I love your ice cream selection and the pup cups! This is one of my favorite places to go for ice cream, and they also have cotton candy. They have a bit of shopping, too. You never know what you're going to find in there.
Derek Gustin
Great local ice cream shop. I've tried several flavors in a dish and they are all good. I usually get a sundae though. Libby's makes THE BEST! Don't forget to check the freezer too. The ice cream sandwiches and brownies are good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara B.
Who doesn't love Libby's?! I buy gift cards for family in the area anytime I'm there because I know it's a stop they'll make. They serve Sundae's ice cream (best ice cream in Indiana!), they have a play area for the you get kids (which is amazing!) and have so many cute gifts if you need to grab something quickly. Their servings are pretty big so keep that in mind :)
the only
Super cute ice-cream place with delicious flavors for an incredibly decent price! staff was pleasant and the atmosphere was very comfy and nice, would absolutely recommend people stop by!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Haley Ryan
Libby’s Ice Cream is absolutely your best option as an alternative for wedding cakes in the Indy area! To start, their ice cream tasting is phenomenal. We were overwhelmed with all their flavor options - in a good way! After deciding to go with ice cream for our wedding day we already knew Libby’s was the way to go, she was a delight to work with in helping us narrow down our flavors and working up a quote. We never felt like we were being upsold or pushed to spend more than we wanted. Past that, they were solid with communication, the ice cream showed up on time and as expected (looking PHENOMENAL), and tasted AMAZING! We got so many compliments from our wedding guests on it. Overall - highly, highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Flight
Tammy Anderson
Great service, but not much of selection.
joyce pack
The watermelon sorbet spritzer is amazing. Very refreshing!
Glen Heppner
Good ice cream and a nice throwback vibe.
Isabelle M.
Libby's is such a cute ice cream shop in Fortville! They have all the classic flavors but also fun and different ones. I loved the mint chocolate chip. My fiancé got the strawberry banana and it was amazing. Really spacious inside with lots of seating!
Best ice cream ever and great people too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love your ice cream selection and the pup cups! This is one of my favorite places to go for ice cream, and they also have cotton candy. They have a bit of shopping, too. You never know what you're going to find in there.
Great local ice cream shop. I've tried several flavors in a dish and they are all good. I usually get a sundae though. Libby's makes THE BEST! Don't forget to check the freezer too. The ice cream sandwiches and brownies are good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Who doesn't love Libby's?! I buy gift cards for family in the area anytime I'm there because I know it's a stop they'll make. They serve Sundae's ice cream (best ice cream in Indiana!), they have a play area for the you get kids (which is amazing!) and have so many cute gifts if you need to grab something quickly. Their servings are pretty big so keep that in mind :)
Super cute ice-cream place with delicious flavors for an incredibly decent price! staff was pleasant and the atmosphere was very comfy and nice, would absolutely recommend people stop by!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Libby’s Ice Cream is absolutely your best option as an alternative for wedding cakes in the Indy area! To start, their ice cream tasting is phenomenal. We were overwhelmed with all their flavor options - in a good way! After deciding to go with ice cream for our wedding day we already knew Libby’s was the way to go, she was a delight to work with in helping us narrow down our flavors and working up a quote. We never felt like we were being upsold or pushed to spend more than we wanted. Past that, they were solid with communication, the ice cream showed up on time and as expected (looking PHENOMENAL), and tasted AMAZING! We got so many compliments from our wedding guests on it. Overall - highly, highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Flight
Great service, but not much of selection.
The watermelon sorbet spritzer is amazing. Very refreshing!
Good ice cream and a nice throwback vibe.
Libby's is such a cute ice cream shop in Fortville! They have all the classic flavors but also fun and different ones. I loved the mint chocolate chip. My fiancé got the strawberry banana and it was amazing. Really spacious inside with lots of seating!
Restaurantji Recommends
A staple for Fortville. We love walking downtown and taking our kids here.
It's really good but their prices are kinda crazy for what you're getting... Not trying to be rude, just honest.
Friendly people and the ice cream was good flavorful.
really good ice cream and I go here all the time
Excellent ice cream. Friendly staff.