Timmy's Pizza & BBQ Garrett

Perfect every time

I haven’t even had a chance to try the food. All I know is I called up and explained my concern that the ribs that I got were too rubbery! The manager at the time not sure if he’s the owner or what his name was Tim. He offered to let me get a new full slab of ribs tomorrow free of charge to make up for the ribs that I got today! Excellent service great care for the customer and great pride in the business! 5 stars just for that! That’s rare!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

The Chicago Style is huge! A medium could probably feed a family of 4. The guy at the counter was friendly and my order was ready when I walked in. The dining room is small but it looks clean and all the signs are cool.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Railroader Pizza, Sausage Roll

Best pizza, best smoked wings, best crazy dough, best sausage rolls+. Hardest working & down to earth owners you’ll ever meet! Love all their food! Catch them on the road as well at the festivals too! You won’t be disappointed!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We love Timmy's ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Incredible customer service. Everybody was happy to help and they all waved me goodbye as I left with my delicious order of wings and cheesy bread.

Was very good pizza, and what they call rolls I didn't try, but was told they were fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food. Great service! The people were wonderful

They have absolutely delicious pizza they put the right amount of toppings. Also all the bbq is mouth watering. Would definitely recommend.

I only ate their once before they temporarily closed and remodeled their company. But I LOVED and I mean LOVED the pizza there. I was very impressed with my order.And I wouldn’t mind one bit to eat there again! Great place for small-town pizza

Best Chicago style pizza around Indiana

Timmys has always been a once in a while treat that everyone looked forward to until you changed the sausage being used. Timmys has always used a finely ground seasoned sausage on pizzas, sausage rolls and strombolies. Which was great. Now you have switched to a large chunky sausage and it just isn't the sane. Not an improvement unfortunately. If it's not broke don't fix it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Nachos

Owners wife makes her own mango sauce that is so good. All of their menu options are good. Wait staff is nice. Plenty of food for the price. Train wreck pizza is our favorite. Clean restaurant.

I stopped in last night for the first time and ate in the dinning room. Very nice experience. Clean. The staff was awesome super friendly! Our food was great! The new owner is really turning stuff around?

Clean, comforting atmosphere. The staff and owner are caring and friendly. I had a pepperoni Chicago style pizza, it tasted amazing, from the sauce, to the toppings and cheese. probably my go to pizza place from now on.