Andy's Diner
$ •
Hours:
7925 IN-28, Elwood
(765) 557-8798
About Andy's Diner
Customers' Favorites
Andy's Diner Reviews
Share your opinion about Andy's Diner
Great food. Good deals on steaks.
I always look forward to eating at Andy's when I come to Elwood to visit my family. We stopped in last night and were super disappointed. The waitress was sitting at a table with other customers while we waited to get our drinks even ordered. The baked potato was very dried out and hush puppies were burnt to a crisp. Just an all around bad experience last night.
My husband & I ate dinner for the 1st time last night. When I headed to the salad bar the mushroom's were VERY dark. But thought hey I'll try them they might just be starting to lose their color. When I placed some on my plate OMG the worst smell hit me. Got back to my table & picked one up to see if that's what I was smelling & it was. They were dark brown & slimy & was way beyond their expiration. I mentioned it to our waitress (whom was great) & she said 'Yea usually they are...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 7PM |
Andy's Diner is a pleasant and affordable restaurant offering excellent food and friendly service. The menu features a variety of options, including a delicious porterhouse steak, 3-piece fish dinner, kids' mac and cheese, and a hearty Tenderloin sandwich with light breading. Customers enjoy the big fat crinkle fries, flavorful pop, and cold coffee drinks. The restaurant is clean, organized, and provides fast, attentive service, making it a hidden gem worth revisiting. Many guests appreciate the good service, friendly staff, and great prices, along with specials like country fried chicken. Wheelchair accessibility is available, and the diner continues to be a popular spot for delicious meals and friendly atmosphere.
Customers have praised the welcoming atmosphere, delicious food, and excellent service. The beef manhattan special on Fridays is a particular favorite, with one reviewer describing it as one of the best they've had. The fried pickles, regular and seasoned fries, and sweet tea have also received high praise. The staff is consistently described as friendly and helpful, ensuring a pleasant dining experience for all.