We typically order from Papa Johns more often because they usually have better deals and lower prices than the competition. However, the last several times in a row that I ordered from here I got my pizza home to discover that it was not done. When biting into a slice it is still a bit doughy. And the bottom of the pizza is undercooked just enough that it's sticking to the box. The first time I thought it was an oversight or a mistake, the second time I was starting to wonder but this time makes three times in a row and I'm not sure I want to continue ordering. Even though I'll pay a little more from Domino's, I may start ordering from them more frequently. I have never once received an undercooked pizza from them. An undercooked pizza that is still doughy can make people sick. It certainly doesn't settle well with my stomach. On a positive note, the staff at Papa Johns has always been friendly to me every time I have picked up my pizza. I have no complaints against the staff. I don't know if the oven are on the wrong temperature for some reason or if people are just pulling the pizzas out a little early, I have no clue what's going on I only know that the last three times in a row I've ordered, my pizzas were undercooked.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie
Jeremy Stone
Way more consistent than the "Bloomington" address stores. Worth the few minutes drive to know you will get what you ordered and that it's not hurriedly thrown together.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica
They were swamped. New Years Eve, which was understandable. I'm very patient and understanding, though. The Papa tracker was off. It's probably due to the number of orders coming in. The gal with the pixie cut blue hair was super friendly and made me feel relaxed and welcome. Even with as busy as they were. My only issue was that we requested the pizzas all well done. They were far from it. I understand they are stressed and pressed for time. It was not a huge deal, but it's how we like our pizzas done. Other than that, it was really good. I would definitely order Papa John's in Ellettsville again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Medium Pepperoni Pizza, Medium Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza, Spicy Italian Sausage, Breadsticks
S R
We ordered extra cheese, and it didn't cover half the pizza. We ordered extra, not light! Also, one pizza was missing the only topping that we ordered aside from the cheese. How do you forget the only topping???? What a waste of money. FNO, we will get Domino's.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Carrie Green Evans
We love Papa John’s and order frequently. We did want to let you know that when our pizza arrived tonight, it looked like it had been involved in a hit and run. We understand things can’t always be perfect and will continue to be loyal customers. We just thought you want to know. It was still delicious!!
Took way too long to receive the pizza and wasn't done, and was luke warm by the time I got it home. Very disappointed this time!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Chanda Ferguson
Never fails to have a great tasting pizzaVegetarian options: I can't remember clearlyParking: Parking lot, seemed big enough for the restaurantKid-friendliness: Yes,Wheelchair accessibility: I just remember the parking and the wheelchair signs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza,
Rachel Cole
Waited 2.5 hours for a 35 minute delivery (2nd time for this location) obviously the food was cold. They made a new order and sent it out, unfortunately, the new order was not good either. The manager was kind enough to refund our order though after all of the issues.
Food: 1
Misty Welch
We are new to the area from Indianapolis.We typically order Papa John's weekly. Our 1st experience to the Ellettsville location was outstanding. Upon arrival we were greeted with a smile by Aaron and food was grrrreat. We will definitely be back on a regular basis :)
Pizza was barely warm it was delivered but it was basically
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Craig Moore
We ordered pizza for my little sister because we were running late and the delivery driver in the Trump trailblazer tried to force himself into our home. Do NOT order pizza from here.
Jolie
Best pizza in Ellettsville!Pizza is always amazing and they definitely have the best deals in town! They rarely make mistakes. However, our last order, they forgot the extra dipping sauces we ordered. When we went back to pick them up, they were super nice and gave us extra ones for our trouble. That was definitely enough to make up for it but they went a step further, a few days later we got a coupon for a free medium size cheese pizza for the mistake, great company...great pizza.
TC Martindale
Ordered two pizzas, found a sharp piece of plastic on one. A shame, I used to order from here all the time but I think that's it for me...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Shanan Lucas
The young lady that waited on me was super friendly. She was awesome.
