Alexanders On The Water

369 W Jackson St, Cicero
(317) 984-8173

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Zach Charville

Great ice cream and great service!

Kris Deutsch

A manditory summertime visit !

Meagan Lackner

The ice cream was good with a nice view to enjoy.

Shannon McQuillen

Wow.. the small group of young hardworking girls in there working tonight were unreal! The joint was packed and they were so quick!! Props to them!!

Bruce Tapp

Very very rude customer service and unimpressive taste for overpriced ice cream. Will never go back!

We were the only people in line. My daughter asked for a sample, then my wife asked for another sample. No one person asked for a second sample, yet The lady loudly said ONLY TWO SAMPLES! She continued being unexpectedly rude throughout the entire transaction.

This treatment was extremely disappointing especially since we moved to the area and were excited about having a relaxing family moment by the lake.

Jason

Driven by so many times but never stopped until today. I got the Black Cherry and Buckeye hand dipped flavors which were quite good. But the Mrs's Tidal Wave was runny straight away like thin cream soup. Guess we'll throw it in the freezer and have it later...

Alicia

First time trying Alexanders. Got a butterscotch chocolate chip tidal wave. I was thinking it would be similar to a blizzard. That was not the case. It was thinner than a milkshake and didn't taste that great. Tried my husband ice cream and it was okay.

Hollie Nicholson

You can’t beat the view or the atmosphere here. Great spot year round and our kids best memories are a golf cart ride with friends to get ice cream. And it doesn't matter if there is a little line in the summer: the lake experience and people watching makes you feel like you're in a movie.

Hollie Nicholson
Personal Trainer & Nutrition Coach for women
(Yes, we eat ice cream :)

Marianny Kingston

Such a cool place to hang out, and the lake view gives off an incredible vibe. The ice cream is a solid 1000000/10.

Danton Harris

Butter Pecan and Cashews. On a waffle con. Yes. Very good. Pricey. $11.04 for two adult single scoop on waffle cones. $13.50 after tip. Good service and it was very busy but its dog days of summer on the water. I recommend this place. 👍🏻

Joe Large

Ice cream is sold with big servings great value and always tasty try 3 scoops of special flavors in a dish. My My My,!

Andrew Merrell

Does not have online menu. Impossible to see menu until you are up to order.
Has a different menu than Noblesville location.

John Davis

Great double cheeseburgers except they forgot the cheese. I ordered dbl cheese and she asked what I wanted on it. And I made the mistake of saying Mustard pickles and onions only,,,,,,

Derek Gibson

The drive-thru speaker wasn't working so we had to order at the window which made everything take much longer than usual. There are also some menu items online that they don't have at this location but the desserts we did get were very good. The service was nice, despite the slowness. We'll still go back because it's usually better than today's visit.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Sheldon Montgomery

How are you gonna stop taking orders cause you are busy very lame excuse hire part time or full time employees

Service: 1

Loading...