I had such a wonderful on my date here! Our server, Hannah, was the blueprint for customer service. She checked on us plenty and made sure that we were completely taken care of. I follow a strict gluten-free diet, and she was sure to inform me of everything I needed to know to be able to enjoy a safe dinner. We WILL be returning and asking for Hannah! 10/10, thank you so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lindsay Bean
Food was fine, nothing to write home about. The calamari was really rubbery and we sent it back. Probably wouldn’t go back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jessie Mock
We have tried for 30 minutes to get a live human being to place a take out order as your on line ordering does not allow to provide steak details or dressing on the side You only have a robot answering the phone SUPER FRUSTRATING AND DISAPPOINTING
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ryan Johnston Sr
They saved our date when the Carmel Oktoberfest only had beer and warm wine. Nothing against beer. I am just looking for something more exciting. They had many cocktails that I've never had before. My wife really enjoyed the Flirtini.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trisha Johnston
Loved the drinks and food. The service was also great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sweet Potato Fries
Judy
I asked for a quiet booth in Open Table due to my hearing impairment. We were seated next to a naturally loud table of 8 in a half booth instead. My tomato soup was lukewarm. House salad was not fresh and had little dressing. The wine by the glass was $18 for a 6oz pour that looked like a 5 oz pour. My friend had a delicious mushroom flatbread and I had my favorite pretzel bites which I always enjoy. Maybe just a one off night because I've usually had good experiences eating here.
Barbara
Our server was professional, light-hearted and delightful! Individualized our questions to menu suggestions that were excellent... flatbread, mini-sliders, salad choices, and soups. We think Matt the Miller's keeps getting even better!
Stephen Meyer
Steak special was a good deal
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lori H
Stopped in after a long ride on the Monon. Enjoyed the dip duo appetizer, a mixed lettuce chicken salad and a fish sandwich. Outdoor seating was enjoyable and the service and staff were friendly and attentive.. highly recommend
Matt the Millers is in a prime location in Carmel, and it’s probably the longest-standing business in this spot. Despite having lived and worked in Carmel, I’d never actually been to this restaurant before. But after a visit to The Aroma Room nearby, Shayla, the owner, recommended I check it out, so I decided to give it a try.
Upon arrival, my friend and I were warmly greeted by Anne, who was incredibly sweet and engaging. She took the time to chat with us for a good five minutes, making our first impression of the place very pleasant. When she heard it was my first time at Matt the Millers, she recommended the pretzel bites and generously offered them on the house. This gesture left a fantastic impression, and as she promised, the pretzel bites were absolutely delicious.
For my main course, I opted for the truffle mushroom burger with regular fries, and to drink, I tried some kind of jalapeño bourbon cocktail, which was a delightful surprise. I couldn’t resist trying another drink and went for a blue cheese martini next. My friend, who is vegetarian, ordered the mushroom flatbread and an elderberry cocktail. She loved the jalapeño cocktail so much that she decided to get one for herself as well.
Julian, our server, was just as pleasant as Anne, providing excellent service throughout our meal. The ambience of the restaurant is very nice, adding to the overall experience. We also appreciated how clean the bathrooms were, and it was a pleasant surprise to find a private door, toilet, and sink in the bathroom. Both my friend and I left highly satisfied with our experience at Matt the Millers. It’s surprising I hadn’t tried it sooner, but now that I have a membership at The Aroma Room, I definitely plan to return and am looking forward to my next visit.