We typically order from Papa Johns more often because they usually have better deals and lower prices than the competition. However, the last several times in a row that I ordered from here I got my pizza home to discover that it was not done. When biting into a slice it is still a bit doughy. And the bottom of the pizza is undercooked just enough that it's sticking to the box. The first time I thought it was an oversight or a mistake, the second time I was starting to wonder but this time makes three times in a row and I'm not sure I want to continue ordering. Even though I'll pay a little more from Domino's, I may start ordering from them more frequently. I have never once received an undercooked pizza from them. An undercooked pizza that is still doughy can make people sick. It certainly doesn't settle well with my stomach. On a positive note, the staff at Papa Johns has always been friendly to me every time I have picked up my pizza. I have no complaints against the staff. I don't know if the oven are on the wrong temperature for some reason or if people are just pulling the pizzas out a little early, I have no clue what's going on I only know that the last three times in a row I've ordered, my pizzas were undercooked.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie
Way more consistent than the "Bloomington" address stores. Worth the few minutes drive to know you will get what you ordered and that it's not hurriedly thrown together.
Food: 5
Service: 5
They were swamped. New Years Eve, which was understandable. I'm very patient and understanding, though. The Papa tracker was off. It's probably due to the number of orders coming in. The gal with the pixie cut blue hair was super friendly and made me feel relaxed and welcome. Even with as busy as they were. My only issue was that we requested the pizzas all well done. They were far from it. I understand they are stressed and pressed for time. It was not a huge deal, but it's how we like our pizzas done. Other than that, it was really good. I would definitely order Papa John's in Ellettsville again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Medium Pepperoni Pizza, Medium Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza, Spicy Italian Sausage, Breadsticks
We ordered extra cheese, and it didn't cover half the pizza. We ordered extra, not light! Also, one pizza was missing the only topping that we ordered aside from the cheese. How do you forget the only topping???? What a waste of money. FNO, we will get Domino's.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We love Papa John’s and order frequently. We did want to let you know that when our pizza arrived tonight, it looked like it had been involved in a hit and run. We understand things can’t always be perfect and will continue to be loyal customers. We just thought you want to know. It was still delicious!!
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Love Papa John's always my go to love it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Brownie, Pepperoni Pizza, Medium Pepperoni Pizza, Medium Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza, Dipping Sauces, BBQ Wings, Breadsticks, Cheese Sauce, Knots, Cinnamon Pull Aparts
Took way too long to receive the pizza and wasn't done, and was luke warm by the time I got it home. Very disappointed this time!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Never fails to have a great tasting pizzaVegetarian options: I can't remember clearlyParking: Parking lot, seemed big enough for the restaurantKid-friendliness: Yes,Wheelchair accessibility: I just remember the parking and the wheelchair signs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza,
Waited 2.5 hours for a 35 minute delivery (2nd time for this location) obviously the food was cold. They made a new order and sent it out, unfortunately, the new order was not good either. The manager was kind enough to refund our order though after all of the issues.
Food: 1
We are new to the area from Indianapolis.We typically order Papa John's weekly. Our 1st experience to the Ellettsville location was outstanding. Upon arrival we were greeted with a smile by Aaron and food was grrrreat. We will definitely be back on a regular basis :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Brownie, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Sauce
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was barely warm it was delivered but it was basically
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
We ordered pizza for my little sister because we were running late and the delivery driver in the Trump trailblazer tried to force himself into our home. Do NOT order pizza from here.
Best pizza in Ellettsville!Pizza is always amazing and they definitely have the best deals in town! They rarely make mistakes. However, our last order, they forgot the extra dipping sauces we ordered. When we went back to pick them up, they were super nice and gave us extra ones for our trouble. That was definitely enough to make up for it but they went a step further, a few days later we got a coupon for a free medium size cheese pizza for the mistake, great company...great pizza.
Ordered two pizzas, found a sharp piece of plastic on one. A shame, I used to order from here all the time but I think that's it for me...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
The young lady that waited on me was super friendly. She was awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5