We dined at Lone Pine for Valentine's Day. They had a set menu for the special occasion. I had the whipped Brie, roasted carrots, salmon and blood orange panna cotta. My partner had the shrimp cocktail , chopped ceasar, ribeye and chocolate ganache. All of the courses were well done. The stars of the meal were the carrots and panna cotta. Our server was excellent with recommendations—I can also solidly recommend their French martini. Overall the experience was on par with other upper tier steak houses in the Indy Metro
Greg
We went for Valentine's Day dinner. Fixed menu which we frequently enjoy. It was very busy and service was keeping up for the most part. My wife's salmon was cooked perfectly, my filet ordered medium rare came out medium well but was still very flavorful. Spinach was a bit overcooked. Considering the volume of food that they have to put out on one of their busiest days, I was a little disappointed but would definitely go back for a "regular" night out to see what their normal dining experience provides. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff.
James
We went for the Valentine's Day tasting menu, 2026. Overall, the restaurant was nice and clean. The staff were helpful and polite. They were willing to answer any questions about the tasting menu. The tasting menu food was delicious, but a tad overpriced for what it was. Two of us, with tip, was $360ish. That included on alcoholic beverage only for $16. For the quality and quantity of the food it was a little high priced. The food was delicious, but I wouldn't say I was absolutely wowed by it. Overall, the noise level in the restaurant allowed for good conversation at our table with out having to be too loud or struggle to hear. The wait staff was attentive with out being over bearing. I'd return to the restaurant, but probably not for a tasting menu. I don't regret it at all, just didn't see the value for the money.
christopher
Fantastic food and service on Valentine's Day. Loved it from start to finish. Our server Megan was very knowledgeable and very efficient. The dessert was one of the best I've ever had.
Hillary
Gator Boots cocktail (spicy marg vibes) was amazing. Had to have 2. Really nice wine and cocktail menus. They were out of the focaccia when we went, but they offered a sourdough instead which was also delish with their sun-dried tomato basil butter. Shrimp cocktail was great. Got the 16oz ribeye with mashed potatoes, and will dream of both for years to come. So flavorful and prepared perfectly. My husband had the swordfish and said it was really good. 20/10 recommend! We will come back again!
Dustin
I took my girlfriend for Valentine's Day and we couldn't have been more pleased. The food, service and atmosphere were fantastic and exactly as I hoped it would be. The swordfish and filet were top notch and were paired perfectly with the oysters rockefeller and brussel sprouts. This was our first time dining here but it will not be our last.
Shawn
First time dining here. They were very busy and our service was slow which is understandable. However when the food came out it was all cold and my steak had no flavor at all. The loaded hashbrowns were good and the server tried to make it right and took our drinks off which was very nice. Overall not a great experience.
Sharon
It was a very expensive evening. But the service was terrible. We all order steaks. The steaks came out and the side took 12 mins to come out. We finished out steaks before the sides came out. Overall poor service
DeAngela
Fantastic experience. Great for large parties. Food and service top notch. Highly recommend!
Karen
We wet to Lone Pine for my husband's birthday. The food was amazing. I had the Bloody Mary Wedge salad. It was different than your typical wedge, but very good. My husband had their French Onion soup. Our steaks were cooked to our liking. Everything was delicious. Our waitress, Mya, was very knowledgeable about the menu. She was also attentive to our needs. We will definitely be back.
First time trying Lone Pine and can't wait to go back. Atmosphere was big city chic meets comfy pub. The meals were all well received by our group.
Gary
Wonderful place! Our first visit. Celebrating wife's birthday. Food was excellent. Service was great. Highly recommend!
Chad
Service was the best part. An OK dining experience but overpriced. Steak was OK, apps were OK, and the fish was OK. Would go back for a more casual meal because the service was good, but would not order big ticket items.
John
The adjacent Christmas market had just opened and everything in the area was packed with people. As a result, service was initially slow, but then was very good. Our beef filet was correctly prepared, but not as tender as we expected. Still, we will go back again soon.
Dean
The food was excellent! However, the service was not great. Our waiter often left us waiting for drinks and to take orders. It was a big distraction from the visit. We may try again because the food was so good, but management needs to sort the staff.
