Columbia City Pizza Company

Excellent pizza, Mac & Cheese, and Breadsticks. Picked up order, ready right on time and fresh from the oven. Staff were all super friendly. If you want real pizza, not chain store, this is the place!

I never post reviews but this place definitely deserves one . I’m always so skeptical about trying new places but I went ahead and ordered the pizza was absolutely amazing and better than I expected . The cheese bread was also fantastic this is the best pizza place in town I will definitely be back !!

The Macaroni and Cheese on the menu is by far the best Macaroni and Cheese I've ever had.

This place is the best pizza and chicken in Columbia city. Great sauce options for your chicken and top tier service. Best place by far.

Train wreck was really good. Boneless buffalo wings were really good especially for the price, baked Mac and cheese was perfectly baked and fresh.Will definitely be back to try another pizza

So good! I love their weekend special. The breadsticks are great too. Awesome customer service & always deliver on time!

We've been living out here in the cornfields fer 7 years an nobody would deliver this close to the county line til Columbia City Pizza Company! Awesome job, great pizza! Wings are excellent! Lookin forward to more pizza deliveries! Thank y'all!

Columbia City Pizza Company has the best wings in town — hands down! The pizza is excellent too. I don’t think we will be ordering from Pizza Hut ever again. Its so neat to get this quality at a great price AND support a local business owned by a very neat family that is fully invested in our community. Five stars for sure!!

Hands down the best pizza in town. Nobody else even comes close. The prices are a little high but the quality is well worth the extra. I would highly recommend.

SOOOO GOOD. We tried two different pizzas, the mac n cheese, wings, and breadsticks. 10/10! Customer service was also great :-) We’ll definitely be back

I love trying new food and your pizza didn't disappoint my taste buds. I'll be back.

Crust was burnt. Like, black. Not baked at an even temperature. definitely not worth the 40 some bucks for the weekend special, that's for sure.Breadsticks however, are WONDERFUL.

Wasn't prepared for this. Got the freight train and the mac&cheese. Mac is a thick 5 cheese experience that could have songs written about it. The freight train was no slouch, keeping the ride going with no disappointment. The list of toppings is unjust to the medely of flavor it put in my mouth. A full meal left me extremely happy and nearly catatonic. Look forward to future orders, hopefully they can keep up with the high standard that they have set.

first time ordering, got 2 different pizza's and they were AMAZING! Family enjoyed as well! highly recommended

I love the friendliness of the crew. They’re always so polite and energetic. However I’ve never had an easy time ordering from here. I’ve had my order be misplaced and had to wait over an hour for my pizza. I’ve had discounts not work. Every time I’m promised they will throw something extra in for the inconvenience, but the extra item is never given. Today we ordered 3 pizzas thinking we would get the discount, but it was only for carry out. We were told again that we would be compensated for the mistake, but again not the case. I love the crew and I love how polite they are. I love how willing they are to make things right. I just wish we had better luck ordering. Their pizza is so good, though!!