The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers, Carmel City Center

799 Hanover Place, Upper Deck, Hanover Place Suite 260, Carmel
(317) 257-2253

Recent Reviews

Susan

The chicken velvet soup/lemon Caesar salad combo was as phenomenal as always! Our waitress was great - couldn't have been better. We got a piece of chocolate silk pie to go. The pie was unfortunately a huge let down. It was grainy and not the decadent flavor that we expected. The pie ended up in the trash which is sad when the dessert should have been the star of the show!

Transported to an experience of elegance, femininity, class. Our waitress made us feel like we were the most important table in the restaurant with her attentiveness and engagement. Food was beautifully presented, high quality and delicious. As always, choosing a cake flavor is hard! Iwent with my favorite chocolate mint -- unbelievable how delicious this cake is with its fluffy frosting and tiny chocolate bits.

LCGD

We dined at the Cake Bake last night to celebrate a special event for my daughter. I made reservations two months ago( March 7th) but when we arrived our table was not ready and we had to wait about 15 minutes for a table to be set up on the patio instead of inside the restaurant because the table meant for us was still occupied. Our waitress was nice but she had too many tables to manage. My daughter ordered the large pasta with butter and it was inedible, incredibly over salted. Our waitress was too busy to check in with us so we had to wait until most of us were finished our meals before we could let the waitress know there was a problem with the pasta. When we told our waitress that there was a problem with the pasta dish she told us this never happens...sigh. I know it was a mistake made by the chef, no big deal but it's hard to hear "hey, don't know what you're talking about. this never happens". She did take the pasta dish off of our bill, and the rest of our meals were delicious. Waitress did thank us for our patience and I know she was overworked. Wish our daughter could have enjoyed her meal and reservations were honored.

Davene Johnson

At lunch there today with 6 others, what a beautiful place, our server was second to none!!!! The food was out of this world and only wish we had a place like this in Georgia. Here visiting and celebrating my grandsons college graduation. Ten gold stars with sprinkles to this amazing place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary

Excellent all the way around! So fantastic for a special occasion!!! The salad—blackberry avocado—the soup—chicken velvet— and THE CAKE —champagne raspberry—were simply delicious! We were celebrating the oldest and youngest events in my granddaughters' lives—return for summer from college and First Communion.Such a wonderful place for making memories!

Cake Bake is still a magical place to eat. The chicken salad was delicious as usual and the cream of mushroom soup was fine. The criminal thing is that they don't have caramel cake year round. For some reason, this has been deemed a seasonal cake. The wait staff will tell you it's one of the most requested cakes at Cake Bake. Why then, Bob is it not available year-round? Beyond frustrating!

Gina

Enjoyed celebrating my upcoming Birthday. Food was wonderful. Usually only have the delicious cakes. Ventured out to try the Lemon Curd Cheesecake-good, yet needed more lemon curd for flavoring and tang. Lemon bar also tried- too sweet, not enough lemon. Petunia Punch was wonderful. This was our 3rd dining experience at the Cake Bake, our server was so-so. It felt like we were an imposition.

B M

The shop is fancy and a nice place to visit when celebrating or treating yourself. Personally, I was not a fan of the cake flavor, but the cake decorations are very artful. These cakes make a great birthday gift too, but order early.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Louise Hoeft

The food was great! Fun place to eat!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Suburbs

You go for the atmosphere and we were sat in the very back. So many open tables and we asked to be near the porch area where it's more lively and we were told no. The quiche was bland and I asked for salt. The coconut passion fruit cake was a B+ for $17 a slice. Not a place I would go back to unless you want fun photos!

Carolyn Kilar

I really enjoyed our raspberry sangria and the desserts. The foodwas really quite terrible. I was told, my sandwich would come out warm, it was cold. Our delightful waitstaff person took it back and had it warmed in the oven. It did not taste good at all. The fries were very good and the sliders were much better than the ham and brie and poor boy shrimp sandwich. I mean come on $15 for a ham and cheese! Although the desserts are delight-ful it would be so very nice if customers could choose between a full slice or a half slice for half the price. Two adults and a child came to $244.00 with tip. Locations do not matter when it comes to gouging the customers.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Lemon Blueberry Cake, Apple Crumble Pie

Sabrina Cagle

The air conditioning was too cold for my liking.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Gluten-Free Black and White Cake

김유성

I bought the menu after receiving a recommendation in poor English, and it was really good~~

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

pickyicky

Another great visit to Cake Bake. I had the ham quiche, truffle fries and shared the red velvet cake ... Everything was very tasty! Service was on point and helpful. Only issue... it was quite chilly with the a/c. When mentioned to our server, she politely addressed our request to adjust it.

Humza Waheed

Hello guys and girls I’m visiting from the United Kingdom as someone that doesn’t live in the USA I had a few of my cousins and family members go to this shop today and I am disgusted with the way they were treated. I’m really proud of my religion as a Muslim I treat everyone the same way I want to be treated (with love and respect) Today’s performance from the staff was incredibly disgraceful as my cousins and family members where racially profiled and not allowed to enter or sit inside while other members of the public were aloud to enter without issue. If I can give a 0star review i would definitely leave one. I’ll never be purchasing anything from there ever again nor will I be sending any of my family to this shop i thought the USA had kind friendly people but after todays experience of being racially profiled I cannot wait to go back to the United Kingdom. NEVER WILL I VISIT THIS PLACE AGAIN. 0STARI hope the manger of the CEO reads this and has a strong talk with katherine or release her from her duty.Thanks for reading.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More

The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers, Carmel City Center

799 Hanover Place, Upper Deck, Hanover Place Suite 260, Carmel, IN 46032
(317) 257-2253