14 Best Italian Restaurants in Evansville

“amazing food and experience!“

“VERY good food. Flavors and portions on point, reasonable prices. Only negative thing is it’s so quiet and music was way too low. Kinda depressing. Will come back though when we’re in really, really good moods! 🤪“

“I was born and raised here until I was 18, and every time I come home to visit, Fazoli’s is my 1st stop. Everything is always delicious, hot and the staff are top tier. They are always so sweet and go above and beyond. Yolanda was our fave today. Such a sweet soul. Thank you for decades of happiness 💜“

“Michelle was very friendly and professional. She resolved anything that we were questionable concerning. We were uncertain about some things regarding what we were receiving though she made for sure we received exactly what we wanted and was prompt within her service. The bread sticks were delicious and fresh. The rest of the food we ordered was as well. . Michelle went above and beyond to make sure that we had a truly pleasant experience and was very bubbly and personable. It is hard to come across a person that practices such customer service skills. If we are in the area again we will be sure to stop back through.“

“We run all over the country for work and we love trying local places along the way. When you arrive it doesn’t necessarily look like much. It gets more welcoming inside though. And the best part…the food and service were amazing. We didn’t know what we were in for until the salad and garlic bread showed up. Great! We had chicken cordon bleu and baked ziti. Again, great. If what you’re looking for is great food and service without the frills, this is an awesome option. At least it proved so for us!“

“Delicious food and cocktails!!!“

“Very impressed with the food and service. Thank you Milano's for a great meal and service!!“

“Wanted to try something different so I got the oven baked spaghetti, meat sauce and garlic bread. Thought because of the low price the portions would be small so I ordered two. Got home and very surprised - large portions and will save the second for tomorrow. Will definitely be back in the future!“

“Tonight my wife and I enjoyed a nice meal at the Olive Garden on Greenriver Road here in Evansville. The atmosphere was pleasant , the food was delicious, and our server “Yonatan M. was the best we’re had.“

“I will say me and my husband have ate at Olive Garden many times, but at the new location this was our first time and we had the most amazing experience. From the beginning our server was such a delight she welcomed our table with a smile every time , food was amazing never had to ask for anything once and not to mention we were checked in on couple times by what looked like some sort of manager and other servers all always with a smile and positive attitude, after this expierience I can assure you that we will be comming back and the food was amazing“

“We went the Smitty’s on a Sunday Night for our anniversary dinner and had the best dining experience a person could ask for. I had the Grouper Parmigiana, and my husband had the Italian Sausage and Peppers. Both were delicious; but that’s not the best part. -- When we started dating, I would always put a virtual candle up on my phone screen and set it on the table. Today, I did the same for old time’s sake. The waitress came to our table to take our drink order and noticed the virtual candle I has set up on the table and I casually mentioned it was our first anniversary and jokingly asked if it was a possible if they have a real candle laying around. WELL, WE GOT A REAL CANDLE. Michael, the assistant manager took it upon himself to make this happen. This man when to the dollar store to pick up a candle for us instead of just telling us it wasn’t possible, or they didn’t have one. THIS SIMPLE GESTURE MADE THE NIGHT SO SPECIAL. We took it home and are lighting it on the following anniversaries. – Other notes, the booths are so intimate and perfect for this type of occasion. We happened to be there on the one Sunday a month they do Jazz, they had a wine bottle deal we took advantage of, and the lovely waitress even acted as sommelier and poured us our first glass. You have earned our business for our following anniversaries, and we highly recommend dining here for such occasions. THANK YOU!“

“We absolutely love Spankey’s pizza and salads. Service is always amazing 🍕🥗 😋“

“Best stroms and hot ham and cheese around.“

“DiMaggio’s Pizza is absolutely fantastic! My go-to order is the pepperoni with hot honey, and it is unreal. The crust is perfectly crispy yet chewy, the pepperoni is flavorful, and the hot honey adds the perfect sweet-heat kick! Yum!“