Bought 4 different cookies and all of them tasted weird, chemically, off putting. They all were also severely and unsafely underdone to the point the bottom was just dense dough. If you can’t make soft or delicious cookies and still bake them properly, you don’t know what you’re doing. For $4 a cookie you should be an entire gourmet quality dessert. DONT GO HERE.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Elaina M.
Love love love these cookies! There is quite the selection! They are huge and tasty! Next time I want to try the edible dough and ice cream sandwich!
Andrew Hoover
Lovely cookie shop, great location right there on Monon. Clean, nice, vibrant cookies.So much better than some chain with a fancy app and pink boxes.Cookies were original, beautiful, and big. Soft but not gooey. Sweet with a taste of salt. The frozen treats looked amazing but it was too brisk on my visit. Wonderful people working - packaged my "now" cookie distinct from my "later" cookies which was kind and very welcome.Shared with friends, but we had: sugar, oreo, s'mores, and strawberry chocolate. I've never had a strawberry cookie before, it was a delight. They all were. Again, pretty on the eyes too. Especially the fancy presentation of the s'mores.
Delicious and freshly made cookies. Never disappointed with the quality and taste. Reasonably priced for the size of each cookie.
Irene K.
Delicious cookies. Wonderful service/location. Get the oatmeal raisin for sure!--there are limited special cookies depending on season also.
Ashley H.
Love these cookies! They have gluten free options (yes - multiple options!) that are sooo good:). Staff is very friendly and prompt. Very clean. We love stopping in when we're in town for a sweet treat!
Jason R.
Showed up on Saturday at 2:40 PM. Closed. Posted hours clearly say should be open. No sign saying closed for an emergency or anything. Just closed for no apparent reason.
Irene King
BEST Oatmeal raisin cookie ever, IMO. My husband and I love oatmeal raisin cookies. We both agreed this is prob the best we have had. Lovely shop, great cookies and fantastic service. Pricing is fair esp if you buy 6....2 free. Wonderful dessert/housewarming, just because gift. Peppermint Choc and S'mores were other favorites (may be seasonal). These cookies have just the perfect amount of everything. Other cookie places are much too sweet/sickening compared to these. A++
After getting my hair done, I decided to find a new dessert related business to stop at. Time to bring more desserts home for the family.I was pretty overwhelmed by the number of cookies available. The individual who helped me was patience and helpful. I purchased 7 cookies (it was buy 6 get 1 free) but unfortunately, one of the cookies wasn’t packed up for me.With that said, the cookies I tried were good (oatmeal raisin and oatmeal scotchie).
If people like soft cookies, I recommend this shop. The cookies are very soft, not mushy, texture is tough, easy to chew, and have new flavors. Not similar to other brands ???
Mary's Mountain Cookies is a small bakery with a nice selection cookies, from classics like Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip to more exotic flavors like Caramel Macchiato and Fudge Fantasy Avalanche, you're sure to find a flavor you'll enjoy. The cookies are soft and fresh. The facility is clean. The service is quick and friendly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Snickerdoodle
Leon Hayden
Being a sole owner, she does an excellent job, preparing, cooking and selling her products. I want to support this individual, I make it a point to stop in and purchase whenever I am on Main Street.Excellent, fresh product !
Jenna K.
I decided to stop in after walking by so many times! I got the snickerdoodle and frosted almond pumpkin cookie. The snickerdoodle was so soft and delicious. The sugar cookie had a good flavor and was soft but tasted a little artificial to me. I'd go back and try other flavors next time.
Molly Z.
I was craving a snickerdoodle cookie and Mary's Mountain Cookies had been on my list to check out for a while so I knew this was a perfect opportunity! There is a huge variety of cookies; all looked delicious! They're HUGE! The snickerdoodle was moist and soft. My husband tried the chocolate chip cookie and said it wasn't his favorite but we plan to try other flavors when we're in the area.
Great, delicious cookie selection!
