We had a wonderful Valentine's Eve dinner. Food, Service were awesome , as usual. Our go to place.
Carolyn
I am a frequent visitor, but was disappointed in the service overall this time, and the cost of our lunch. I thought $77 (w/tip) for my daughter and I (and no alcohol) seemed insane. It's so loud in the main dining room during busy hours prob due to all the concrete, but was hard to have a conversation - the tables so close to each other doesn't help either.
Diana Mitchell
Very good pancakes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andreana Marra McCabe
Met an old friend for lunch earlier this month, my service animal was with me. My service animal barked, once, when someone approached our table. An employee told us the “owner” was in the house and required us to be seated in the outside patio area. The temperature was 19 degrees, and although there was some heat in this area, we ate with our jackets on and our food was soon cold. I won’t be patronizing this restaurant again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Edgar Morales
Great Sunday brunch!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cynthia Fisher
Great food, wonderful service, clean and pleasent atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Vanatti
I got a charcuterie board and it was not good at all. The meats were fatty, hard and chewy. The bread was so crunchy and chewy that I hardly enjoyed it. My $110 visit was very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
K Ham
Went here for dinner last Friday with friends. It was delicious!
We had a group of 6 and made reservations. They have indoor and outdoor seating available.
I got the salmon quinoa bowl, my daughter got chicken wings, friends got pasta and brisket. The salmon and brisket dishes were HUGE!
The salmon was perfectly cooked: crispy on the outside, tender on the inside. I knocked down a star because there weren’t much veggies or pesto and the menu had advertised pesto veggies with quinoa. It was mostly quinoa. Would’ve liked more pesto and veggies!!
We also shared the fresh juice sampler. I loved the cashew milk and carrot juice.
This place is good and has room for more potential! It’s nice to have delicious, healthier options in Carmel and Indy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
The Food Dude
Garden Table in Carmel turned out to be a genuinely pleasant surprise — one of those meals where every course hits exactly the way you hoped it would. The space itself sets the tone immediately: clean, bright, and welcoming, with décor that feels thoughtful without trying too hard. It’s the kind of place where you settle in and instantly think, “Yeah, this is going to be good.”
I ordered the Benny Burger, and it was spot-on. The patty came out perfectly medium-rare, the egg was cooked exactly right, and the seasoning pulled everything together without overshadowing the ingredients. The fries deserve their own mention: crisp on the outside, tender inside, and seasoned well enough that you don’t need to drown them in anything.
My wife went with the smoked salmon and avocado toast, and they did not skimp on the salmon. The poached egg was textbook perfect, and even the gluten-free bread — which is often a gamble — was legitimately good. Our daughter’s croissant French toast may have stolen the show, though. Light, flaky, rich, and absolutely delicious.
We finished with the cheesecake, and the kitchen was wonderfully accommodating, adding an off-menu berry compote and chocolate drizzle that elevated the dish without making it overly sweet.
Drinks were another high point: my old fashioned was solid for a pre-mix, and my wife’s Bloody Mary was vibrant, layered, and balanced — great heat without being overpowering.
Overall: great food, great service, and a genuinely enjoyable experience. Garden Table is absolutely worth a return visit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tina
Reserved for myy 18 year old daugher and her friends . They said the food was excellent, server was great, and they loved the juice sampler ! Thank you !
The food was really good! It was super loud & hard to converse until most of the lunch crowd left. But otherwise good.
victoria
we had a 10+ person party and they were still super quick with our food and taking our order! 10/10 would come again for work brunches
Keith
Our waiter, Cuba, was great with our group of 6. Most had not been to Garden Table before. The food is always fresh and a good variety of choices.
Sara
When I initially looked at the menu, I rejected the idea of going to Garden Plate for dinner. We're vegetarians, and the menu had a surprising lack of non-meat options for a place with garden in the name. But, the reviews on Yelp were very positive, so we decided to give it a try, and we're s glad we did! We ordered four appetizers and a creamy pesto pasta dish, and everything was extremely good. We at on the patio, which was super lovely. Everyone at the table had a different lemonade shake-up, and everyone was happy. We had such a lovely dinner that we went to a different location in downtown Indy for lunch the next day, but the brunch/lunch menu was less hospitable for vegetarians and the place was extremely noisy, so we bailed. But, the next time we're in Carmel for dinner, we'll 100% come to Garden Plate for dinner.
