pink heart with ribbons and an under the sea theme for my 4 year olds birthday and everyone asked for the cake place. I usually gate-keep my party info but I was glad to share the info with my guests.

January 2026

More Reviews

Restaurants in Carmel, IN

Classic Cakes

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Classic Cakes