Ye Olde Fish House

2024 17th St, Columbus
(812) 378-2921

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Peanut Butter Pie Pecan Pie and Lemon Pie

Tenderloin Sandwich with Fried Potatoes

Fish Basket Combo with Fried Potatoes

Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing

Fish Sandwich with Fried Potatoes

Fish Dinner Combo with 2 Sides

Signature Fish Sandwich

Strawberry Cheesecake

Great Fish Sandwich

Macaroni and Cheese

Photos

+51 photos

+50 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Ye Olde Fish House

Recent Reviews

5 Stars! We've heard of this little place (wth a 4.7 rating), so we did an early dinner. It was the best fish I've had in years! It was more than worth the 35 minute drive to Columbus.

October 2025

The front door sticks. So if you are there during regular hours and you think the door is locked, try again. I almost missed getting my first fish sandwich from Ye Olde Fish House and I’m so glad I didn’t!! Amazing ppl, amazing service and AMAZING FISH!!
Can’t wait to try the ham and beans.
And if you follow my posts, you know I don’t like it at restaurants like Subway, 5Guys and Starbucks that have tip jars out. Well, these people are amazing. They...

October 2025

Delicious fish sandwich. I have heard from several people that this is the local place to grab a fish sandwich. It certainly didn't disappoint. I'm a mayo and ketchup guy, but they offered a tarter along with other condiments as options.

August 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Columbus, IN

Ye Olde Fish House

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Ye Olde Fish House