Bought 4 different cookies and all of them tasted weird, chemically, off putting. They all were also severely and unsafely underdone to the point the bottom was just dense dough. If you can’t make soft or delicious cookies and still bake them properly, you don’t know what you’re doing. For $4 a cookie you should be an entire gourmet quality dessert. DONT GO HERE.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Love love love these cookies! There is quite the selection! They are huge and tasty! Next time I want to try the edible dough and ice cream sandwich!
Lovely cookie shop, great location right there on Monon. Clean, nice, vibrant cookies.So much better than some chain with a fancy app and pink boxes.Cookies were original, beautiful, and big. Soft but not gooey. Sweet with a taste of salt. The frozen treats looked amazing but it was too brisk on my visit. Wonderful people working - packaged my "now" cookie distinct from my "later" cookies which was kind and very welcome.Shared with friends, but we had: sugar, oreo, s'mores, and strawberry chocolate. I've never had a strawberry cookie before, it was a delight. They all were. Again, pretty on the eyes too. Especially the fancy presentation of the s'mores.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Individually Bagged Cookies, Sugar Cookie
Delicious and freshly made cookies. Never disappointed with the quality and taste. Reasonably priced for the size of each cookie.
Delicious cookies. Wonderful service/location. Get the oatmeal raisin for sure!--there are limited special cookies depending on season also.
Love these cookies! They have gluten free options (yes - multiple options!) that are sooo good:). Staff is very friendly and prompt. Very clean. We love stopping in when we're in town for a sweet treat!
Showed up on Saturday at 2:40 PM. Closed. Posted hours clearly say should be open. No sign saying closed for an emergency or anything. Just closed for no apparent reason.
BEST Oatmeal raisin cookie ever, IMO. My husband and I love oatmeal raisin cookies. We both agreed this is prob the best we have had. Lovely shop, great cookies and fantastic service. Pricing is fair esp if you buy 6....2 free. Wonderful dessert/housewarming, just because gift. Peppermint Choc and S'mores were other favorites (may be seasonal). These cookies have just the perfect amount of everything. Other cookie places are much too sweet/sickening compared to these. A++
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Snickerdoodle, Oatmeal Raisin, Chocolate Chip
After getting my hair done, I decided to find a new dessert related business to stop at. Time to bring more desserts home for the family.I was pretty overwhelmed by the number of cookies available. The individual who helped me was patience and helpful. I purchased 7 cookies (it was buy 6 get 1 free) but unfortunately, one of the cookies wasn’t packed up for me.With that said, the cookies I tried were good (oatmeal raisin and oatmeal scotchie).
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookie, Oatmeal Raisin, Chocolate Chip
Restaurantji Recommends
If people like soft cookies, I recommend this shop. The cookies are very soft, not mushy, texture is tough, easy to chew, and have new flavors. Not similar to other brands ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fudge Fantasy, M&M, Chocolate Chip, Oreo, Peanut Butter Cookie
Mary's Mountain Cookies is a small bakery with a nice selection cookies, from classics like Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip to more exotic flavors like Caramel Macchiato and Fudge Fantasy Avalanche, you're sure to find a flavor you'll enjoy. The cookies are soft and fresh. The facility is clean. The service is quick and friendly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Snickerdoodle
Being a sole owner, she does an excellent job, preparing, cooking and selling her products. I want to support this individual, I make it a point to stop in and purchase whenever I am on Main Street.Excellent, fresh product !
I decided to stop in after walking by so many times! I got the snickerdoodle and frosted almond pumpkin cookie. The snickerdoodle was so soft and delicious. The sugar cookie had a good flavor and was soft but tasted a little artificial to me. I'd go back and try other flavors next time.
I was craving a snickerdoodle cookie and Mary's Mountain Cookies had been on my list to check out for a while so I knew this was a perfect opportunity! There is a huge variety of cookies; all looked delicious! They're HUGE! The snickerdoodle was moist and soft. My husband tried the chocolate chip cookie and said it wasn't his favorite but we plan to try other flavors when we're in the area.