Little Caesars Pizza

2560 Garfield St, Gary
(219) 885-5558

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cephas Pullins

Clean. Efficient.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jess

They overly burnt my breadsticks they weren’t even edible I’m pregnant n was exited to eat just to open em to see this bs

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Ramika

Horrible pizza I thought when the new owners took over there would be a change. Hecky naw order online get there to pick up 2 of the 8.99 sausage pizza, they had 1 sausage per slice of pizza. This isn't what I paid for. Give me what I pay for. Tragically put together. Will never come here again. I rather spend more money for better quality food.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Gloria Ramos

This location is a disappointment. My Crazy Bread arrived burnt! Please tell me how and why they thought burnt bread was ok to serve?! Shame on all of them!! Never again will I ordered from this location!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Asa Johnson

Bread sticks burnt and I didn't get my sauce

Food: 3

Service: 3

Baby Boo

They'll take your money! No food received no refund issued!
Rude people. Im starting to think Little Caesars as a brand is to blame for allowing these independent owners to operate under their name in such a disgusting way.
The girl with the glasses that works at the front counter is unsanitary she'll cough, sneeze and wipe her nose without sanitizing after and will proceed to touch everything including your food! No need to wonder why people keep getting sick 😒 just nasty.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Queen Love

Update: I called multiple times for a refund for an order I never received. I was told the owner will reach out to me and process my regund, still haven't received a call, email, text, Morris code or MY REFUND !!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sonya “REDD” Webster

Omg this pizza is so good yall

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ayrial Frith

I place my order online on 12/18/2025 Thursday. I purchased three pizza’s. I placed the order for 12/19/2025 for 1:30 pick up. When I arrived my mom went in to get the pizza’s. When she brought them to my van they were cold to the touch. So I went back in and told the girl at the front corner that my food was cold. She stated with a nasty rude attitude that the pizza’s were placed for a 10:30am order and I told her that was wrong that it was for 1:30pm. So I went to van to grab my phone so I could show her the time on my phone. Then she acted like she didn’t want to see my phone. She kept saying that it was someone else’s fault. So eventually they made the order over. The whole experience was a mess because I had to take those pizza’s to my son school for their Christmas party. And I didn’t want their pizza to cold. Worst experience ever. Won’t be back.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mike Polley

Good food for a good price

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Josh Altman

I eat at this store once or twice a year, when I have time to forget how bad the service was the last time. 🙄
I know what I'm getting at Little Ceasars: mediocre pizza at a pretty good price. I ordered a pretzel crust pizza and wings at 11:25, scheduled for 12:00. I showed up at 12:05 and then waited for my pizza until 12:20, when I received my regular-crust pizza.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Chi Town

I highly recommend people do not go to this location. Made an order for delivery that I never received. Told the cashier my order and I saw that she had the wrong address on file so I gave her my current address. She then wrote the address down and said ok, your order should be there within 15 minutes. Well, they sent my order to the address I asked them not to. Completely ignored the address I gave them. But what gets me upset is not only did I not get my food. But they took my money and didn't refund or make it up. Just stole my money. Be careful with this location. They will rob you....

Service: 1

Earl Robinson

The young lady behind the register was very non helpful not to mention she was also rude . I will never go to that restaurant again not to mention that the app was a waste of a download.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kevin Cobb

I ordered a large sausage pizza that should cost $8.99 but because I asked for it to be well-done (this location often serves under-cocked pizza in my opinion) and extra tomato sauce on the pizza I was charged $10.36 for a custom pizza which I believe is too high for such low quality pizza. I got the pizza home and it was just cheese. The service at this location is also slow, and rude sometimes in my opinion.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Will Hulu

Worst pizza ever. 7 eleven is about the same

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Loading...