Feinstein's at Hotel Carmichael

1 Carmichael Square, Carmel
(317) 688-1947

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Courtney Walsh

Gina at Feinsteins is WONDERFUL!! She went above and beyond for accommodations for us. The entire experience start to finish at Feinsteins was 11/10. Highly recommend one of their murder mystery nights!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rachel Bachman

Never been to am event

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Darren Vincent

Awesome food and great place to see wonderful entertainers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Darcy Ward

Wonderful atmosphere and talented performers. The staff was very attentive and kind. Our order was messed up repeatedly, therefore the 4 stars on the food. The food was good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Debbie Roberts

We have been there twice recently and both times the food was absolutely horrible. This week at our table 3 out of the 4 people sent their food back and each of us ordered something different

We then all ordered burgers which we thought would be a safe choice. They came out dry and tasteless and burnt edges . Burgers is not what I want to eat at a Venue like this .

Will I go back again NO. Not when their is a 25 minimum on food and it s horrible not to mention a very limited menu

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Scott McDonald

The shows have always been fun, but the food has been consistently awful. Our guests commented on how bad the chicken dish was. The $12 salads were basically bagged mixed greens dumped in a bowl. The fish tacos had very little fish or toppings and were so chewy that they were almost inedible. The flatbread had very few toppings and was essentially cheese bread. I would not choose to eat there without a minimum of $25 / person for food and drink.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 4

Nacole Swenson

My opinion. The Drag show is fun. They just need to do it differently. Like do your song and dance on stage. The people who want to tip can go up to you on stage. It truly looked like you walked around begging for tips. After the drag queens get off the stage you can't really see them anymore. Need a hamburger Mary's. Atleast you are playing doing something while they are collecting tips.
The spend 25 per person is yucky.. but it is what it is. Food was ok definitely not worth the money. I had a beer. It was good. Hubby had a mountain dew. He said was flat. You must experience it though I did!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Khek Dengmanivanh

It was a very nice place and the entertainment they had that night was excellent. Human Jukebox was very entertaining and we had a lot of fun.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lucy wright

I bought tickets for "Deception" 3 months+ in advance, meaning I had thoroughly planned and anticipated experiencing what amazing reviews I had heard about Feinstein's and their shows, only to be completely shattered every step of the way. Started off in the main lobby, beautiful architecture, pleasant hostess, Feinstein's looked nothing short of a blast to the past. The exact set up that makes you think, "Wow this is going to be amazing!" Unfortunately that didn't last long as our waiter started off with an awkward "walkthrough" of the menu stating, "Our Lamb Chops are the best, I highly recommend!" Great we'll take two! Followed by him almost in the same breath saying, "Oh that's right we are actually all sold out." So we settled on the burger, which not only came out well done (ordered it medium rare) but also burnt to the point where you could barely tell there was anything else on it, and the seared chicken breast, although I requested no pico de gallo, I also was not expecting the most bland small bit of chicken that I received on top a heap of barely seasoned wild rice. As a seasoned Chef you cannot tell me that the pico de gallo is the only thing giving this $25 dish all it's flavor, that's absurd! Moving on to my partner's beer, it was described as a "Wheat Belgium" which one would expect to be cloudy, however even if it was a new type of beer and we just were unsure, the server was also unsure and called it a "champagne beer" sorry not what we ordered. The manager was walking by, took one look, took it away while saying "Sorry it must've been the end of the keg". Which also having been a bartender, I've not once experienced the end of a keg completely changing the color of a beer. When they brought "the right beer" it was the exact same, but with an orange garnish. So now not only is the server confused, the manager is lost, and we, the guests, no longer are confident in this tragic experience. It also serves to note that the entire time everything was going wrong, the manager did not once come over to talk or check in on us. The only somewhat saving grace was the beautiful Raspberry lemonade bomb dessert we got. Fluffy Lemon cake with light and perfectly sweetened raspberry mousse, covered skillfully in white chocolate. My personal pastry chef opinion there can always be more lemon curd in the middle, but the entire mini entremet was a perfect medley of lemon and raspberry, each layer complimenting the next. Other than that, what was supposed to be a grand evening out went from bad to worse leaving us completely mentally exhausted by the time we left. 1 star for the architecture, 2nd star for the dessert.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Cici K

Unfortunately the worst meal I’ve eaten outside my home in quite some time; the rice was not cooked and the chicken was microwaved rubber. Thankfully the wine and staff were lovely, as well as the show.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Ruthann Curtis

Our waitress was phenomenal

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jane Wenzel

The food was tragic! We were a party of over 40 and the food quality, taste and presentation was an embarrassment! It is SO overpriced for the quality. We were told they have a new chef and one wonders how could this kind of food be served. Rice, broccoli and boneless chicken breast with NO seasoning. And, the waitress took our guests bread plate while he was in mid bite because “she had to bring the dinner plate!!!” We keep trying to patronize Feinstein’s Cabernet but are official finished.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alex Bullion

We saw Andie Case again and we love that they keep bringing her back. The food is an experience, the burger was delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Francisco Valencia

My wife and I started our day with latin jazz brunch at Feinsteins at Hotel Carmichael. The latin jazz was great. It did not feel like it was Sunday. Felt like it was Friday or Saturday night. Music was great. My food the shrimp and grits lacked the flavor. My pallet craved a little extra salt.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Jennifer Warf

Shows here are so much fun. Service is amazing. They make you feel like royalty. ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...

Feinstein's at Hotel Carmichael

1 Carmichael Square, Carmel, IN 46032
(317) 688-1947