We dined at Lone Pine for Valentine's Day. They had a set menu for the special occasion. I had the whipped Brie, roasted carrots, salmon and blood orange panna cotta. My partner had the shrimp cocktail , chopped ceasar, ribeye and chocolate ganache. All of the courses were well done. The stars of the meal were the carrots and panna cotta. Our server was excellent with recommendations—I can also solidly recommend their French martini. Overall the experience was on par with other upper tier steak houses in the Indy Metro
We went for Valentine's Day dinner. Fixed menu which we frequently enjoy. It was very busy and service was keeping up for the most part. My wife's salmon was cooked perfectly, my filet ordered medium rare came out medium well but was still very flavorful. Spinach was a bit overcooked. Considering the volume of food that they have to put out on one of their busiest days, I was a little disappointed but would definitely go back for a "regular" night out to see what their normal dining experience provides. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff.
We went for the Valentine's Day tasting menu, 2026. Overall, the restaurant was nice and clean. The staff were helpful and polite. They were willing to answer any questions about the tasting menu. The tasting menu food was delicious, but a tad overpriced for what it was. Two of us, with tip, was $360ish. That included on alcoholic beverage only for $16. For the quality and quantity of the food it was a little high priced. The food was delicious, but I wouldn't say I was absolutely wowed by it. Overall, the noise level in the restaurant allowed for good conversation at our table with out having to be too loud or struggle to hear. The wait staff was attentive with out being over bearing. I'd return to the restaurant, but probably not for a tasting menu. I don't regret it at all, just didn't see the value for the money.
Fantastic food and service on Valentine's Day. Loved it from start to finish. Our server Megan was very knowledgeable and very efficient. The dessert was one of the best I've ever had.
Gator Boots cocktail (spicy marg vibes) was amazing. Had to have 2. Really nice wine and cocktail menus. They were out of the focaccia when we went, but they offered a sourdough instead which was also delish with their sun-dried tomato basil butter. Shrimp cocktail was great. Got the 16oz ribeye with mashed potatoes, and will dream of both for years to come. So flavorful and prepared perfectly. My husband had the swordfish and said it was really good. 20/10 recommend! We will come back again!
I took my girlfriend for Valentine's Day and we couldn't have been more pleased. The food, service and atmosphere were fantastic and exactly as I hoped it would be. The swordfish and filet were top notch and were paired perfectly with the oysters rockefeller and brussel sprouts. This was our first time dining here but it will not be our last.
First time dining here. They were very busy and our service was slow which is understandable. However when the food came out it was all cold and my steak had no flavor at all. The loaded hashbrowns were good and the server tried to make it right and took our drinks off which was very nice. Overall not a great experience.
It was a very expensive evening. But the service was terrible. We all order steaks. The steaks came out and the side took 12 mins to come out. We finished out steaks before the sides came out. Overall poor service
Fantastic experience. Great for large parties. Food and service top notch. Highly recommend!
We wet to Lone Pine for my husband's birthday. The food was amazing. I had the Bloody Mary Wedge salad. It was different than your typical wedge, but very good. My husband had their French Onion soup. Our steaks were cooked to our liking. Everything was delicious. Our waitress, Mya, was very knowledgeable about the menu. She was also attentive to our needs. We will definitely be back.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time trying Lone Pine and can't wait to go back. Atmosphere was big city chic meets comfy pub. The meals were all well received by our group.
Wonderful place! Our first visit. Celebrating wife's birthday. Food was excellent. Service was great. Highly recommend!
Service was the best part. An OK dining experience but overpriced. Steak was OK, apps were OK, and the fish was OK. Would go back for a more casual meal because the service was good, but would not order big ticket items.
The adjacent Christmas market had just opened and everything in the area was packed with people. As a result, service was initially slow, but then was very good. Our beef filet was correctly prepared, but not as tender as we expected. Still, we will go back again soon.
The food was excellent! However, the service was not great. Our waiter often left us waiting for drinks and to take orders. It was a big distraction from the visit. We may try again because the food was so good, but management needs to sort the staff.
Loading...