This place is from Heaven! We travel from Louisville ky to get the Sticky Bun and apple pie on the regular. for Thanksgiving Holiday we have the pumpkin pie delivered to our house. So glade we found this hidden gem! Such warm and freindly svc! A treat threw and threw!!
Kellie Taylor
Charming company with genuine and personable owners. The chocolate bourbon pecan pie is 10/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marilee Anderson
Friendly service. Pie slices are so small! And $6 a slice. Highway robbery. ITs about 3 bites! High priced.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Drew Schaffer
I had the sticky bun. Ate it with my fingers it was that good. May be a good idea to get extra portions when you go here. Its really hard to share.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ellen Stuart
Very disappointing cherry pie that was way over priced st $32. Crust was soggy and filling poor
Rachel
Amazing breads omg
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A A
A friendly shopper at Fresh Market advised me to check out “the pie guy” at the local farmer’s market. She said he’d be right in the front. We followed her advise and purchased a sweet potato pie and a lemon cheese pie. I’m so glad we did! We took the pies to a family dinner and they were a big hit. They were fresh, delicious and flavorful! Will definitely hit them up the next time we’re in town.
Jessica Manifold
The best sweet potato pie next to my grandma's I've had!!! So excited try more! Good addition to Fortville market and Fortville!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachel Tolliver
About half way through the best banana bread I’ve ever had and so many great other flavors I’ve tried so far 🔥🔥
Kent Shaffer
We love the chocolate chess pie and the pecan rolls! Everything is delicious!?
We had heard about Generations PieCompany, so we gave it a try this Thanksgiving. Never again. We were so disappointed. First, the man working at theFortville location was rude when my husband picked up. The caramel apple pie was terrible. It was so watery, the crust was soft. The pumpkin seemed under cookedand had very little filling.. My family all said a grocery pie would have been better. Thankgoodness I had made another dessert. That is what everyone ate. My dad who loves sweets, didn't even want the leftover pie.We threw it out
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Sarah Williams
I bought a small bourbon chocolate pecan pie from the downtown farmer's market and it was friggin' delicious. I will definitely be trekking to wherever they'll be selling pies in the future and can't wait to try more flavors!
Shaunna Lehman
Picked up a small lemon chess pie and wish I had bought the large pie. So freaking good! Great find at Carmel Farmers market!
Angela Osman
The crust on their apple pie is *chef’s kiss*. The apple filling is also amazing.
Lacy Panyard Holton
Got one of these pies at the farmers market. Highly suggest Hattie’s apple pie.
This place is from Heaven! We travel from Louisville ky to get the Sticky Bun and apple pie on the regular. for Thanksgiving Holiday we have the pumpkin pie delivered to our house. So glade we found this hidden gem! Such warm and freindly svc! A treat threw and threw!!
Charming company with genuine and personable owners. The chocolate bourbon pecan pie is 10/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly service. Pie slices are so small! And $6 a slice. Highway robbery. ITs about 3 bites! High priced.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
I had the sticky bun. Ate it with my fingers it was that good. May be a good idea to get extra portions when you go here. Its really hard to share.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very disappointing cherry pie that was way over priced st $32. Crust was soggy and filling
poor
Amazing breads omg
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A friendly shopper at Fresh Market advised me to check out “the pie guy” at the local farmer’s market. She said he’d be right in the front. We followed her advise and purchased a sweet potato pie and a lemon cheese pie. I’m so glad we did! We took the pies to a family dinner and they were a big hit. They were fresh, delicious and flavorful! Will definitely hit them up the next time we’re in town.
The best sweet potato pie next to my grandma's I've had!!! So excited try more! Good addition to Fortville market and Fortville!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
About half way through the best banana bread I’ve ever had and so many great other flavors I’ve tried so far 🔥🔥
We love the chocolate chess pie and the pecan rolls! Everything is delicious!?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We had heard about Generations PieCompany, so we gave it a try this Thanksgiving. Never again. We were so disappointed. First, the man working at theFortville location was rude when my husband picked up. The caramel apple pie was terrible. It was so watery, the crust was soft. The pumpkin seemed under cookedand had very little filling.. My family all said a grocery pie would have been better. Thankgoodness I had made another dessert. That is what everyone ate. My dad who loves sweets, didn't even want the leftover pie.We threw it out
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
I bought a small bourbon chocolate pecan pie from the downtown farmer's market and it was friggin' delicious. I will definitely be trekking to wherever they'll be selling pies in the future and can't wait to try more flavors!
Picked up a small lemon chess pie and wish I had bought the large pie. So freaking good! Great find at Carmel Farmers market!
The crust on their apple pie is *chef’s kiss*. The apple filling is also amazing.
Got one of these pies at the farmers market. Highly suggest Hattie’s apple pie.
Loading...