Miller Pizza Co

622 S Lake St, Gary
(219) 938-7071

Recent Reviews

Todd Tucker

Great Beef sandwiches and pizza. Has been 22 years since I ate here and it it still good.

Dee Jackson

I visited often pre-pandemic and the whole place had a vibe that made you just want to hang out after work, school, the beach, etc. Great food, good atmosphere and back when the patio was open, you could just sit and enjoy the breeze...and the loud annoying train horn, but hey, you can't always get what you want. About a month ago, I went back again for the first time in three years. I ordered to go, but it was STILL the same; great food, good atmosphere, and nice workers. I LOVE THIS PLACE...lol!!!

Andrea Green

I just found out today I was on the do not deliver list 05/11/2022. I ordered food while I was at work and it came 2 1/2 hours later when I was about to get off work. Instead of them telling me they were short staffed on delivery drivers. They kept lying saying it was on the way. After about the third call they sent me straight to voicemail. So when they finally came the food was cold and I sent it back. I was a regular customer and never had any other issues until that day. Then today when I asked why I was banned they put me on hold and never came back to the call. This is the reason local businesses get bad reviews because of employees that don't care about good customer service. Times have really changed

Nick D.

If you've never had Miller's, you're missing out. As a steelworker, we get their pizza quite often and it never disappoints. Highly recommend!!

Bridgette Collins-George

Miller Pizza has always been good but what stood out was the customer service. They were courteous, attentive and helpful. The night we went, we had gon to 2 other restaurants and left because we were seated and no one ever came to acknowledge us in any way. Despite not having servers we still received better service than the places with it. Thank you for the hospitality, hot pizza and amazing Antipasto Salad.

Richard Ramos

We ordered a large deep dish earlier this afternoon. It has been a few years since I've had a deep dish from Millers. They are not what they used to be. Was crust than an actual deep dish. We were not all that impressed.

Max Lenzen

I came in with my family tonight and we got a deep dish pizza and two dishes of wings, I didn’t have any pizza as it’s not my cup of tea but they were by far the best wings I’ve ever had in my life. They were crunchy and balanced, with a good atmosphere and nice workers, I can’t think of a single negative about this restaurant

Mary Munez

The food was really great and hit the spot. We are here for work and wanted to get lunch locally. We didn’t want to get anything that felt too fried since we were working for many more hours after. I ordered a lunch special (multiple slices of pizza and a drink) I saw if and thought I’d maybe feel bloated cuz of the size. But felt just fine since the dough was super high quality and the pizza was not at all greasy. The staff was really nice and professional, the store and restrooms were clean and there was parking in the back. Food was prompt and served hot. Prices were normal. It was a great choice for us passing through!

genious00

Not often we buy from here last time was a year or so ago which was pretty good. Maybe they had an off night this time. Delivery takes a bit long which is understandable, but the pizza was cold when we got it. Although it looked delicious we proceeded to take the first bite and the bottom crust was very doughy (undone). Very disappointing for the almost 50$ we paid including Delivery and tip. The driver had a mask which was cool I guess. But it'll probably be another long while before we order from here. Or maybe should try the thin crust instead of the deep dish

Marie C

I'm really dumbfounded at all these good reviews! I've given them 3 tries in the last 6 years and my family would rather eat a frozen Home Run Inn pizza than one of theirs. Their pizza is horrible! The sauce is terrible and the crust taste like flour. I've lived in New York and Chicago and both of those cities know how to make pizzas! Miller Pizza does not! We have also tried their Italian beefs. Do yourself a favor and make your own at home. Buano sells good frozen ones. When I ordered the Italian beefs I told them I wanted them dipped. They weren't dipped. They were dry as a desert and the meat was bland. I can't afford to waste food but all 3 times I've ordered from them we threw our food away! Three strikes are all they will get from my household! I will never go there again. I've also found out from 5 long time residential families around me that they don't eat there either.

Sharon L.

Great pizza and friendly people!!!!!! I love the sauce it is rich and tasty!!!!!!!!!!!!

SharCarre Celeste

Long Time Miller Pizza Customer, although the prices are astronomically more expensive, the pizza is generally still of quality. I treat myself to a thin crust pepperoni and mushroom pizza every so often. While I love the traditional deep crust, the thin crust also has won over my heart!

GoldenRose19

My family and I really enjoyed their pizza. It was one of the best pizzas I have had in a long time. I recommend this place, you won’t be disappointed. You order at the counter and there is limited seating if you need to dine in. The staff is also very friendly!

Daniel J.

Good pizza but order ahead. Long wait otherwise. Always crowded. Not a fan of its location as parking sucks and some of the people outside seem sketchy.

JP Tan

Wouldn’t accept my temporary Illinois drivers license. It’s just bad business and garbage management. My Italian sausage was cold too. Don’t come here.

Load More