Ahlemeyer Bakery
$ • Bakery, Gluten-Free, VeganAbout Ahlemeyer Bakery
Customers' Favorites
Ahlemeyer Bakery Reviews
Share your opinion about Ahlemeyer Bakery
We visited Ahlemeyer Bakery last week.
Though I've been wanting to write a post about their pies since then, life got in the way.
We bought three pies: apple, mixed berries, and sugar cream. Oh, the sweet taste of American pies! I'm salivating just thinking about them.
My favorite was their apple pie: a perfect blend of tart and sweet. Their pie crust, oh heaven, was soft, airy, crunchy, and buttery. I could form a mattress out of that pie crust and sink my...read full review
I love Ahlemeyer Bakery and I go there weekly. Sarah Beth and Samantha are amazing! Everything they make is delicious! Their pies are scrumptious. in addition to all their regular goodies, they do special orders and can prepare desserts according to dietary restrictions. They do special menus for holidays and events like PI day! They are kind, helpful,friendly and have the best attitudes. We are so fortunate to have this wonderful bakery in Columbus.
So wonderful and easy to do business with for my son’s birthday. Thank you so much!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 2 - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 12PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Ahlemeyer Bakery is a great local bakery known for its outstanding pies and cakes. They provide excellent customer service, responding promptly to inquiries and fulfilling custom orders. Their Kentucky Chocolate pie is a rich treat, and their carrot cake is delicious. Recently, customers have raved about their apple pie, which features a perfect blend of tart and sweet flavors, with a pie crust that is soft, airy, crunchy, and buttery. They also offer a Sugar Cream pie, which is praised as a true Indiana tradition. Prices are fair, and orders are ready as promised, making it a wonderful spot for special occasions. This local favorite is also known for its gooey German chocolate brownies and a variety of cookies, making it a go-to place for sweet treats.