Antonio's Italian Restaurant

1105 Goshen Ave, Elkhart
(574) 295-8424

Recent Reviews

Pat R.

Incredible pizza. Life changing flavor. Out of this world people and food. Do yourself a favor and get some quality authentic food!Food: 5/5

Holly Jenkins

We ordered from the wrong one and they didn't skip a beet. They made everything we originally wanted and was done in a timely manner. I love everything they have on the menu. Very friendly and clean place...Food: 5/5

B Schatz

We ordered a classic pepperoni pizza to go and it was totally worth the drive across town. Terrific flavor! We put it up there as one of the best pizzas in Elkhart. Nice atmosphere on the inside. The staff were welcoming and helpful. We look forward to returning to dine in to try one of their many appetizing entrees!Food: 5/5

Kara R

This place has THE best Italian food!! Their mozzarella sticks are a must try as they are fresh not frozen. We love sitting on the patio and watching the chefs come out to pick fresh herbs and ingredients from their own garden.Food: 5/5

Dave Cipriani

Looking for a place to have a nice dinner for Father's Day, we found Antonio's. Wow! Excellent food, service, etc! We got a pizza and the lasagna. The pizza was fantastic. Lots of meat, well cooked and piping hot when it came out. The lasagna was some of the best I've ever had. We have already decided we are going back for my birthday next week!! If this review has helped, give it a thumbs up!

Fred Yager

Outstanding. This was my second time there and the food is great. I love a meaty pizza and the Stallion does not disappoint. Tons of pepperoni and bacon and sausage. 14” of pizza heaven. I could not begin to eat it all. Not even half which is how much I planned on boxing up for home.Food: 5/5

Lee Back

Got there as soon as they opened. Glad we did. An hour later and the line was out the door. Good food and good service!Parking: Enough for the diners.Wheelchair accessibility: All ground level.

Sharon Harrison

They put a party of three in a side dinning room off from the bar that had 2 large groups. Both groups were very loud and getting louder with the more they drank. It made it impossible to have a conversation or to enjoy our food or dinning experience. Our waitress was busy with the two large groups and we were neglected- had to flag her down multiple times to get drink refills, boxes to take our food home.


Food, atmosphere, service even the patrons are wonderful here.Food: 5/5

Santino Patragas

Amazing food but specifically the pizza!

Laura Majerczak

We decided to take a 90 minute road trip to this place because it was a lengthy wait the last time we drove through Elkhart. We remembered it smelled so good from the outside! At 58 years old and I can honestly say it's the BEST PIZZA I've ever had!!! Went with the regular was phenomenal!!!! Also tried the Lasagna Bolognese. Best sauce ever! I'm so full but worth the drive & the 35 minute wait. Decor is dated but very clean and well maintained inside. Classic Italian restaurant. We'll be back!!!

Andrew Fry

Great food and flavor. Not knots and mozzarella sticks were really good. Kids menu is not really existent, but kiddos (ages 4-11) liked the portion size of the create your own pasta. Youngest got a small pizza; desserts were really good as well. Service was great as well and very attentive even with how busy they were on a Saturday evening. So many things we wanted to try so we'll have to come back soon!


My wife and I were invited to join some old friends, we are all seniors, arrived at 430 on Saturday night, right time to go, my wife ordered the salmon and I ordered the chicken, both with out salad. Good food, good service, clean place. But , over priced for the quantity of food, we went home and ate a big bowl of popcorn, only drank water there and our bill was still 60.00 .we are not big people, and my wife rarely can finish her meal, she cleaned the plate. Needless to say we will not be returning. Thank you

Ilia Quinonez

Great Italian place. The garlic knots are amazing and not your typical garlic knot they are very light and airy. We had the shrimp Alfredo and it was really good! Great atmosphere and great prices. We will be going back to try the pizza!Food: 5/5

God, family & country

So I've heard of this place for years, finally went to elkhart to try it out. It's very good. They are definitely in my top 5 pizza places to eat. Actual fresh food with Actual fresh ingredients beats the daylights out of pizza chains 100% of the time. Very pleased with this purchase.Food: 5/5

Load More

Antonio's Italian Restaurant

1105 Goshen Ave, Elkhart, IN 46516
(574) 295-8424