Custom Cakes near Carmel, IN

“Looked online to find an authentic French baguette. Sent my husband on a 20 minute drive to buy a loaf. The lady on the phone said that their baker had learned to make the baguettes in France so they were indeed authentic. Husband returned with a $5.00 loaf and when I cut into the very small loaf, it looked like a whole grain piece of bread fom Kroger or Fresh Market. It did not taste like a French loaf nor did it have the texture of a French baguette. So disappointed in the whole experience and will definitely not return for bread!“

“I purchased cakes from classic cakes for many many many years when my children were smaller and then into adulthood for birthdays, graduations, and other events. The cakes were always delicious and beautiful however, there is one designer that does not listen to what you ask for. When you tell her, the team colors are red, she made the cake green. When I told her I needed a sculpture of a specific dog and even sent a picture she made it anything but that dog. I realize that a certain amount of artistic license goes into this, but there were at least 10 times when the cakes were not what was ordered, and I didn’t say anything because I needed to pick them up and take them to the event the day that I picked them up and what do you do when the cake is wrong and you need it that day? Everybody said the cakes tasted good so we were fine, but it is disappointing to not get what you ordered.“

“The girls were so polite today 7-31-25 I had the Founders favorite and I switched only the ice cre to banana pudding OMG IT WAS SOOOOO GOOD! I THIBK THIS WILL BE MY GO TO. Very clean and fast service! I will return. My daughter had the Oreo overload with M&m in it she loved it!! Nice dessert date. Great tasty icecream.“

“Just starting on their food smells good“

“They did a wonderful job on my wedding cake and cupcakes! I highly recommend them for custom cakes! The owner was also able to re-create a Cookie Monster cake! It was beautiful!“

“My place of employment served pies from here today and the pecan pie was THE best I have ever had! Amazing!“

“Stopped by since we were in the area and we had a birthday to celebrate. The lady asked if I knew what I was looking for, and she would see if she could make it possible. She was able to make the exact cupcake the birthday kiddo requested. Snagged a few cookies while we were there, and they were a big hit!“

“The kids got two large-ish ice cream cups with one mix-in and while it was a delicious treat, I was surprised that it came to $15 for just two. Okay, maybe for the size of cups it was worth it . They love picking the mix-in! The service was fast and professional. There are two small dining tables inside if you want to stay and eat.“