Domino's Pizza

905 1/2, W Pike St, Goshen
(574) 349-9340

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dominic Hofer

Nothing much to say other than its domino’s pizza. Haven’t had issues with the pizza itself and haven’t had any incorrect orders yet. The inside just feels depressing compared to any other pizza place I’ve been to.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

mary collins

Customer service was great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kirk Miller

I don't know why my GF decided to pick one of these up. Absolute garbage. The cheapest of the cheap frozen pizzas are better than this flavorless nonsense. It got even worse cold. Feeding to my dogs. At least they lick their own ass, so this is comparable.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Spend’n \u0026 Eat’n Living Da Life

I prefer real Italian pizza, but my favorite was closed and it was raining so I decided to order pizza from here. I went in about 1 month ago to pick up, I watched them rush the food out the oven, the ladies that worked there have zero patience. I don’t understand why people work in an environment where they will deal with the public and not have patience. Why don’t you find a job where you don’t have to fake care. My pizza that day was 8/10 only because I watched them make it. 5/16/25 we used a coupon to order pizza, I tried the pan pizza, and it was nasty 0/10. Pan pizza is supposed to imitate the pan, with either a thicker crust and burnt edges, this pizza wasn’t a pan pizza. It was an excess amount of cheese, which I did pay for extra cheese, but the 2 toppings I ordered on the pizza, you literally could count the sausage and the mushrooms. My pizza wasn’t made with care, but rushed. It wasn’t even cooked done. The wings here are mushy they -do -not -get crispy at all. The wings are undercooked and not done, called the store to complain about the chicken wings because chicken has to be cooked done or you can get sick. The manager basically spoke highly of why the wings are soft and mushy and the only way to get them crispy is running them through the oven twice, well why didn’t you just do that? I mean you have to be a special kind of dumb to know the wings aren’t cooked correctly and still not do it. So they much rather get a high off ppl calling and complaining & if you love their wings, you most definitely can’t cook. Anyway I see why they have “pizza insurance” take advantage of the offer, I will. Also go inside to get your pizza, when you’re not watching them make your pizza, that’s when they don’t care. Quality control should be number 1-3, they don’t look at the food and go that should go back inside longer or this doesn’t look good, they are like robots and just follow the directions. Any job you work, you have to do more, you don’t do less, and this here pizza restaurant does the least. Do I hate the chain? No! I actually never ate Dominoes Pizza until I ate it in Montana and it was very tasty and cooked right, so yes Dominoes have good pizza, it just has to be made right and with care. This one here in Goshen, the ratings is 3.2 on Google, that’s a low score for a place of business that cooks food, and that low score is because they don’t care. So I’m definitely taking advantage of “pizza insurance” basically a free replacement pizza, go inside to watch them make it, and will not order anything else from this particular location. The employees know nothing about making good pizza here.

Food: 1

Sabrina Estel

Was good. We will get again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chino Alvarado

The pizza was good and the sandwiches needed a little more meat other then that it was ok ...but my wings that was terrible they where so little looks like they got it off a baby chick.. they need better wings

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Edwin McMillan

Disgusting.

Ordered 2 pizzas, and garlic knots. Got parmesan knots, and one of the two pizzas that we received looked like it was scrap dough with no sauce or cheese and had sat outside the kitchen for three hours before it was microwaved and put in a box for delivery.

For $50, I'd have at least expected to be insulted to my face, rather than to have this culinary affront left on my doorstep.

Won't buy from them ever again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sydney Penner

not sure why people are giving bad reviews. i’ve frequented this dominos since it opened a couple years ago. i don’t think i’ve ever had a bad experience. a few times they’ll forget to square cut my pizza, but that’s about it! it’s always fresh, fast, and made exactly the way i want it. not proud to admit it but i honestly go here at least once every two weeks, if not once a week. they’ve NEVER missed i swear.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melody Miller

Food is amazing

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Custom Medium 2-Topping 12 Pizza

todd schrock

I took advantage of the 9.99 special and had 2 pizzas cooked perfectly and topped plentifully to all my specifications. I was promptly greeted and my take out order rang up when I arrived.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shanita Johnson

I have to say I was pretty disappointed in our pizzas we ordered 3 pizza Saturday night , one was free and the other two were on a special for $9.99. The pizzas were overcooked. It's like there was hardly any toppings on it. At first I thought maybe because they run specials they didn't put much thought into it but I ordered from them a couple of times before this and the pizzas were on specials and they were absolutely delicious that's what piqued my interest in Domino's again so, I was just disappointed.

apples3301

The people were very friendly

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Sweet Mango Habanero Wings

Ricky Shelton

Easy experience, everyone was polite, ad well as friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

RyD'79

I was almost ran off the road by a Domino's driver in Goshen, Indiana and last time I ordered pizza from them it was cold and stale.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

alan simmons

Hear me out……. I call to check address to get food delievered and I’m told they don’t come here mind Pizza Hut is farther but they will deliever there greesy pizza they need to widen out there deliveries y area

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...