Plamen Dimitrov
Interesting food, like the juices but some are strange. Delicious food and nice interior design.
We had a wonderful Valentine's Eve dinner. Food, Service were awesome , as usual. Our go to place.
I am a frequent visitor, but was disappointed in the service overall this time, and the cost of our lunch. I thought $77 (w/tip) for my daughter and I (and no alcohol) seemed insane. It's so loud in the main dining room during busy hours prob due to all the concrete, but was hard to have a conversation - the tables so close to each other doesn't help either.
Very good pancakes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Met an old friend for lunch earlier this month, my service animal was with me. My service animal barked, once, when someone approached our table. An employee told us the “owner” was in the house and required us to be seated in the outside patio area. The temperature was 19 degrees, and although there was some heat in this area, we ate with our jackets on and our food was soon cold. I won’t be patronizing this restaurant again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Great Sunday brunch!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, wonderful service, clean and pleasent atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got a charcuterie board and it was not good at all. The meats were fatty, hard and chewy. The bread was so crunchy and chewy that I hardly enjoyed it. My $110 visit was very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Went here for dinner last Friday with friends. It was delicious!
We had a group of 6 and made reservations. They have indoor and outdoor seating available.
I got the salmon quinoa bowl, my daughter got chicken wings, friends got pasta and brisket. The salmon and brisket dishes were HUGE!
The salmon was perfectly cooked: crispy on the outside, tender on the inside. I knocked down a star because there weren’t much veggies or pesto and the menu had advertised pesto veggies with quinoa. It was mostly quinoa. Would’ve liked more pesto and veggies!!
We also shared the fresh juice sampler. I loved the cashew milk and carrot juice.
This place is good and has room for more potential! It’s nice to have delicious, healthier options in Carmel and Indy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Garden Table in Carmel turned out to be a genuinely pleasant surprise — one of those meals where every course hits exactly the way you hoped it would. The space itself sets the tone immediately: clean, bright, and welcoming, with décor that feels thoughtful without trying too hard. It’s the kind of place where you settle in and instantly think, “Yeah, this is going to be good.”
I ordered the Benny Burger, and it was spot-on. The patty came out perfectly medium-rare, the egg was cooked exactly right, and the seasoning pulled everything together without overshadowing the ingredients. The fries deserve their own mention: crisp on the outside, tender inside, and seasoned well enough that you don’t need to drown them in anything.
My wife went with the smoked salmon and avocado toast, and they did not skimp on the salmon. The poached egg was textbook perfect, and even the gluten-free bread — which is often a gamble — was legitimately good. Our daughter’s croissant French toast may have stolen the show, though. Light, flaky, rich, and absolutely delicious.
We finished with the cheesecake, and the kitchen was wonderfully accommodating, adding an off-menu berry compote and chocolate drizzle that elevated the dish without making it overly sweet.
Drinks were another high point: my old fashioned was solid for a pre-mix, and my wife’s Bloody Mary was vibrant, layered, and balanced — great heat without being overpowering.
Overall: great food, great service, and a genuinely enjoyable experience. Garden Table is absolutely worth a return visit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Reserved for myy 18 year old daugher and her friends . They said the food was excellent, server was great, and they loved the juice sampler ! Thank you !
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was really good! It was super loud & hard to converse until most of the lunch crowd left. But otherwise good.
we had a 10+ person party and they were still super quick with our food and taking our order! 10/10 would come again for work brunches
Our waiter, Cuba, was great with our group of 6. Most had not been to Garden Table before. The food is always fresh and a good variety of choices.
When I initially looked at the menu, I rejected the idea of going to Garden Plate for dinner. We're vegetarians, and the menu had a surprising lack of non-meat options for a place with garden in the name. But, the reviews on Yelp were very positive, so we decided to give it a try, and we're s glad we did! We ordered four appetizers and a creamy pesto pasta dish, and everything was extremely good. We at on the patio, which was super lovely. Everyone at the table had a different lemonade shake-up, and everyone was happy. We had such a lovely dinner that we went to a different location in downtown Indy for lunch the next day, but the brunch/lunch menu was less hospitable for vegetarians and the place was extremely noisy, so we bailed. But, the next time we're in Carmel for dinner, we'll 100% come to Garden Plate for dinner.
Interesting food, like the juices but some are strange. Delicious food and nice interior design.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...