John's Pizzeria
1209 Sheffield Ave, Dyer
(219) 322-8400
Customers' Favorites
Cheese and Sausage Pizza
Homemade Garlic Bread
Fettuccine Alfredo
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Vesuvio
Beef Sandwich
Fried Zucchini
Cheese Pizza
Wings
Menu
Photos
+63 photos
+62 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I wasn't very impressed here. Pizza was just ok. Nothing to write home about. We got a few basic pizzas and it took almost an hour to get them. I think only one lady was working lounge side and the seating area so we hardly saw her. I had to go up and ask for our bill so we could pay.
Hoping to find the frozen pizza of my youth, I sought out this place. It may be the stuff of Friday night meals, but it was hard to tell as we ordered sausage and mushrooms. Crispy crust served with sufficient amount of sauce and toppings. Italian Peroni beer on tap was a nice touch.
The wine size wasn't a value for the price, however. This is not the city.
The 50s diner music was annoying after the first half hour, as it was loud for the few occupants...
The wine size wasn't a value for the price, however. This is not the city.
The 50s diner music was annoying after the first half hour, as it was loud for the few occupants...
I love this place!! Shout out to Maria. She’s a sweat heart. And shout out to Alex for being a boss! Love there energy and very clean and pure hearted people with the best pizza in town
You May Also Like
Boz Hot Dogs - 1205 Sheffield Ave
![]()
Fast Food, Hot Dogs, American, Soup
Sheffield's Restaurant - 1027 Sheffield Ave
![]()
Sports Bar, American, Vegetarian