Old Town Tavern

29 W Main St, Carmel
(317) 846-5545

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Peter Putelis

Great place with great people!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

K Shumaker

This is a smoking bar. We did not stay.

Atmosphere: 1

Alexandria Collier

Leslie and her security guard have major issues and i witnessed her mistreat people. i will work my hardest to make sure i inform anyone i come in contact with about the negativity witnessed at this establishment.

Service: 1

Precious Moore

I got booted out for no reason. I didn’t disrespect anyone, my friend just asked for a drink, and the lady looked at me and said I could leave. I asked why, what did I do? She said if you don’t have an open tab, I’m not giving you anything. But my friend, who looks different from me, walked up and got a drink. I feel highly offended and left without a fuss because I don’t see why treat others that way. We are all human. Definitely was a racist bartender. She was a heavy set caucasian lady .

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Caitlin G

Old school and amazing

Micah Nist

Utterly disgusting smells and tastes like cigarettes. I was kicked out by a bartender for wearing my hat backwards which is apparently a rule. The person who told me looks like a normal person so I didn’t know it was a worker. They gave me no second chances and just told me to leave. I wasn’t acting out or rude at all. Would not recommend

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mickey Hurley

A little slice of old school Americana. Warning, they do still allow smoking. Some nights are bad but mostly fine. The atmosphere is great, the crowd is great and the bartenders are great, especially Soren!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

M L

I go here multiple times a month, and trust me when I say it’s not the closest to my house. It’s a tiny hole in the wall, but it reminds me of bars back home on the gulf coast. It’s tiny and comfortable, and other than the regular crowd who sit at the bar all of the time everyone else is always different every night.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Kip Benbow

Traditional dive bar! My kind of haunt. I can’t get more into it as I worked there and am good friends with the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Mike H

Our favorite Bar in town! Ive been going there since 1988 and go in there with my Sons who are regulars there. Great place to go and have a Cigar and a Beer. Bruce and the Staff are laid back and always good to us. It is the best time around the holidays, most of the people from out of town are there (that have grown up in Carmel) and you can run into and old friend! Check it out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Geisler

The “owners lawyer” didn’t want to hear me talking to another patron about my HORRIBLE experience last night. Asked me to pay my tab and leave and told me I wasn’t welcome here ?. This place is owned by a bunch of looney toons if they think that’s good business. It caters to regulars and that is it. Don’t go here if you’re not a regular.

Kent Hiller

Favorite dive bar in all of Hamilton county!! And Leslie is the best EVER

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

BeeBee

Bartender only recognized the regulars. So sad!Very disappointed for a beginning Holiday start..Horribly bad!We pay her paycheck. Will not return...

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 1

Trinity Manning

good drinks, fast service, and kind bartenders!

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Neal Lindsey

Little smokie knew a lot of people there

Loading...