Graeter’s is the GOAT. Best ice cream in the world. Plus, they are always overstaffed and will let you try anything with patience. The best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tim Alfermann
Great ice cream! Excellent place to go just for
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Allison Lenselink
Was absolutely stoked to find out they had a brick and mortar shop in Carmel when we visited! We always buy their ice cream when we can find it in the grocery store and it was even better in person!!
Max Hotz
On the expensive side, $12.50 for 1 scoop each in 2 waffle cones. However, very yummy!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dark Chocolate Brownie
Justin Davis
As always, Graeter's delivers the goods. You really can't go wrong if you enjoy classic hard serve icecream.
Jonathan Webber
This is delicious, fantastic ice cream, only available in the Midwest (PA, KY, Chi)Please expand!!!
Kelsey H.
I love getting ice cream, especially as the warmer days are starting to end. I tried the new boldly bearcat, which was delicious! I was a bit disappointed that i could literally see the bottom of the bowl with my $4+ scoop of ice cream. It felt really overpriced and small, especially compared to Handels and other options
Connor J.
Ice cream is good but tiny portions. $8 double scoop, shouldn't be tiny little scoops
Robert Klatte
Great ice cream and so many wonderful flavors to choose from….definitely a delightful and delicious frozen treat on a hot Summer’s day
Kunal_Kool
Great location for sweet treats and walks. Many choices of ice cream flavors and shakes.
Our FAVORITE ice cream shop!! I always get the chocolate dipped waffle cone and usually get different flavors although my most ordered are buckeye and dark chocolate brownie. Sooo good
Purple Pickles
Me and my boyfriend were very disappointed tonight. Usually greaters is good. My milk shake was way too watery. There was too much milk. My boyfriends brownie sunday was watery, and a cold brownie.
Glen Heppner
Best ice cream, period. Only the gelato in Rome, Italy can be considered superior when it comes to a frozen dessert.
Raena L.
Yelp's telling me I haven't done a review here, which I just can't imagine! 116th in FIshers/Carmel next to City BBQ off 37. Young staff is always very pleasant. PlLenty of traditional and unique flavors to try. This time, I had the Buckeye Blitz Chocolate Chip, a chocoalte peanut butter bit of heaven. #yum #ReviewsByRL
Michelle Karin
Why is this ice cream so expensive? It’s good, but I honestly didn’t think it was that great.The ice cream was okay, the mint chocolate chip was icy and not a pleasant texture. I was hoping for a creamier consistency.
Graeter’s is the GOAT. Best ice cream in the world. Plus, they are always overstaffed and will let you try anything with patience. The best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great ice cream! Excellent place to go just for
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Was absolutely stoked to find out they had a brick and mortar shop in Carmel when we visited! We always buy their ice cream when we can find it in the grocery store and it was even better in person!!
On the expensive side, $12.50 for 1 scoop each in 2 waffle cones. However, very yummy!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dark Chocolate Brownie
As always, Graeter's delivers the goods. You really can't go wrong if you enjoy classic hard serve icecream.
This is delicious, fantastic ice cream, only available in the Midwest (PA, KY, Chi)Please expand!!!
I love getting ice cream, especially as the warmer days are starting to end. I tried the new boldly bearcat, which was delicious! I was a bit disappointed that i could literally see the bottom of the bowl with my $4+ scoop of ice cream. It felt really overpriced and small, especially compared to Handels and other options
Ice cream is good but tiny portions. $8 double scoop, shouldn't be tiny little scoops
Great ice cream and so many wonderful flavors to choose from….definitely a delightful and delicious frozen treat on a hot Summer’s day
Great location for sweet treats and walks. Many choices of ice cream flavors and shakes.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our FAVORITE ice cream shop!! I always get the chocolate dipped waffle cone and usually get different flavors although my most ordered are buckeye and dark chocolate brownie. Sooo good
Me and my boyfriend were very disappointed tonight. Usually greaters is good. My milk shake was way too watery. There was too much milk. My boyfriends brownie sunday was watery, and a cold brownie.
Best ice cream, period. Only the gelato in Rome, Italy can be considered superior when it comes to a frozen dessert.
Yelp's telling me I haven't done a review here, which I just can't imagine! 116th in FIshers/Carmel next to City BBQ off 37. Young staff is always very pleasant. PlLenty of traditional and unique flavors to try. This time, I had the Buckeye Blitz Chocolate Chip, a chocoalte peanut butter bit of heaven. #yum #ReviewsByRL
Why is this ice cream so expensive? It’s good, but I honestly didn’t think it was that great.The ice cream was okay, the mint chocolate chip was icy and not a pleasant texture. I was hoping for a creamier consistency.