Young server was attentive. Still needs to develop people skills a little bit that comes with experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Shay Powell
We are new to Carmel and this place has the best happy hour! The food is very yummy. The servers are all super polite and great. We have been twice and this will definitely be one of our go to spots. Highly recommend. It’s always very nice to sit outside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Happy Hour
Michelle Brackett
We usually have a great experience here but not this time. We went here for Devour Indy and order off the Devour menu. They didn’t seem that busy and our server was nice but service was very slow. I order the 8oz steak medium rare but it came well done and dry. In our long wait for service, I noticed a person next to us also received an overdone steak and she sent it back but it took so long for her to get a replacement that her family was done eating before she got it so I did not send mine back. For dessert, we had the banana cream pie shooters which are described as having candied walnuts and shortbread but we only received little plastic cups of banana pudding with whipped cream on top, no candied walnuts or shortbread. Basically we got a cup of plain Jello pudding for dessert. I would have mentioned it to our server but she didn’t come back for so long that we just decided to just eat it so that we could go and get away from the bugs that were flying around us our entire dinner.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Lori
First time here, stopped in after a long ride on the Monon as it is conveniently located to the trail. Enjoyed the dip duo appetizer, a mixed lettuce chicken salad and a fish sandwich. Outdoor seating was enjoyable and the service and staff were friendly and attentive.. highly recommend
I had such a wonderful on my date here! Our server, Hannah, was the blueprint for customer service. She checked on us plenty and made sure that we were completely taken care of. I follow a strict gluten-free diet, and she was sure to inform me of everything I needed to know to be able to enjoy a safe dinner. We WILL be returning and asking for Hannah! 10/10, thank you so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was fine, nothing to write home about. The calamari was really rubbery and we sent it back. Probably wouldn’t go back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
We have tried for 30 minutes to get a live human being to place a take out order as your on line ordering does not allow to provide steak details or dressing on the side
You only have a robot answering the phone
SUPER FRUSTRATING AND DISAPPOINTING
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
They saved our date when the Carmel Oktoberfest only had beer and warm wine. Nothing against beer. I am just looking for something more exciting. They had many cocktails that I've never had before. My wife really enjoyed the Flirtini.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved the drinks and food. The service was also great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sweet Potato Fries
I asked for a quiet booth in Open Table due to my hearing impairment. We were seated next to a naturally loud table of 8 in a half booth instead. My tomato soup was lukewarm. House salad was not fresh and had little dressing. The wine by the glass was $18 for a 6oz pour that looked like a 5 oz pour. My friend had a delicious mushroom flatbread and I had my favorite pretzel bites which I always enjoy. Maybe just a one off night because I've usually had good experiences eating here.
Our server was professional, light-hearted and delightful! Individualized our questions to menu suggestions that were excellent... flatbread, mini-sliders, salad choices, and soups. We think Matt the Miller's keeps getting even better!
Steak special was a good deal
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in after a long ride on the Monon. Enjoyed the dip duo appetizer, a mixed lettuce chicken salad and a fish sandwich. Outdoor seating was enjoyable and the service and staff were friendly and attentive.. highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service, but burger is way too dry
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Matt the Millers is in a prime location in Carmel, and it’s probably the longest-standing business in this spot. Despite having lived and worked in Carmel, I’d never actually been to this restaurant before. But after a visit to The Aroma Room nearby, Shayla, the owner, recommended I check it out, so I decided to give it a try.
Upon arrival, my friend and I were warmly greeted by Anne, who was incredibly sweet and engaging. She took the time to chat with us for a good five minutes, making our first impression of the place very pleasant. When she heard it was my first time at Matt the Millers, she recommended the pretzel bites and generously offered them on the house. This gesture left a fantastic impression, and as she promised, the pretzel bites were absolutely delicious.
For my main course, I opted for the truffle mushroom burger with regular fries, and to drink, I tried some kind of jalapeño bourbon cocktail, which was a delightful surprise. I couldn’t resist trying another drink and went for a blue cheese martini next. My friend, who is vegetarian, ordered the mushroom flatbread and an elderberry cocktail. She loved the jalapeño cocktail so much that she decided to get one for herself as well.
Julian, our server, was just as pleasant as Anne, providing excellent service throughout our meal. The ambience of the restaurant is very nice, adding to the overall experience. We also appreciated how clean the bathrooms were, and it was a pleasant surprise to find a private door, toilet, and sink in the bathroom. Both my friend and I left highly satisfied with our experience at Matt the Millers. It’s surprising I hadn’t tried it sooner, but now that I have a membership at The Aroma Room, I definitely plan to return and am looking forward to my next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pretzel Bites, Mushroom Flatbread
Young server was attentive. Still needs to develop people skills a little bit that comes with experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
We are new to Carmel and this place has the best happy hour! The food is very yummy. The servers are all super polite and great. We have been twice and this will definitely be one of our go to spots. Highly recommend. It’s always very nice to sit outside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Happy Hour
We usually have a great experience here but not this time. We went here for Devour Indy and order off the Devour menu. They didn’t seem that busy and our server was nice but service was very slow. I order the 8oz steak medium rare but it came well done and dry. In our long wait for service, I noticed a person next to us also received an overdone steak and she sent it back but it took so long for her to get a replacement that her family was done eating before she got it so I did not send mine back. For dessert, we had the banana cream pie shooters which are described as having candied walnuts and shortbread but we only received little plastic cups of banana pudding with whipped cream on top, no candied walnuts or shortbread. Basically we got a cup of plain Jello pudding for dessert. I would have mentioned it to our server but she didn’t come back for so long that we just decided to just eat it so that we could go and get away from the bugs that were flying around us our entire dinner.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
First time here, stopped in after a long ride on the Monon as it is conveniently located to the trail. Enjoyed the dip duo appetizer, a mixed lettuce chicken salad and a fish sandwich. Outdoor seating was enjoyable and the service and staff were friendly and attentive.. highly recommend
Loading...