13 Best Italian Restaurants in Evansville

“Always a great experience. All the staff go above and beyond to make sure it is a good meal and good time. Yolanda is what makes the entire thing awesome. She is seriously our favorite employee!!! We always pray she's there when we go!“

“Michelle was very friendly and professional. She resolved anything that we were questionable concerning. We were uncertain about some things regarding what we were receiving though she made for sure we received exactly what we wanted and was prompt within her service. The bread sticks were delicious and fresh. The rest of the food we ordered was as well. . Michelle went above and beyond to make sure that we had a truly pleasant experience and was very bubbly and personable. It is hard to come across a person that practices such customer service skills. If we are in the area again we will be sure to stop back through.“

“amazing food and experience!“

“VERY good food. Flavors and portions on point, reasonable prices. Only negative thing is it’s so quiet and music was way too low. Kinda depressing. Will come back though when we’re in really, really good moods! 🤪“

“Food and drink was excellant! It's also in a very cute old house!“

“Very impressed with the food and service. Thank you Milano's for a great meal and service!!“

“Delicious food and cocktails!!!“

“Fantastic Italian cuisine. Stuffed mushrooms were great as was the chicken cordon bleu. The German Riesling Wine paired well with this dish. Great atmosphere. They were ok with early evening walk-ins, but the restaurant filled up quickly. Street parking.“

“I love love love this restaurant they have great food and a great stuff“

“Tonight my wife and I enjoyed a nice meal at the Olive Garden on Greenriver Road here in Evansville. The atmosphere was pleasant , the food was delicious, and our server “Yonatan M. was the best we’re had.“

“Great food, great atmosphere, and excellent service.“

“Best stroms and hot ham and cheese around.“

“The company I work for uses Smitty's occasionally for work events. Yesterday we had a miscommunication, and when we got there to set up for our event they didn't know we were coming. Katie and the rest of the crew went above and beyond to quicly set up the private room and accommodate our 25 guests. I don't believe there is another restaurant in town that would have pulled this off for us, and Smitty's staff did it with grace and good humor. As always, the food and service were outstanding. Thank you, Katie, and the rest of the staff for helping to make our evening a great success!“