Auntie Em’s Farm Fresh Pies

113 E Main St, Centerville
(765) 541-2499

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Blake McKinsey

I love the whole atmosphere. It’s very cozy down to the decor & the products they sell like the pair of coffee cup earrings I got. ☕️ The coffee is great as well.

Karen Walton

I don't live in the area but come out often to camp at lake. Stopped in on a recent trip to check the shop out. It was worth the stop. The pie and pumpkin roll were the best I have had in a long time. Would definitely recommend.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Valerie Hunsinger

My favorite coffee spot! Not to mention their pies are amazing too!!!!

CatLady1015

There was barely any pie and no where to sit....they also had those church propaganda comics that have inappropriate illustrations about hell. Coffee wasn't the best either.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Laura Bissonnette

Delicious menu and friendly staff. God reward you!

Lyndsey boggs

Friendly place, good pie :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mindy Myers

The coffee & lattes are delicious and our family loves their peanut butter pie and chocolate chess pie!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristen Allen

We got raspberry pie slice and a chocolate cream pie slice- both delicious. My husband got a raspberry and toffee nut latte which he really liked. My drink was sublime. I got the spiced Chai and oh my goodness- absolutely delicious. If you like ginger and chai, get that drink! Friendly staff, too ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Janet Prows

I like the meringue better than the whipped cream on the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alivia Pence

Wonderful coffee service and products

Reed Bolser

The coffee was the best I ever had, and the pie I ate was AMAZING! Do yourself a favor and stop in. I really enjoyed visiting with Emily and Gina as well!

Laura Lamb Hope

Bought a strawberry pie and apple pie for family Christmas, and they were both a hit! My family LOVED the strawberry pie because of how fresh it was and they liked it didn’t have the heavy gel other pies can have. The apple pie was stuffed full with apples and was delicious! I personally don’t usually like pie crust, but the crust was so good I couldn’t resist. We also tried the seasonal hot chocolate, I got a toasted marshmallow and my husband tried the peppermint and they had the right amount of sweetness. We will be back and recommend to everyone. Thank you!

Dakota Firsich

I decided to do an in depth review so people can get a good feel for this place before going. First I have to say that if you are in the area this is a wonderful place to stop! Sometimes visiting places that are very religiously themed can be unpleasant because of the manners of the owner or workers. That was very much not the case! It felt very welcoming! My keys have oujia board stuff on them and there weren't any comments or weird looks. There were no pushy invitations to join a church it was just a place that seemed like it grew from the owners heart. They believe in god and want to share that part of themselves in their business. I think anyone who is interested in religion could probably have a nice chat with them about it even. Customer service was kind and fast! The shop is very clean and also cute with lots of themed coffee names. When I went in I ordered an iced peppermint mocha, a slice of gingerbread pie and a slice of blackberry pie. The total cost was about 20 dollars, so not too pricey for a specialty bake shop. The latte wasn't particularly to my taste but it was definitely made with good ingredients. I enjoy a very strong latte flavor but this tastes more like your standard normally brewed coffee flavor but it was espresso. So if that is your speed then it will probably be a 10/10 for you for me I'd give it an 8. I LOVED the gingerbread pie. This surprised me because I am sensitive to overly sweet things and I'm actually not very fond of gingerbread. But it was still a 10/10 for me. It had a great balance of flavor and sweetness. The graham cracker crust was also perfect. It wasn't soggy and it wasn't too hard. The blackberry pie was much the same. The regular pie crust wasn't soggy or too hard. It had the right balance of sweetness and most importantly the berries on top were fresh. It didn't just have blackberry jam thrown on it like a lot of blackberry flavored things. Blackberries are my favorite fruit so this was also a 10/10 personally. Overall my experience was a 9.5 out of 10. I hope people see this and go support a good local business! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeremy Kraft

Nantucket cranberry pie was delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...